Andy Sheets

Carmel IN

Compass Indiana, LLC

134 Closed Sales

$84.3M Total Value

$254K - $2M Price Range

$629.2K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Andy

Andy Sheets is a trusted real estate professional with more than 18 years of experience and over $300 million in career sales, including $125+ million on Morse Reservoir alone. As a full-time lake resident, Andy doesn’t just sell Morse Lake — he lives and plays it, bringing unmatched local knowledge, personal experience, and proven results to every client. Together with his wife and licensed business partner, Amanda, the Sold By Sheets team is known for hands-on service, direct communication, and creative marketing strategies that stand out — from professional photography to on-the-water banners. Whether buying or selling, clients count on Andy’s blend of expertise, community connection, and passion for the lake lifestyle to deliver smooth, successful transactions.

Home Types: House, MultiFamily, Condo, Townhouse, Lot/Land, Commercial, Other

Years of Experience: 19

Education: Indiana University

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	16
Total Value	$13,503,000
Average Sale Price	$843,938
Price Range	$265K - $2M

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	14
Total Value	$7,662,790
Average Sale Price	$547,342
Price Range	$315K - $950K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	31
Total Value	$23,923,900
Average Sale Price	$771,739
Price Range	$192K - $2M

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	22
Total Value	$12,217,565
Average Sale Price	$555,344
Price Range	$165K - $1.4M

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	67
Total Value	$44,357,705
Average Sale Price	$662,055
Price Range	$192K - $2M

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	67
Total Value	$39,955,013
Average Sale Price	$596,343
Price Range	$126K - $1.7M

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Andy is Experienced In

Andy's Active Listings

$995,000
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,216 Sq Ft
64 Hickory Ridge Cir

Cicero, IN
Rare opportunity on Morse Lake with 1.4 wooded acres - a setting that is almost impossible to find on the lake! Tucked among mature trees, this waterfront property feels like your own private nature park while still offering all the fun of lake life. The open floor plan features vaulted ceilings, tons of windows, and multiple living spaces designed to take advantage of the beautiful wooded and

Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$1,295,000
- 4 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 3,381 Sq Ft
1711 Mulberry Cir

Noblesville, IN
Tucked among mature trees in the highly sought-after South Harbour neighborhood on Morse Lake, this home offers the perfect blend of privacy, lake views, and incredible community amenities. With 81' of water frontage, multiple levels of lakeside deck space, and a private dock, this property is ready for boat rides, kayaking, paddle boarding, fishing, and swimming in this desirable idle zone

Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$674,900
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,488 Sq Ft
2360 Stringtown Pike

Cicero, IN
Affordable lakefront opportunity on Morse Reservoir with the kind of views that are hard to find at this price point! Enjoy 25' of water frontage, highly desirable west-facing sunset views, and multiple tiers of outdoor living space including decks and a lakeside boardwalk designed for soaking up lake life. This brick ranch offers a flexible layout ideal for either full-time living or an easy

Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$349,900
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,223 Sq Ft
20971 Shoreline Ct

Unit 215

Noblesville, IN
Enjoy easy lake living at The Villas on Morse Lake with deeded boat dock included! Boat slip #25 is located just steps from the condo, making it incredibly convenient to hop on the boat and enjoy Morse Reservoir all season long. (See dock map in photos for exact slip location.) This 2 bedroom, 2 bath condo is ideally located on the lake side of the building and features peaceful east-facing lake

Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$639,000
- 5 Beds
- 4 Baths
- 4,449 Sq Ft
4000 W Morse Dr

Cicero, IN
Built in 2017 and beautifully maintained, this 4400+ sq ft Morse Landing West home offers the perfect blend of modern style, functional space, and an unbeatable location near Morse Reservoir. Just minutes from charming downtown Cicero, you can walk or bike across the reservoir for dinner, live music, coffee, and all the small-town lake life vibes people love about this area. Inside, the open

Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$269,900
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,828 Sq Ft
444 N Keystone Ave

Indianapolis, IN
Completely remodeled from top to bottom with newer mechanicals, this home just east of downtown Indianapolis offers the perfect blend of modern updates and a convenient location close to everything downtown has to offer. The open floor plan creates an easy flow throughout the main level, highlighted by a spacious kitchen with island-ideal for everyday living and entertaining. The main-floor

Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$224,900
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,440 Sq Ft
800 N Peru St

Cicero, IN
Opportunity awaits with this fixer-upper in Cicero, ideal for a first time home buyer, investor, flipper, or buyer looking to renovate and create rental income. Seller is open to upgrade allowances! Set on a nearly half-acre lot, this property offers strong value-add potential both inside and out. The home features a main-floor bedroom, two additional bedrooms upstairs, two full bathrooms on the

Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$1,495,000
- 3 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 3,964 Sq Ft
3162 Beach Blvd

Cicero, IN
VERY rare opportunity on the main body of Morse Lake! Built just 3.5 years ago, this nearly new custom ranch with walk-out basement checks every box for luxury lake living. From the moment you walk in, you'll love the open floor plan, raised ceilings, hardwood floors, and incredible west-facing water views ready for unforgettable sunsets. The spacious great room features a cozy gas fireplace

Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

Recently Sold

$318,000

Sold May 29, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,431 Sq Ft
155 Coatsville Dr

Westfield, IN
- 2% Below List
- $222/SF
- 14 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $322K
Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$1,100,000

Sold May 8, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 3,391 Sq Ft
18 Point Ln

Arcadia, IN
- 14% Below List
- $324/SF
- 277 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $1M
Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$725,000

Sold May 7, 2026
- 5 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 3,896 Sq Ft
208 Surrey Hill

Noblesville, IN
- 3% Below List
- $186/SF
- 5 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $729K
Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$330,000

Sold May 6, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,255 Sq Ft
3028 Stilton Dr

Cicero, IN
- 3% Below List
- $146/SF
- 3 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $337K
Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$1,500,000

Sold Apr 17, 2026
- 5 Beds
- 6.5 Baths
- 6,543 Sq Ft
4248 Creekside Pass

Zionsville, IN
- $229/SF
- 0 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $1M
Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$1,115,000

Sold Mar 16, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 2,476 Sq Ft
304 Sussex Cir

Noblesville, IN
- 14% Below List
- $450/SF
- 66 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $1M
Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$310,000

Sold Mar 16, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,006 Sq Ft
6336 Green Leaves Rd

Indianapolis, IN
- 14% Below List
- $155/SF
- 147 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $320K
Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$350,000

Sold Jan 23, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,149 Sq Ft
20834 Waterscape Way

Noblesville, IN
- 22% Below List
- $305/SF
- 298 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $358K
Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

$265,000

Sold Dec 29, 2025
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 2,119 Sq Ft
7250 Fitch Ave

Indianapolis, IN
- 18% Below List
- $125/SF
- 26 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $290K
Andy Sheets Compass Indiana, LLC

Awards and Designations

NAR - National Association of Realtors
SFR - Short Sale & Foreclosure Resource

Other Experience

Foreclosures, Short Sales

Andy Sheets

(866) 740-2187

Homes for Sale by City

Andy Sheets

About Andy

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Andy is Experienced In

Andy's Listings and Deals

Andy's Active Listings

Recently Sold

Awards and Designations

Other Experience