









About Carrie
When I’m not working, you’ll probably find me on the sidelines cheering on my daughter at her sporting events. Supporting others—whether it’s my clients or my family—is truly what I love most.
Transaction History
- 1 Year
- 2 Year
- 5 Year
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
1 Year View by Quarter
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
2 Year View by Quarter
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
5 Year View
Neighborhoods Carrie Has the Most Experience In
-
37 Sales
-
24 Sales
-
17 Sales
-
13 Sales
-
11 Sales
-
4 Sales
Carrie's Listings and Deals
Carrie's Recent Active Listings
-
$87,500
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,568 Sq Ft
- 23 Short Ln
- Shippensburg, PA
Don’t miss this well-maintained 3 bedroom, 2 bath doublewide located in a quiet, welcoming community! The open concept design creates a spacious, airy feel. Beautiful hardwood flooring adds warmth and character throughout the home, which has been lovingly cared for and is truly move-in ready.Lot rent is just $430 a month and covers water, sewer, and trash, a rare perk you won’t find in most
Carrie Gardner Realty One Group Golden Key
-
$315,000
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,616 Sq Ft
- 4043 Campbell Cir
- Orrstown, PA
Charming ranch-style home on nearly an acre lot in a quiet, sought-after neighborhood. Campbell Circle is known for its peaceful, rural feel while still being just minutes from town for all your conveniences. Step inside to a warm and welcoming space featuring hardwood floors throughout and ceramic tile in the kitchen and bath. All appliances, including washer and dryer convey. A spacious 24'
Carrie Gardner Realty One Group Golden Key
-
$169,900
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 816 Sq Ft
- 521 W King St
- Unit H
- Shippensburg, PA
Easy living at its best! This charming 2nd-level 2 bed, 1 bath condo offers the convenience of one-level living with an open concept design that seamlessly combines the kitchen, dining, and living areas. Enjoy new carpet and luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, plus the convenience of laundry on the same level. A walk-in closet provides ample space for your clothes. The HOA fee of just $183.79
Carrie Gardner Realty One Group Golden Key
-
$329,900
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 1,771 Sq Ft
- 10119 Cardinal Dr
- Orrstown, PA
Welcome to this spacious 4 bedroom, 3 full bath bi-level home located in a desirable community just minutes from the PA Turnpike and Rt. 641. Step inside to find fresh paint and updated flooring throughout, creating a move-in-ready feel. The newly added full bath is a true highlight, featuring a jetted tub and a walk-in shower for a spa like experience. The oversized 2-car attached garage
Carrie Gardner Realty One Group Golden Key
-
$30,000
- Land
- 0.38 Acre
- $78,947 per Acre
- 0 Mount Foot Spur
- Tell Township, PA
Bring your vision to life on this buildable .38-acre lot in a peaceful rural setting. With both a well and septic already in place, much of the groundwork has been done for you. Enjoy the privacy and tranquility of country living. Bring your offer today!
Carrie Gardner Realty One Group Golden Key
-
$224,900
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,524 Sq Ft
- 34 Michael Ct
- Shippensburg, PA
Welcome to this beautifully maintained, low-maintenance, one-level home located in a desirable 55+ community. This charming residence offers a host of additional features, including a bright sunroom and a lovely covered porch, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. An open layout allows for an abundance of natural light and a sense of spaciousness. New LVP flooring and real hardwood flooring give
Carrie Gardner Realty One Group Golden Key
-
$415,000
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,508 Sq Ft
- 2027 Jelena Rd
- Shippensburg, PA
REDUCED!! Like new and move-in ready! Motivated sellers due to relocation . This home was built in 2019 and looks even better than the day it was completed. Sitting on an a larger than most .35 acre lot with an oversized garage and extended driveway parking, there’s plenty of space inside and out.Upstairs, the primary suite features a beautiful built-in desk, walk-in closet, and private
Carrie Gardner Realty One Group Golden Key
-
$91,500
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,152 Sq Ft
- 38 Colonial Cir
- Shippensburg, PA
**REDUCED**Cozy & Charming 3-Bedroom Home – Like New!Welcome to your next home! This 3-bedroom, 2-bath gem was built in 2021 and is still in like-new condition. It’s a great fit for first-time buyers, anyone looking to downsize, or someone just wanting a low-maintenance place to call their own. You'll love the peaceful vibe—enjoy quiet mornings on the spacious front porch while listening
Carrie Gardner Realty One Group Golden Key
-
$239,000
- 4 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 2,016 Sq Ft
- 9 N Queen St
- Shippensburg, PA
**BRING YOUR OFFER!This historic charming home in the heart of downtown Shippensburg offers great potential as either an investment property or a future family home! With 4 bedrooms and 1 and 1/2 bathrooms, there’s plenty of space to accommodate a variety of lifestyles. The walk-up attic adds convenient storage, while the full front porch that wraps around the side enhances the home's curb
Carrie Gardner Realty One Group Golden Key
Awards and Designations
- Remax 100% Remax Executive
Other Experience
Carrie's Reviews
6/26/23d. sierra
Google Review
Carrie's the best!
