$927,366Average Value$516Average Price per Sq Ft24Homes For Sale
Historic town with old-fashioned main street and NYC access
Families, young professionals, retirees and second-home buyers all move to Atlantic Highlands for its proximity to the beach, quaint town and easy access to NYC. Susan Natale, an experienced agent with Coldwell Banker, raised her family nearby. “First Avenue could be from 'Back to the Future,'” she says about the town’s old-fashioned main street, adding how the entire town reflects an “everyone knows everybody” vibe.
About 4,400 residents live in this Monmouth County enclave, a year-round community that gathers for the annual July 4th fireworks and fair, Halloween parade, Easter egg hunt, film fests and weekend farmer’s market.
Housing can be found at all price points, from historic Victorians in the hills to water view condos. Sandy Hook, a six-mile beach stretch that’s part of a protected national park, is just minutes away.
Seastreak Ferry leaves from Atlantic Highlands for an easy commute to New York City.
Atlantic Highlands uniquely old fashioned Main Street is a picturesque look.
1/2
National Park beaches and extensive rail trail
Beaches are among the main attractions for residents. There’s a tiny beach in town at the end of First Avenue, but many locals join private beach clubs in nearby Sea Bright. Sandy Hook also offers seasonal beach passes. This pristine section is reached via a short bridge and sectioned off into numerous beaches, each with its own lot and vibe. For example, the beach at Lot C rents kayaks, while Gunnison Beach is known for nude sunbathing. There's also the 8.7-mile Sandy Hook Pathway, popular for biking and running. Nearby, The Henry Hudson Trail rivals the beach in popularity, a 24-mile paved pathway that begins in the Atlantic Highlands and follows former railroad tracks past wetlands and streams.
Snug Harbor Beach moments from Atlantic Highlands is empty in March but will be packed soon.
Atlantic Highlands hosts the Rail Trail for hikers and all outdoors fans.
1/2
Victorians, hills and water views
Streets wind up hills overlooking New York Bay and the NYC skyline, climbing all the way up to the East Coast’s highest point on Mount Mitchill. Some sections are heavily wooded while others are lined with sidewalks, conducive for exercising outdoors. Atlantic Highlands is synonymous with Victorians, and many of these are perched in the hills; historic Victorians are coveted but rarely come on the market. Ocean Boulevard also weaves up into the hills and is populated with multimillion-dollar homes, but Natale estimates water views start around a million. The average home value is $790,000.
Condos start in the $200,000s and a starter home can be found for around $600,000. New construction has been popping up and starts around $2 million. Prices generally span $235,000 to $4 million.
Atlantic Highlands has numerous Victorian homes overlooking the water.
Water views abound in Atlantic Highlands creating picturesque views.
1/2
Year-round arts and culture
In addition to the many community events, the Atlantic Highlands Arts Council holds year-round programming, like a wine-tasting fundraiser to help provide free summer programs for kids. First Avenue Playhouse is a community theater that offers dessert and a show, and Smodcastle Cinemas is a small, independent movie theater recently acquired by Kevin Smith of "Clerks" fame. It recently launched an annual film festival too.
Smodcastle Cinemas in Atlantic Highlands hosts Hollywood movies and special events.
Atlantic Highlands First Avenue Playhouse features a desert theatre in an intimate setting.
1/2
Cute main street and outdoor dining
First Avenue is Atlantic Highland’s main street, an inland stretch populated with American flags and local shops that terminates at On the Deck. This community hangout next to the Seastreak Ferry is beloved for its fresh seafood and live music, and sunset views of the bay and skyline don’t hurt either. Nicholas Creamery draws summer crowds for small-batch ice cream and rotating flavors. Renaissance Emporium hosts multiple vintage and antique vendors under one roof. Foodtown is convenient for groceries, and additional supermarkets and big box chains are 15 minutes away in Middletown.
Many restaurants downtown Atlantic Highlands have outdoor seating for the nicer weather.
Downtown Atlantic Highlands has a Rockwell picturesque look.
1/2
Strong schools with close-knit community
Public school students attend Atlantic Highlands Elementary School from pre-kindergarten through sixth grade, which scores an eight out of 10 from Great Schools. Students continue on to Henry Hudson Regional School for grades seven through 12, with an average eight-to-one student/teacher ratio and a B-plus rating from Niche.
The schools in Atlantic Highlands help to tie the town together.
Atlantic Highlands schools are a strong part of the fiber of the community.
1/2
Commuter ferries right in town
NYC commuters have the option to take the Seastreak Ferry to either Pier 11/Wall Street in about 40 minutes or to East 35th Street in about an hour. Service is most frequent during the rush hour commute. Another option is driving 20 minutes to catch the New Jersey Transit train from Middletown station, getting to the city in about 1 hour and 15 minutes. And boaters have the option to park their boats at Atlantic Highlands Municipal Marina.
Ferries to New York City are within walking distance from downtown Atlantic Highlands.
The Seastreak Ferry leaves from Atlantic Highlands to New York on a regular basis.
1/2
Areas of Atlantic Highlands is in a flood zone.
Flooding is a factor
Pockets of town are in a flood zone and were deeply impacted by Superstorm Sandy in 2012. The community has since rebuilt, but the site Risk Factor lists 277 homes at major risk of flooding within the next 30 years.
Written By
Christina Norwood
Video By
GL Moses
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Ryan Brown,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Atlantic Highlands, NJ sell after 27 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Atlantic Highlands, NJ over the last 12 months is $738,500, up 4% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Discover an extraordinary living opportunity in the heart of downtown Atlantic Highlands. This 3 family home that was once a thriving church has been transformed into 3 amazing living spaces. The main church with all its preserved character boasts an open floor plan with a sleeping loft; the 2nd unit has 2 BR's and 1.5 baths, the 3rd unit boasts 4 BR's and 2.5 baths; The thoughtful detail in each
New construction located just off First Ave in the heart of Downtown Atlantic Highlands, with an estimated Spring/Early Summer 2026 move-in! The Hampshire offers 3,308 sq ft with 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a spacious loft, finished basement, and 2-car garage. A formal dining room leads to an open-concept living area with fireplace and a gourmet kitchen featuring a quartz island, double wall oven,
Linda KirkD. R . Horton Realty of Atlantic County LLC
This Hampshire by D.R. Horton is a stunning new construction home plan featuring 3,230 square feet of living space, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a large loft area and a 2-car garage. The Hampshire is popular for a reason! As you’re welcomed into the home, you’re greeted by the spacious formal dining room, the perfect space to entertain your guests on those special occasions. The foyer opens up to a
Quiet coastal living on a private cul de sac, moments from the beach. This two bedroom, one bath home offers a flexible plan with the second bedroom currently used as a sunroom that opens to the backyard. A basement bonus room works for an office or extra storage. Note that the basement ceiling is low. Enjoy a fully fenced, pet friendly yard with a patio and power, a low maintenance stone front
Renovated 1st floor unit ! Granite kitchen counters, Newer appliances, and private quiet patio with view of the woods. Large living room with tons of closet space throughout. In-unit Washer/Dryer combo is what separates this unit from the rest. Less then 5 minute drive to Seastreak Atlantic Highlands. Heat and water included in rent. Available for quick move-in for qualified applicant.
A spacious 2 bedroom - 1.5 bath one-of-a-kind rental in Atlantic Highlands is ready for you. This amazing space boasts an open concept living area/dining area with a chef's kitchen, a wine refrigerator plus a center island with seating for four. Just steps away from downtown shops, restaurants, and the Seastreak Ferry, commuting to NYC for work or play has never been easier. Discover a rental
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
