$910,110Average Value$489Average Price per Sq Ft7Homes For Sale
Mystic blends small-town living with tourist attractions
Mystic is a coastal Connecticut village known for its historic architecture, walkable downtown and relaxed lifestyle. Located where the Mystic River meets the Fishers Island Sound, the area is a tourist destination that draws big summer crowds. Tourism helps provide jobs for residents, and the nearby town of Groton is a submarine manufacturing hub. The homes here vary widely, from historic homes downtown to townhouses nearby. The top-rated Stonington Public Schools help attract year-round residents to the area.
Locals in Mystic enjoy a great selection of Italian restaurants, including favorites like Anthony J's, with Anthony J's standing out as a local favorite.
From above, Mystic comes to life with the iconic Mystic River Bascule Bridge at its center, surrounded by charming streets and popular tourist attractions.
1/2
What you can expect to pay for a home in Mystic
The median home sale price in Mystic is in the mid-$700,000s, lower than Stonington ’s overall median but higher than the nearby community of West Mystic. “Everybody wants to live in downtown Mystic until they see the price tags,” says Bridget Morrissey, a broker at Bridget Morrissey Realty who has lived in the area for over 30 years, “but there are a lot of areas priced in the $400,000s and $500,000s where you could still walk downtown.”
Prices vary widely depending on location, size and acreage:
Most single-family houses range from the upper $400,000s to the mid-$800,000s.
Homes over 3,000 square feet or on several acres can range from the lower $900,000s to around $3 million.
Condos and townhouses generally cost between the upper $300,000s and the upper $800,000s, though waterfront and luxury units can go for more.
Mystic’s single family Colonial Revival homes provide ample living space, combining classic design with comfortable, family friendly layouts.
Townhouse condos in Mystic offer a perfect blend of comfort and functionality, ideal for those seeking a vibrant, connected lifestyle.
1/2
Housing styles range from historic homes to modern builds
There’s a wide variety of housing styles and sizes in Mystic, including modest bungalows, spacious estates and townhouse-style condos. “You have anything from houses built in the 1700s to houses built in 2026,” Morrissey says. “It’s a very, very desirable area.” Colonial Revival, Italianate and Queen Anne designs are common in the downtown area, while split-level, ranch-style and Cape Cod homes are more common nearby. You can find townhouse-style condos throughout the community, most of which were built in the 1980s.
Ranch style homes blend simplicity and comfort, with single level layouts that make everyday living easy and inviting in Mystic.
1/2
Stonington Public Schools get strong ratings
Kids can attend the top-rated Stonington Public Schools district, which has two elementary schools and one middle school, all of which receive top ratings. Stonington High School is highly rated and has been recognized by the AP School Honor Roll for its access to Advanced Placement courses. Students here are required to complete a senior project where they work with a community mentor and complete fieldwork on a topic.
Deans Mill School develops strong character and creative skills among it's students.
Stonington High School sits on a wide open campus with several athletic fields.
1/2
The pros and cons of living in Mystic
Charming New England architecture, water recreation, and top-rated schools are a few of the things that draw people to Mystic and make them want to stay. “I don’t want to live anywhere else,” Morrissey says. “One of the nice things about being in real estate is you get to drive around the area every day, and it’s just a pretty area.” Amy Swan, a Realtor with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices New England who lives in the area, says, “I love the simplicity of it. … It’s just a very easy lifestyle.”
Morrisey says that traffic, especially during tourist season, is one of the biggest drawbacks of living here, and most of it is caused by the drawbridge that connects to Mystic’s Groton side. “It goes up every 40 minutes after the hour every day in the summer, and that makes big traffic jams.” The bridge’s summer schedule lasts from May through October, and it operates on demand in other months.
A local strolls with his dog through downtown Mystic, passing signposts that guide visitors to the town’s various attractions.
From above, the Mystic YMCA provides residents with top notch recreational facilities and programs, all just minutes from Williams Beach Park, where they can relax and enjoy beautiful water vistas.
1/2
Tourism and submarine manufacturing provide jobs
Tourism is a huge part of Mystic’s economy, with the village’s restaurants, museums and scenic downtown area attracting visitors and employing residents. Groton, which is around 9 miles away, is known for its submarine industry and is near large employers like General Dynamics Electric Boat and Naval Submarine Base New London.
A massive ship anchor on display in Mystic stands as a striking maritime landmark, celebrating the town’s rich nautical history.
Locals in Mystic enjoy a great selection of Italian restaurants, including favorites like Anthony J's, with Anthony J's standing out as a local favorite.
1/2
Award-winning restaurants and a waterfront downtown
Downtown Mystic spans Main Street on both sides of the Mystic River. Most stores are on the Groton side of the village, and there are popular restaurants on the Stonington side, including:
The Shipwright’s Daughter, which was named one of the New York Times’ best restaurants in 2024 and is helmed by a James Beard Award-winning chef
S&P Oyster Restaurant and Bar, which overlooks the water and serves a blend of New England and South American cuisine
Bravo Bravo, an Italian restaurant that makes all its pasta in-house
For groceries, you can head to Big Y or McQuade’s Marketplace nearby. The Olde Mistick Village near Interstate 95 is an outdoor mall with locally owned shops, restaurants and a movie theater.
Shipwright's Daughter offers a cozy, nautical inspired dining experience in the heart of Mystic, serving fresh seafood and locally inspired dishes.
At Highliner Seafood, visitors can shop for a fantastic selection of fresh seafood, perfect for creating delicious meals at home or enjoying the local flavors of Mystic.