Personable, yet professional.
6/4/23Angel Onativia
Google Review
Carrie is is the hardest working, honest, and professional realtor we’ve worked with. She will find you what you are looking for or die trying. No matter what kind of home you’re looking for she will get you squared away and happy in your new home
4/3/23Kelly Bracken
Google Review
Our family can't say enough about Carrie!!!!!
Kind,helpful,honest,patient,understanding and a very hard worker.
Thanks to Carrie We have our new home and are very grateful
3/19/23Jessica Doe
Google Review
Carrie is the most patient, thorough, and professional realtor I've dealt with. She helped me to find an amazing rental property near Washington, D.C. She really went out of her way to help me, and we had fun in the process! I highly recommend her for your home search!
3/19/23Tessie Guyer
Google Review
Carrie was very compassionate and patient with me. This was a hard time for me, selling my mom's house after her passing. Carrie walked with me every step of the way! Would highly recommend her!
1/30/23Adi Horner
Google Review
Carrie did a great job with keeping the communication open, helping us find houses to look at in a timely manner and just being a truthful helper in our first time home buying experience. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for that best fit for a new home!
12/17/22Carey
Google Review
Sold my home through Carrie/Remax, had several bids within just a few days! She was great at ensuring all the paperwork was explained and completed, especially given I was working with her remotely from North Carolina.
12/7/22Tammy Weller
Google Review
Carrie Gardner is an Awesome Real Estate Agent and I am Very fortunate that she is part of the Remax Prestige family.
She works smart and hard for her clients and is always willing to help out others when ever she can.
11/4/22kelly Benshoff
Google Review
We absolutely loved how carrie went above and beyond to get things done with buying and selling our houses.
8/23/22Brandon Perkins
Google Review
We had a fantastic experience working with Carrie! She was able to work with our schedules to quickly find us a wonderful home! She really made the whole buying process a delight!
8/22/22Julie Leid
Google Review
Carrie, made our experience smooth, worked with us and was an absolute joy! I would recommend her to all:)
8/22/22Mark Ryder
Google Review
6/13/22Elizabeth Robinson
Google Review
she is my mother, but no matter where we are or what time it is she will answer your phone call😂
6/6/22Svax AP
Google Review
6/3/22Jeremy Heckman
Google Review
Carrie has excellent communication skills and always has the client's best interest in mind.
5/13/22Sarah Bryant
Google Review
She was able to get us connected to an agent out of state, where we are moving to. Very kind and helpful!
5/6/22Seth Frey
Google Review
We have and will continue to use Carrie for all our real estate needs. She goes above and beyond in every aspect of buying and selling process. I highly recommend using Carrie for your real estate needs, whether that’s buying or selling. You won’t be disappointed
4/29/22Chandler Baum
Google Review
4/21/22Brittney Greenawalt
Google Review
4/5/22Charles Coy
Google Review
Carrie: We are so thankful for your assistance in selling our rental property. We always believed we could sell our property, and you sure did put forth your best to make that happen. We appreciate the concern and patience you displayed during this time. Pleasure working with you.
3/30/22Donna Lopp
Google Review
Carrie Gardner is such a caring realtor and was so attentive to my needs. She was very knowledgeable, patient, kind and always answered my questions. She was fun to work with and I would highly recommend her.
