Homes for Rent in Coldwater, OH

Surrounded by fields of corn, soybeans and wheat, Coldwater is home to roughly 5,000 people in the heart of Mercer County. Faith and family are closely held values for many residents. The cross-tipped Holy Trinity Catholic Church has served the area since 1899 and continues to symbolize the village’s strong German heritage. “I talk about pride in Coldwater a lot because everybody has a sense of pride for how they represent themselves, their homes and their families,” says Mayor Doug Bertke, a Coldwater native. “Farming has always been a part of life here. It’s never ended and it never will, and that’s where we get our work ethic.” Many homebuyers choose Coldwater for its stellar school system and deep family connections. “Even if young people move away for jobs or new experiences, it's very common for them to move back to be closer to family or look after elderly family,” says Sarah Klosterman, a local Realtor with Howard Hanna Realtors. Coldwater Exempted Village Schools receive an overall A grade from Niche while being ranked the best school district in Mercer County. “We’re big with the athletics and have many, many state championships. We just had three during the 2024-2025