1/2
Outdoor activities include boating and beach trips
The Mystic River and Fishers Island Sound are popular for boating. There are several marinas in the village, including Seaport Marine and Gwenmor Marina. The Ocean Community YMCA is a popular gym near Williams Beach Park, the village’s only public beach. For ocean swimming, Swan says people usually head to Watch Hill or Misquamicut in Westerly, which is also where the closest hospital is. The Mystic Seaport Museum is a big attraction for the area, offering classes and featuring exhibitions about maritime history. The Mystic Aquarium, which has beluga whales, is nearby.
Visitors and boaters alike flock to Mystic Point Marina in Mystic to enjoy scenic docks, nautical charm, and a peaceful harbor setting.
Williams Beach Park offers a relaxing waterfront escape in Mystic, where visitors can enjoy sandy shores, scenic views, and outdoor recreation.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Mystic neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Mystic
US
Homicide
1
4
Sexual Assault
1
4
Assault with Weapon
1
4
Robbery
1
4
Burglary
4
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
4
4
Larceny
2
4
Crime Score
3
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Mystic Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Mystic, Stonington sell after 43 days on the market compared to the national average of 58 days. The median sale price for homes in Mystic, Stonington over the last 12 months is $722,500, up 5% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Light, bright 2BR, 2BA condo with spectacular views of Mystic Harbor and out to Fishers Island Sound. Adjacent to marina and easy walking distance to Mystic's shops and restaurants, yet out of the busy flow of downtown traffic. Quiet elevator building. Location, location, location!
Original small house built in 1920, added a post and beam wing in 2000-2002. Very charming with Peony tree gardens, large deck with awning, lots of wood work and beams inside. A must see. A nice walk to downtown Mystic restaurants, shops and waterfront. There is a full basement with on-grade full height doors; a very large Jotul wood stove with duct work to provide auxiliary heat for first floor.
Located steps to Downtown Mystic!!! Thoughtfully updated and ideally located, 16 School Street presents a refined blend of comfort, character, and effortless coastal living in the heart of Mystic. This well appointed residence offers three bedrooms and one and a half baths, with a layout designed for both everyday living and relaxed entertaining. Recent improvements enhance the home's
CUSTOM HOME TO BE BUILT - New Construction in Masons Estates! A 4-bedroom Newport Style Coastal Home in one of Mason's Island's premier gated communities on a 1.13-acre lot! This exceptional colonial blend timeless architecture with modern luxury, offering an expansive Great Room design ideal for elegant living. Upon entry, this wonderful home will feature a quaint covered porch that leads to the
Unobstructed Water Views! Welcome to a rare offering in the Heart Of Downtown Mystic where timeless New England charm meets coveted waterfront living. Relax and unwind on your magical Front Porch and watch the boats sail by with unobstructed water views of The Mystic River and The Mystic Seaport Museum. This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence is nestled on .30 acres with
Exceptional investment opportunity featuring THREE income-producing multi-family properties offered together as a premier portfolio package. Comprised of SIX total residential units-two distinct units per building-this rare offering presents robust cash flow, maximum flexibility, and undeniable long-term value for seasoned and aspiring investors alike. Location is everything, and this portfolio
Set on a gentle promontory, this rare waterfront property features 1.18 acres of level, cleared land on one of Stonington's most picturesque streets. The property offers a superior high vantage building site anchored by original stone walls and mature trees, complete with a two-story barn and Brazilian walnut dock. With 372 feet of direct frontage on the protected waters of Quiambaug Cove, the
A turn-key investment opportunity in the heart of Mystic. This completely updated multi-unit building blends coastal sophistication with a high-yield asset model, making it a true trophy property for your portfolio. In the LS-5 zone, it is positioned perfectly for an owner occupier on the second floor with rental units for the modern traveler on the first level. Or, use all units as long-term
An exceptional waterfront lot offering the rare opportunity to own almost 1 acre of level coastal property in prime Stonington. Historic stone walls and mature trees frame sweeping views of the serene waterfront of Quiambaug Cove. 225 feet of frontage on the cove provides access to the deep waters of Fishers Island Sound. Equally positioned between the vibrant, close by amenities of downtown
Nestled in a prime location, this pre-existing, non-conforming lot offers the perfect blend of convenience and tranquility. Surrounded on three sides by the serene Avalonia Land Conservancy, yet just minutes from the vibrant heart of Downtown Mystic, you'll enjoy easy access to renowned restaurants, boutique shops, and train services connecting to New York and Boston. Nearby attractions include
Perched high above the shoreline with breathtaking panoramic views of Fishers Island Sound and Long Island Sound, this exceptional custom-built 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence offers over 3,400 square feet of beautifully renovated coastal living on 0.88 manicured acres in one of Mystic's most desirable waterfront settings. Designed to capture magnificent sunsets and ever-changing water views, this
Stately Mystic Residence in Premier Live-Work Zone Perfectly positioned in the heart of Historic Downtown Mystic, this grand 4,259 sq ft residence offers a rare opportunity to own a stately 4-bedroom, 4 full and 2 half bath property on a professionally landscaped corner lot. Nestled on a level 0.25-acre parcel in the coveted LS-5 Zone, this unique offering allows for a flexible Live-Work
Updated 1500 sq. ft. 2 bedroom apartment located 1 block from the Mystic Train Station. Walk into downtown in just 2 minutes and enjoy all the great restaurants, shopping and parks! Large eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a walk-in pantry, spacious living room, 1 full bath and 2 large bedrooms will make this apartment a comfortable place to call home. Washer and dryer in the
Two bedroom one full bath second floor apartment located in Downtown Mystic. Apartment is complete with hardwood flooring, nice size kitchen and includes a washer and dryer in the unit. Additional room offers comfortable living space. Enjoy views of the Mystic River from the private balcony/deck space. Heat and hot water are included. One parking pass for parking lot is included with the lease.
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
