Aaron Weber

8/22/25Mg Kim

Google Review

Aaron did a great job in selling my condo in Madison, Wisconsin. From the very beginning, taking photos and videos even while my tenant was still living in my condo, to showing it to prospective buyers, to receive a very good offer, helping negotiate the price, to all the way to the closing. We found the buyer within days of listing my property. I sold it very quickly without any repair work, and at a very reasonable price. I live out of state but I did not even have to visit my property to sell it. I will not hesitate to recommend Aaron as the best real estate broker in Madison Wisconsin. Thank you Aaron.

6/20/25Brett M. Cooper

Google Review

I strongly recommend Aaron. A great combo of excellent customer service and effective real estate prowess.

Over the last 4 years, he helped me both buy and sell a condo. Each time the transaction went smoothly, with quick closings both times and no challenges.

Aaron demonstrated excellent customer service from the start. When I first moved to Madison, I contacted many realtors, knowing that I'd eventually be looking to buy. Other realtors said "call me when you're ready," but Aaron took a different approach...he said "Let me drive you around town and get you acquainted with Madison." He then proceeded to drive me all around town, showing me a ton about Madison that I would not have known about. It was SO helpful to me, and he did this with zero guarantee that I was actually going to buy anything.

That "customer first" attitude sold me on Aaron, so when I was ready to buy, and then again to sell, there was only one person I was going to call!

6/19/25Chris Bauch

Google Review

We had a wonderful experience working with Faye Clasen to purchase our first home. She was very interested in learning our wants and needs, always gave honest assessments of the homes we viewed and was never pushy. She was very flexible and always open to providing help, doing viewings and answering questions. She made buying our first home very easy and I would work with her again in a heartbeat.

6/18/25Cassandra Kendall

Google Review

Faye was the perfect realtor for us. She offered great insight and adjusted to our needs as buyers tremendously. She really made the process of finding the right house a fun journey. Additionally, she was able to help with additional resources that assisted our move!

6/10/25Courtney Miller

Google Review

Aaron was a phenomenal agent to work with! My husband and I were trying to purchase a house in Wisconsin from several states over and Aaron made it happen. He set up virtual showings and did some great negotiating to get us under contract for the perfect home. He made the entire process as easy and stress free as home buying can be.

6/6/25Megan Bergner

Google Review

Kyle was a delight to work with from the moment we met! He was patient and super duper helpful with the millions of questions I had. I have already recommended him to friends, and even though I don't plan on moving again for a long while, he will be the first I reach out to when that happens. Thank you Kyyyyyle!

5/28/25Landon Heming

Google Review

Words cannot describe how amazing Aaron is! My wife and I were given a very short window to buy a new home in a new state. Aaron quickly turned what I expected to be a nightmare into an easy and enjoyable experience. His expertise and virtual tours were a lifesaver and even allowed us to close on our new home with time to spare! I cannot recommend Aaron and his team enough, they truly went above and beyond in every aspect of the process. Thank you, Aaron!

5/16/25Patrick Johnson

Google Review

Stuck with me through the process and helped me get my home bought!

5/8/25Kristen Cooley

Google Review

Kyle has made the home buying process much less stressful! He is a genuinely honest person that was easy to work with and always accessible to answer my questions.

5/5/25Brittany T

Google Review

Aaron has all the qualities you want in a realtor. He's responsive, efficient, knowledgeable, connected, and a man of his word. Our experience with buying and selling our home was so smooth, we're still in disbelief about how well it went. We couldn't have asked for a better realtor. Thank you!

4/28/25Andrew

Google Review

I really enjoyed working with Michael Paumen. It was my first time buying a home and I was a little bit clueless and awkward on most of the details. In spite of my awkwardness Michael was able to guide me through the process to help me figure everything out, and find the home that was perfect for me.

3/8/25Kyle Kaul

Google Review

Ryan Dahl was an incredible realtor. From his prompt communications, to his vast knowledge about different options for getting us into a home. Ryan always went above and beyond including taking the pressure out the home buying process. He advocated for us and I would highly recommend him to anyone whether it’s your first time buying or looking for a specific forever home!

