Amy Nitzschke

After more than a decade in B2B sales, I made the leap into real estate - and it was the best decision I ever made! My team member Machelle Walton and I have helped hundreds of Central Ohio families navigate one of the biggest, most exciting decisions of their lives: finding home.
Here's what we love most: every client's story is different. First-time buyers brimming with questions and dreams. Growing families ready for more space. Sellers turning the page to their next adventure. Whatever brings you to real estate, you deserve personalized attention, straight answers, and an advocate who's in your corner from start to finish.
My background in communications and journalism taught me to listen first and ask the right questions. Add in 25+ years of sales experience, and you get a strategic approach that never loses the human touch. Machelle and I work as true partners for our clients—giving you multiple perspectives, broader market coverage, and a team that's genuinely invested in your success.
Beyond individual transactions, I'm passionate about our Columbus community. I serve on the Columbus REALTORS Board of Directors (2024-2026) and chair the Columbus REALTORS Foundation Committee for 2026, supporting affordable housing and real estate education across the region. This keeps me connected to our market and committed to raising the bar in our profession.
Whether you're exploring Powell, Gahanna, Grove City, or anywhere in the Columbus metro, we know these neighborhoods inside and out—the schools, the hidden gems, the local favorites, and how to negotiate the best deal for you.
Central Ohio is home, and I can't imagine being anywhere else. The people, the growth, the energy—it's exceptional. I'd be honored to help you discover it for yourself.
Ready to make your move? Let's schedule a complimentary 1:1 consultation to talk about your goals and map out your next steps. Reach out today - your next chapter is waiting!