Hilary Casstevens

12/20/25Birgit Miller

Google Review

Letter of Recommendation for Hillary Abernathy Castevens

I am pleased to write this letter of recommendation for our real estate agent, Hillary Abernathy Casstevens, whose professionalism, compassion, and dedication exceeded our expectations.

Having grown up in the area, Hillary brought a real understanding of the local market and surrounding communities that proved invaluable throughout the process.

Our situation was particularly complex, as we were selling a century-old home that had been in our family for 108 years. It was truly a one-of-a-kind property with no viable comparisons. The decision to sell also carried deep emotional significance for our entire family.

Hillary handled every aspect of this process with patience, grace, and a level of professionalism unmatched by others we have worked with in the past. She understood the uniqueness of the property, as well as the emotional weight attached to it.

She supported our family every step of the way, while also being equally thoughtful and attentive to the family purchasing the home. This speaks volumes about her integrity and character.

Because no one in our family lived nearby, Hillary went above and beyond her role as an agent, assisting with numerous tasks and details that could have easily become overwhelming.

Thanks to her dedication, what could have been a very difficult and stressful transition became a genuinely positive experience.

We were very pleased with Hillary’s real estate skills, knowledge, trustworthiness, and genuine care. It was clear throughout the process that she was focused on finding the right home for the right family and not simply completing a sale.

We recommend Hillary Abernathy Casstevens without hesitation to anyone seeking a real estate professional who brings expertise, compassion, and unwavering commitment to her clients.

Sincerely,
Birgit Miller

11/7/25dubya clark

Google Review

Buying a home can be incredibly challenging, but Hilary was with us every step of the way. She went above and beyond by personally showing us multiple properties, quickly sourcing new listings that matched our needs, and patiently answering all our questions from the very first tour. Once we found the perfect home, Hilary guided us seamlessly through every phase of the process with expertise and care.
She was always punctual, highly responsive via phone or text, and available whenever we needed her—no matter the time or day. Even after closing, Hilary didn’t disappear; she followed up diligently to ensure all post-purchase documents were handled smoothly and answered any lingering concerns.
Throughout the entire journey, Hilary remained friendly, professional, and remarkably patient. We couldn’t have asked for a better partner in this process. 10/10—would absolutely work with her again!

7/9/25Erin Sadler

Google Review

I can't say enough good things about Hilary! She helped us sell our home and from day one, she was incredibly positive and hopeful (while maintaining realistic outcomes), which really helped keep our spirits up during a stressful time.

What I loved most was how much of a delight she was to work with. She always had a smile and made us feel confident that everything would work out. She kept us in the loop throughout the whole process and was always available when we had questions.

If you're looking for a real estate agent who truly cares and will make the experience less stressful, I highly recommend Hilary. We'll definitely be calling her for any future real estate needs!

1/10/25Kellie McCrocklin

Google Review

Hilary was the Perfect choice to walk through the step of House buying with me. I went through a devastating divorce this year, and I had to rent an Apartment for the 1st time in my life. I had moved into my spouse's home entering marriage life years ago, and I had never purchased my own home. I was definitely starting over at 55. So many emotions went into finding my Forever home, and Hilary was so supportive, encouraging, and ultimately a great friend to me, while going through the motions..... I am so thankful and very blessed that God led me to Hilary.

12/27/24Tabitha Oliver

Google Review

Was one of the best experiences selling our home. We have experienced many realtors and I must say Hilary is the best ! Very punctual and kept us up to date on everything ! She has also earned a place in our hearts as well !

12/17/24Brittany C

Google Review

Hilary is a great agent and is so informative! She will help you every step of the way.

12/13/24Shannon Clark

Google Review

Hilary is such an amazing person. She always has your best interest. She listens to your dreams and desires. She is professional and caring. If you are selling or buying, I would highly recommend her.

12/6/24Darrian Real

Google Review

Hilary helped me with buying my house back in April of 2018. I could not have done in with without her! Being a first time home buyer Hilary made it a very smooth and easy experience!

12/4/24swkees

Google Review

Having lived in our present home for 48 years and feeling the need to downsize was a very emotional turn in life for us. We’ve never utilized a realtor for selling or for buying. To say we were naive is an understatement. We are grateful that our daughter recommended Hilary. Our home sold after being listed for 10 days. It was not just the quick sale that impressed us. Hilary prepared us for each step in the process and led us through all of the things that needed to be done following the sale. She stayed in constant touch with us and was always happy to answer our questions. She made our emotional “procedure” a very pleasant journey.