3/7/25Sydney “Syd” Woodruff

Google Review

Mike P was a fantastic realtor! He worked with my schedule, guided me through the process clearly, assisted me in selling and buying (at the same time!) it’s been such a pleasure. He made sure closing date was perfect for life. I was so impressed with how he presented my home for sale and how well he communicated the process steps.

Highly recommend!

1/8/25Rachel Lacy

Google Review

Aaron was a wonderful asset in us selling our condo in downtown Madison. He utilized all the resources to ensure our condo had wide viewership to increase our potential buyers. We always felt in the loop from a communication style and knew Aaron was doing everything he could to get our place sold at the highest dollar. We couldn't recommend him more!

12/22/24Victor Vega

Google Review

Aaron's outstanding communication skills transformed our interactions, setting a new standard of excellence. As we concluded our home search, we had the pleasure of meeting Aaron, who provided a thorough explanation of the process, expertly navigating us through each step. His prompt responses to our queries, regardless of the time, gave us complete peace of mind. We highly recommend Aaron for his exceptional service, which embodies the perfect blend of professionalism and personalized attention.

10/7/24John DeShazer

Google Review

Outstanding Realtor Experience with John Stanislawski.

We had the pleasure of working with John Stanislawski when relocating to Middleton, Wisconsin, from out of state, and we couldn't be more grateful for his dedication and expertise. From the very beginning, John went above and beyond to accommodate our needs, even conducting virtual tours to help us navigate the housing market remotely.

John's knowledge of the area and his network of local professionals made the entire process seamless. He connected us with all the service providers we needed to make our house truly feel like home. Despite our countless questions, John always remained patient, friendly, and quick to respond, ensuring that we felt supported every step of the way.

If you're looking for a realtor who is reliable, knowledgeable, and committed to your best interests, we highly recommend John Stanislawski. His professionalism and positive attitude made a world of difference for us, and we are thrilled with our new home thanks to his efforts.

8/15/24Christina M

Google Review

Michael Paumen is the best ☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆. Not only is he a great Real Estate Agent he's like family. If he wouldn't put his own family in that home you can trust he wouldn't set you up for failure either. Extremely knowledgeable, professional, caring, dependable, & pretty funny. It's been an honor to work with him my family bought our first home July of 2024. I'm honored to call him my Agent, friend & family. Michael truly cares about his clients and is so patient with questions and being informative when it comes to buying a home.

8/8/24Douglas Alan Pearce

Google Review

Aaron explains everything. He's patient when needed and very experienced. He looked out for us, which is important because we didn't know the area, local laws, or some of the most important things to look for, even before you get a home inspection. And he has a good sense of humor, which is the best way to deal with the stress of home shopping and moving.

7/13/24Megan Bobolz

Google Review

Great experience! Highly recommend!

7/5/24luke spencer

Google Review

Kyle Wahlgren was a fantastic agent! We could not see the house in person, so he went above and beyond to make sure we got multiple views and virtual tours of the house. He also helped us understand how the house price measured up to the area and helped us negotiate. Highly recommend!

7/4/24Carrie Booher

Google Review

Aaron is fantastic! He knows the market, and he was not only informative, but he quickly figured out what was important to us and helped us through a search to find the right house. He was patient, funny, and super responsive. We highly recommend!

6/20/24Nolan Lendved

Google Review

Aaron proved to be an excellent agent for us, finding us a great home in a difficult market from 800+ miles away. He and his team were so amazingly helpful and personable, making an inherently stressful process as easy and pleasant as possible every step of the way, from our initial criteria and search right through closing and moving in. As first-time homebuyers, we especially appreciated Aaron's helpful explanations, attention to detail, and highly personalized service and recommendations. When unexpected issues arose after an accepted offer, Aaron went above and beyond to make sure things worked out in the most advantageous way possible. I would not hesitate to recommend Aaron and his team.

4/21/24Mark Retzlaff

Google Review

This is our second time with Aaron as our realtor. He got us into an amazing house and sold our house for above asking! Aaron’s wealth of knowledge and customer service are top notch. I would highly recommend Aaron and his Team to anyone. Dude is a pro!

4/16/24Jeremiah Miller

Google Review

Greatest realtor ever! So happy with our home. They even have a truck to use! We recommend the Aaron Weber group to anyone that asks for a recommendation for a realtor. Thank you!

