Harbor Isle, NY Homes for Rent

Harbor Isle is a secluded bayside neighborhood known for its privacy and boating culture. Accessible only by two bridges, it offers a tranquil lifestyle with residents often kayaking around the island or relaxing on backyard docks overlooking the salt marshes. The area features single-family homes, including Cape Cod, ranch-style, and split-levels, with prices ranging from $600,000 to $1.3 million depending on proximity to waterways. Harbor Isle boasts a lower crime risk compared to the national average, enhancing its appeal for families. Children attend highly rated schools such as Francis X. Hegarty Elementary School, Lincoln Orens Middle School, and Long Beach High School. The neighborhood’s features include the BoatHouse Harbor Isle Marina, which hosts community events and offers a sandy beach for relaxation. Nearby Island Park provides additional recreational opportunities, including Little League fields and the Panaghia Greek Orthodox Church Spring Fest. For dining and shopping, residents head to Barnum Island for local favorites like Jimmy Hays Steak House and Jordan Lobster Farms, or travel a few miles to Oceanside and Long Beach for more options. Harbor Isle is conveniently located 13 miles from JFK Airport and 5 miles from Mount Sinai South Nassau Hospital, with a 50-minute train ride to Penn Station from the Island Park LIRR Station. Flood insurance is recommended due to occasional flooding from extreme weather events.