Townhomes for Sale in Barnum Island, NY

Barnum Island, a South Shore hamlet, is known for its quiet community and strong fishing culture. Located just 2 miles from the beach, residents enjoy boating and fishing in the Western Bays, with private docks providing access to Shell Harbor and Shell Creek. Shell Creek Park offers athletic courts, a playground, and a splash park, while the nearby Island Park Little League fields host local games. Homes range from prewar Cape Cods and colonials to ranch-style and split-level homes built through the 1960s, with waterfront properties offering scenic views. The Yacht Club, a gated community, features townhouses with waterfront access. Local schools, including Francis X. Hegarty Elementary, Lincoln Orens Middle School, and Long Beach High School, are highly rated, with the high school’s choir earning accolades. Austin Boulevard is the main commercial strip, featuring dining options like Jimmy Hays Steak House, Ananau Peruvian Cuisine, and Moo Burger, as well as Jordan Lobster Farms for fresh seafood. The Island Park LIRR Station provides a 50-minute commute to Penn Station, while JFK Airport is 11 miles away. Despite the charm, residents must consider flood risks and insurance due to the bayfront location.