12/18/23Heather Splinter

Google Review

Aaron was so much fun to work with! He was so willing to do a home tour any day any time! As a first time home buyer he really pointed out all the pros and cons of each place we saw which made us feel so secure when putting in an offer! After a month he helped us find our first home! He made the process beyond easy and stress free!

11/7/23Chris L

Google Review

Kyle Wahlgren was awesome! Super helpful and very easy to communicate with.

9/8/23Wendy Selck

Google Review

Aaron is wonderful! He went well above and beyond for us to sell our house. We don’t know what we would have done without him. We were on a fairly tight deadline, relocating across country for my job. He was able to get the job done with time to spare! I would HIGHLY recommend Aaron Weber!

9/7/23Dave Z

Google Review

Very quick responses to email only communications. Excellent at problem solving, dealing with unusual situations and simply getting things done. On multiple occasions went way out of his way. Extremely trustworthy as well. A++++

9/5/23Joshua Schultz

Google Review

Michael Paumen was a exactly what you hope for in a realtor - communicative, knowledgeable and persistent. He was a great asset and worked hard to make the process go smoothly and work for us. I unreservedly recommend.

5/12/23Ray

Google Review

Aaron was very helpful throughout my home buying experience. Very informative, and helped me with any questions I had a long the way!

5/8/23Zachary Ascherl

Google Review

Aaron was really amazing to work with. He communicated extremely well. He fought hard to negotiate the price of the home excellently. He really has the pulse of the greater Madison area well understood.

3/11/23Maggie L

Google Review

We sold our condo and bought our new home with Andrew. Working with Andrew was a great experience from the beginning; he was incredibly knowledgeable and most importantly for us, reassuring throughout the process. He was always available to answer questions and really made us feel secure in a process that was highly stressful at times. His sense of humor was appreciated and he went to bat for us every step of the way. We would highly recommend him with no reservations!

3/6/23Adam Nutting

Google Review

Mike did an amazing job helping us purchase our first house! He was extremely informative, knowledgeable, and thorough. Once we zeroed in on the house we wanted he recommend an inspector who was extremely thorough and was there on inspection day telling us exactly what the inspector was looking at and WHY he was looking at it. Not to mention his kind, caring, and energetic personality that made us feel a lot more comfortable with our decision. I would wholeheartedly recommend Mike to anyone who is looking for an honest, transparent, and most importantly thorough realtor. 10/10 will work with Mike on our next investment!

12/24/22Qahtan Abdulsattar

Google Review

I appreciate the opportunity to choose Aaron Weber Group to be a part of my first home purchase journey and would like to specially thank my agent Michael Paumen who was so responsive to any questions or concerns that we had regarding this property and went beyond our expectations, I will definitely continue working with him in the near future for the next home purchase or sale!

12/3/22Devyn Cardella

Google Review

For almost a year we were house hunting and it became a very stressful thing and there were many times we wanted to give up and just felt it would never happen for us, but with the help of Aaron Weber Group and Kyle Wahlgren we are finally in our dream home. Kyle was by our side every second and went above and beyond to make sure we never had to worry about anything and kept us laughing and smiling the whole time. He kept us updated about every detail no matter how small and we couldn't have asked for a better person to help us. Not only was he a fantastic realtor throughout the entire process but we also formed a great friendship! I would highly recommend Kyle and Aaron Weber Group you will not be disappointed.

11/2/22Jennifer Sippel

Google Review

Aaron is fantastic! We have worked with him twice now, and his knowledge and expertise in this industry really shines through! Thanks Aaron!

10/21/22Libby Gutgesell

Google Review

My husband and I purchased our first home this fall with the help of First Weber- specifically Aaron. We are new to the Madison area and weren't sure who to use for our realtor so a coworker recommended Aaron, as he had closed on his first home recently with Aaron's help. We are so happy we picked Aaron.

Being first time buyers with no idea of real estate, having an experienced realtor like Aaron really made things a lot easier. When we started looking for homes, Aaron organized multiple showings a week and worked around our full time work schedules. He is knowledgeable about not only the real estate market but also housing specs/structural things in general so he would give us all of the information about the property that he could and then let us come to our own conclusions. We never felt pressured to make a decision about a house or put in an offer on something.