12/14/21John Mower
Google Review
Carrie helped me find a great house at a great value. It took me a while in today's market to find my home, but Carrie was very helpful and patient. She had me in several homes the day they hit the market and a few a day or two before they were officially listed. Almost every home we looked at was right in line with what I was looking for. She knows the process VERY well and is extremely helpful. Highly recommend!!!
12/13/21J L
Google Review
Carrie was great to work with! Highly Recommend!
11/2/21Justin Bonner
Google Review
Wonderful Experience. Really pushed for best price. Helped out all through the process and also assisted when I was out of town getting the house in order or arranging contractors. Can’t say enough good things about Carrie or the team. Thanks
10/24/21Jim B
Google Review
We could not be happier with the service Carrie provided when we sold our commercial property. We are out of state and Carrie made everything easy and hassle free. She is professional and top notch. We will not hesitate to use her again if the need arises!
9/27/21Chris McClung
Google Review
Carrie was so helpful while we were trying to find our new home! She responded right away to schedule our showings and always accommodated our schedule. She was very helpful through the entire process and in the end helped us to find the perfect place!
7/16/21Tom Bradley
Google Review
Carrie Gardner was our real estate agent in the recent successful sale of our house. She was highly professional, knowledgeable, and a tireless agent in the sale of our house. At the same time, she was always most pleasant and sociable. If problems in process arose, she was right on top of it; if we had questions, she was right there with accurate answers. When we closed on the sale of our house, my wife and I were most happy with her role as our agent. If excellence in real estate has a name, we believe it would have to be Carrie Gardner.
2/20/21Sarah Brafford
Google Review
It was pure luck that I had the pleasure of speaking with Carrie when I called her office about a property they had listed. One thing led to another and after that phone conversation I felt totally comfortable with Carrie and wanted to work with her as our realtor. She was so enthusiastic and proactive from the very start. She immediately set us up with the MLS and was sure to point out up and coming properties that she thought would suit us. We started looking in October with the only goal of being in a home by Christmas. With how fast homes were selling she knew it was a priority to get walk throughs scheduled and see the homes before others got the chance. I'm positive this is how we ended up in a home we completely love. She was great at negotiating for us when we put in our offer and throughout the closing process. If I can tell you what sets Carrie apart from other realtors its her genuine excitement for going through the home buying process with you. It felt like we had a friend cheering us on. Don't let "years in the business" deter you...she is the third realtor we have worked with buying a house and by far the best. My husband and I made numerous comments to each other about how much better Carrie was than other realtors we had worked with previously that had been in the business for 15 and 20 years. Carrie is very knowledgeable and trustworthy. If there was a question she didn't have an answer to she would say let me find out. We appreciated her honesty so much as it proved she wasn't just trying to push a sale on us. She wanted to make sure we had all accurate information. I'm happy to say we got the second house we put an offer in on (this market is so tough--tons of competition)! We are actually thrilled now that the first house didn't work out. Carrie made the entire closing process a breeze and updated us throughout the process. She gave us a warm welcome to our new home and best of all...she got us in two weeks before Christmas!!! I really wouldn't dream of working with anyone else after how good our experience was. Remember choosing a good realtor can make all the difference when buying/selling and I can say with total confidence that Carrie is going to go the extra mile for you. We appreciate you so much!
11/22/20Jamie Birgfeld
Google Review
11/20/20Ron Lloyd
Google Review
I'd been looking for a cabin in this area for a couple of years. I called on Carrie to show me cabins as they came up for sale. She was very patient. It was at least the 5th or 6th cabin that she showed me and it was just right. I have no regrets. It's not far away so I go there multiple times per week. Very happy.
11/18/20Taylor Smith (Taylor Smith Videography)
Google Review
Carrie helped us through our first home sale and second home purchase. She made the sale process easy on us and kept us advised every step of the way. And the buying process was 100x better than our first time around with another realtor. We felt so informed and comfortable every step of the way, which relieved so much stress from our shoulders: Every road block we hit, Carrie helped us navigate. We couldn't be more grateful for her help.
11/12/20Mary Ann Murphy
Google Review
Carrie was very helpful in finding us the right home. She was always professional and gave accurate information when needed. Carrie worked around our schedules to be sure we saw the houses we wanted to see. Even with the COVID disruptions she didn’t miss a beat. When we finally found the home we wanted the sellers agent appreciated her patience and kindness. We intend to use Carrie in the spring to sell our second home when our renters move away.