During the offer process, Aaron helped us craft strong offers but also helped us set boundaries so we would be able to walk away from a property without overspending or making rash decisions. We never felt pressured to spend more than we were comfortable with or rush the process unnecessarily. When we were outbid, he helped keep our morale high and kept finding homes for us to view until we finally found the perfect one.

When our offer was accepted, Aaron kept in close contact with both our lender and the sellers to make sure the entire closing process went smoothly. He was present at all inspections and at the final walkthrough. He kept us calm during close until we finally got keys in hand. He even gave us advice on post-close things like utilities and renovations.

For two people with full time jobs and no real estate knowledge, having an experienced realtor like Aaron made this process a lot less hellish than it could've been. I would absolutely recommend Aaron to anyone.

10/19/22Alecia Mather

Google Review

10/6/22Don Kalinowski

Google Review

I would and have recommend Michael Paumen. He performs his job well above the norm. Michael Is not only an incredible agent but also a great guy. I will use no one else in the future. Add 5 more stars for him 10 would more accurately describe his service.

9/2/22Lixia Qin

Google Review

Kyle was fantastic to work with throughout the whole process. He was always there to answer questions along the way. I was quite nervous about the process of buying our first house. Kyle walked us through step-by-step, made sure I knew what to expect, and offered expert advice that helped me through the negotiations. I would recommend him to anyone.

7/10/22Martin O'Connell

Google Review

Kyle was terrific. He quickly got a sense of what type of property we wanted and found us an excellent fit. Throughout the process he was very professional, responsive to any questions or queries we had, and provided helpful advice about the process. As a result, things went very smoothly, with zero stress. He also helped with complications arising from us being abroad, going above and beyond to ensure everything went to plan. In addition, he’s a top guy. I can’t recommend him strongly enough.

6/17/22Danielle Perry

Google Review

Working with Aaron Weber Group, specifically agent Will Jackson, was a great experience. Will was helpful in both the buying and selling process. Incredibly knowledgable in what to look for when buying a new home! We also really enjoyed the complimentary moving truck. This helped us cut costs during the move which was appreciated. If you're looking for a realtor in the Madison area, I can't say enough praise for Will!

4/15/22Katie Mahoney

Google Review

Aaron was amazing to work with. He was accommodating, very knowledgeable, motivated, and just generally wonderful. Selling our home could not have been easier. He was by far and away the best realtor we have worked with.

4/7/22Younes Nejahi

Google Review

Aaron was amazing. As a first time home buyer we couldn’t be happier. It only took us few days from the time we contacted him to our offer getting accepted. He was professional and knowledgeable. I could feel that he knew if we would like a house even before we set foot in that house. He would prepare and print all the info on the houses we were going to visit. He was responsive and happy to answer to any questions we had. We are definitely going to hire him to sell our house in the future.

2/12/22Sam Skalsky

Google Review

Will was Excellent! We loved working with him and the Aaron Weber Group to find our first home! Will was always very timely in responding to any questions that we had. I would definitely recommend using him if you are looking for a Realitor especially as a first time home buyer!!

12/12/21Jonathan Barrera

Google Review

Michael was simply fantastic -- he helped us every step of the way with buying our first home. When we started the process, we didn't know the first thing about real estate, but Michael was a really great teacher and took the time to explain everything to us in detail. By the end of our home search, we knew exactly what we were looking for in a house and got the perfect house that fit all of our criteria.

He's also just a fun guy. We mentioned we hated squeaky floors, and he made it a point to get to home showings early so he could hop around and judge the squeakiness of the wood floors. That's commitment!

11/12/21Ram Dahal

Google Review

Great experience working with Aaron Weber Group, specially with realtor Aaron. Very responsive and willing to help in every step of home buying from searching home, finding inspector for home inspection, loan process, settlement etc. Overall, I am satisfied with Aaron weber group.

10/1/21Dan Horne

Google Review

Will is a great choice, especially if you are a first time buyer! He is honest during prospective open house walk throughs and will help guide you through the process without pressuring you into decisions. He is readily available for questions and can make things happen even at the last minute.

6/5/21Chris Barrett

Google Review

Aaron is a relentless advocate for your best interests, exactly what you want in a Realtor. He has immense knowledge of south central Wisconsin and you can't go wrong working with him.

5/22/21Neha Gandhi

Google Review

It was a wonderful experience working with Aaron, He is very knowledgable, professional and responsive through out the process. He understood my needs and was able to help me find a perfect home!

5/13/21Kerry Russell

Google Review

Aaron came recommended from my sister and brother-in-law. As a first time home buyer, Aaron was great at answering all my questions and helping me understand my options. I would strongly recommend him to anyone who is looking for a house in this competitive market!

4/6/21Spot

Google Review

A solid experience working with Mike and his team. They were very thorough and paid attention to the fine details. They excelled communicating and explaining any questions or requests that came along with buy and selling my house. This is my second time working Mike and his team. I look forward to working further with them in the future.

1/27/21Yury Bukhman

Google Review

Aaron helped us buy a house. It was a great experience. He understands his client's perspective. He has been very prompt in answering all our questions. He is very resourceful: he was able to provide all necessary documents and information, such as a flood plane map, aerial view of property boundaries, etc. He also referred us to a home inspector and to contractors who helped us renovate the home after the purchase. Aaron also followed up and continued to be helpful after our home purchase was completed. We are impressed with Aaron's skills and expertise and recommend him highly.

1/19/21Sarah Kuech

Google Review

Aaron was easy to work with and very responsive- very knowledgable and helpful guiding me through the process

12/16/20Laura Brue

Google Review

We had the recommendation to go with Aaron Weber from a family member. So we did and Aaron Weber helped us find our first home! He made the process easy and stress free. Aaron listened to us and made sure that our values were represented in the homes that he found for us. Aaron is extremely responsive, working late nights to make deals happen and I appreciated all the extra time he spent with us to walk us through the process. At closing Aaron spend time easing our nerves and gave us a beautiful individualized gift (hand painted portrait of our home), which was very memorable for us!

Months after purchasing our home - our very old water heater was going out and Aaron went above and beyond to help us work with a home warranty company and was able to help us get a brand new water heater. Almost 6 months later and we still keep in touch with Aaron, he is an amazing realtor and I would recommend him to any family or friend.

10/21/20MyReeah Johnson

Google Review

Will Jackson helped my husband and I buy our first home! And when we were ready to upgrade into our forever home, he was right there to sell our house (in 4 hours) and purchase our new one. He would respond to our text messages on a Saturday evening at 10pm. He was right there answering all our silly questions. I will be recommending him and Aaron weber group to everyone looking to buy or sell!

10/21/20Sonia Sanchez

Google Review

4/14/20Colette L

Google Review

Will and the team at Aaron Weber guided us professionally through an unfamiliar process. Everything was explained and no offer was made until they were satisfied it was the right offer. Our offer was accepted over many others because of the advise that Will gave us. We are very grateful. The service kept running until after the close was finalized. I would happily recommend the team here.

4/2/20Tube Soaker

Google Review

Professional & attentive. House sold fast!!!

4/2/20esather86

Google Review

Aaron inherited an absolute nightmare, I was stationed in Japan trying to sell a house that was very poorly renovated. I had no way of addressing the issues required in order to get the house up to code. Insert Aaron, he stepped in and did things that a real estate agent is not expected to do. Understanding my predicament, he coordinated multiple contractors on my behalf, and maintained a positive line of communication throughout the whole ordeal. The most impressive detail in this story was the fact that the house was selling for 99,000. There wasn't a huge payday lined up for him, he worked way harder than most would have and was a professional the entire time. Thank you, Aaron.

3/6/20Jacob Gelhar

Google Review

1/8/20Rachel Irving

Google Review

Aaron truly went above and beyond to help us find and purchase our first home. He was very timely with his communications/replies via e-mail and text & was patient with us when we wanted to see a lot of different homes and take our time (over a year) before buying. He advocated for us strongly during the purchase negotiation period and connected us with contractors and other home specialists as needed. He is incredibly knowledgeable, professional, helpful, friendly, respectful, honest, and hardworking. We felt so grateful to have Aaron as our agent and will definitely work with him again if/when we choose to sell our new home and move on to another. Thank you, Aaron!

1/4/20Jake Conant

Google Review

Aaron was great to work with. Helped us find exactly what we needed. Highly recommend.

1/2/20Bryan Nodorft

Google Review

Aaron was a stellar agent to use to buy and sell our homes this year. He was always very honest and concise. He responded to our requests in a short time and was a pleasure to work with. I cannot recommend him enough if you are looking to sell or buy a home in the Madison Area. Thanks Aaron!!

11/21/19Abid Ahmad

Google Review

Aaron is the best real estate agent that I have ever worked with. He does what he say he will do. I trusted his advice. Aaron went above and beyond in his efforts to get our place sold in Madison.

11/6/19Susan Howe

Google Review

Aaron Weber made our long-distance house buying so much easier. He was always available by phone, email or text. He got to know what we wanted and was proactive in the search. I liked that he knew about the inner workings of a house, electrical, sump pumps and all of the major things that make a house comfortable and safe to live in. My husband built a home and is an engineer; they would carry on conversations about issues which I knew nothing about. Aaron went above and beyond my expectations. You will receive stellar service.

8/27/19Mystee Pulcine

Google Review

Fantastic work from Aaron Weber. He went above and beyond to help us with what ended up being a very long and difficult process. His diligence kept the process moving, and his calmness kept us from falling into panic at the hardest times. We could't have asked for more.

9/11/18Glenn Miller

Google Review

Aaron and his team are proactive, responsive and incredibly knowledgeable of the Madison real estate community. My wife and I couldn't be happier with the customer service!

9/11/18Felix Lu

Google Review

We worked with Aaron Weber and Andrew Cronin as our second realtor when trying to sell our house. Our first realtor had a standard approach, which wasn't wrong or bad, but it seemed sluggish and perhaps sub-optimal. When we talked with Aaron and Andrew at the advice of some friends, we were still skeptical, but their pitch was smooth, up-to-date, tech savvy, and they were very energetic. Great - talk is cheap right? They showed us their rankings for realtors in the area, they were something like number 15 out of ~2000! We were impressed, but did words and statistics translate into action and results? It did! We had a fixed schedule to move out by a certain date. Aaron and Andrew advised and laid out a plan and were with us every step of the way to answer questions, make suggestions, and carry them out. Once we had moved out of state, Aaron and Andrew kept us updated at all the critical points and made it as painless as possible. We were free to worry about our new jobs, new place, new schools, etc. without the details of the sale bogging us down. I would recommend working with the Aaron Weber group without hesitation.

4/6/18Michael Howard

Google Review

Aaron has spent the past 8 months researching and visiting homes and vacant properties. Aaron was dedicated to making sure that my family had the perfect home that met all of our needs. Aaron exceeded my expectations, throughout the entire home purchasing process. Thanks Aaron!

12/30/17Denise Clearwood

Google Review

5.0 star rating 12/29/2017
Mike Paumen went above and beyond to find us the right house...and working through all the different scenarios and interests we had in different houses. He worked tirelessly to show us all the properties we were interested in without forcing us to make a decision after three showings!! He also did a great job selling our existing house in less than a few weeks. We highly recommend working with Mike...he listens and responds in a positive manner. Another perk was the opportunity to move over three weekends by using their moving truck...didn't even know about that perk until after we had been working with Mike for awhile!!

12/22/17Shane Griffith

Google Review

12/4/17Julia Barron

Google Review

We chose Aaron as our realtor based on the great reviews he received online. After speaking with him and comparing him to another realtor we got the sense that Aaron would get the job done. And we were not wrong! Before we could even put the house up for sale Aaron recommended some repairs and connected us to a contracting firm. They ended up doing a great job and at an affordable price. We posted our house for sale in mid summer and it was sold by November. This was very fast considering that we lost most of the summer. Aaron marketed our house even after the summer was over. He kept us informed of the process the entire time. Aaron used an electronic signature system which allowed us to sell the house in Wisconsin from another state. Because we were out of state, we relied on Aaron for quite a lot! Aaron set up repairs for us and visited the property whenever we needed to get something done. We always got the sense that our sale was a priority for him, even though he had other clients. Our sale also involved a number of negotiations that Aaron handled and it was definitely not an easy house to sell. Aaron was able to get the sale to move forward even though there were multiple opportunities for the sale to stall. Our house also involved buyer with an FHA loan which required a lot more work on Aaron‘s part. We are very pleased with Aaron‘s work and would definitely recommend him!