12/2/24Deanna Zimmer

Google Review

Hilary is the walking definition of excellence. She is extremely knowledgeable and keeps her clients informed along the way of what is to be expected next, while answering any question that may arise. She is also very aware that this could be an emotional rollercoaster and she exhibits empathy as she navigates the way. Her clients may start off as just that but through this process they become friends as relationships are important to her. Her smile lights up the room and has the ability to make anyone feel welcome. When you make the decision to work with Hilary, rest assure that you are in good hands.

11/26/24Stacey King

Google Review

11/25/24Lashonda Edwards

Google Review

Hilary Casstevens, eXp Realty help guide me through the stress of things that may be needed to help boost the value of my home. She was very attentive with quick responses, hard working, and has a caring manner. Thanks Hilary!!

11/25/24Rachel Batthauer

Google Review

I have the privilege of watching the behind the scenes with Hilary and how she runs her business. Hilary is a hard worker that is dedicated to her client’s needs. I value her work ethic and attention to details. She is highly recommended to anyone wanting a top notch realtor! 5 stars indeed!

11/25/24Kari May

Google Review

Hillary not only is an excellent realtor, and goes above and beyond for her clients, but also is so giving to her community and the kids in the school system!! Thank you Hillary!!

11/25/24Amanda Brantlinger

Google Review

It takes a lot for me to give a 5 star review, but the consideration, time and effort Hillary puts in to helping one buy and sell a home makes it a very easy decision! The best!

11/25/24Leslie Sanders

Google Review

Hilary always goes above and beyond. She listens and truly cares about her clients. Hilary understands the market and works hard to make the process as stress-free as possible.

11/24/24Kate Miller

Google Review

Hilary is the one person I know I could go to for anything and she’d have the answers, or she would work hard to find them! She’s been an absolute blessing to have in my family’s lives for the last 15 years. We’re very grateful to know her!

11/24/24Rose Sanders

Google Review

11/24/24Michelle Sanford

Google Review

Hilary is patient and genuinely cares about her clients. Her extensive knowledge of the real estate industry gives her a strong foundation to negotiate and close transactions.

11/23/24Brooke Stines

Google Review

Hilary Casstevens is a first class real estate agent. With her years of experience she knows how to navigate you through the buying/selling process and get the most for her clients. Customer service and satisfaction is her #1 priority and as a client you feel that in every aspect. Hire Hilary- you will thank me!

11/21/24Kris Bishop

Google Review

I habe referred a couple of friends to Hilary. She is easy to work with and a great communicator. I will continue to send anyone looking for a great realtor to Hilary!

11/20/24Kimberly Ross

Google Review

Hilary was amazing! She was so patient and kind with my mother and I. We had specific needs and she made sure to find exactly what we wanted. We had been apprehensive going into this but she made the entire experience so easy. Couldn’t have asked for a better realtor!

11/19/24Chris Beck

Google Review

Hilary is an outstanding realtor who made the entire process of finding and selling a home for our kids seamless and enjoyable. Her professionalism, attention to detail, and genuine care for her clients set her apart. She took the time to understand exactly what they were looking for and worked tirelessly to find homes that fit their needs. Her knowledge of the market and her excellent communication skills kept them informed every step of the way. Would highly recommend Hilary to anyone searching for a dedicated and trustworthy realtor!

11/19/24Gary Brower

Google Review

Hillary helped us find our dream home! Even with our very specific needs she found it. She was friendly and explained every step of the process. I highly recommend her to all my friends.

11/19/24William Spoerner

Google Review

Hilary with eXp Realty was absolutely fantastic to work with! From the start, she provided clear and thoughtful advice on which updates were essential to maximize the value of our home, breaking them down into ‘must-dos’ and ‘nice-to-dos.’ Her expert guidance through every step of the process—from preparing the house to listing and closing—made selling our home incredibly easy. With Hilary and eXp Realty’s professionalism and support, the entire experience was smooth and stress-free. We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor!

11/19/24Mackenzie Benson

Google Review

Hilary was the best to work with! She sold our house quickly and took care of all the little hiccups we encountered along the way with ease!

11/19/24Hope Hoffman

Google Review

Hilary is so great!! She is very kind and patient and makes you feel so comfortable especially first time home buyer!!

11/19/24lynn parker

Google Review

Hillary was amazing. I had unfortunately lost my home in a fire. Not only did she help me sell my damaged property she also then worked very hard with me everyday to ensure that I found a wonderful new home. She is absolutely the best realtor I know. Her knowledge and experience really showed what the commitment that she put into helping me purchase my new property. I highly recommend Hillary if you are in the market for a new home.

11/19/24Dave Dick

Google Review

Hilary helped us (my sisters and I) sell our Father's house after he passed. She is a real go-getter and doesn't stop until the job is finished. I would highly recommend Hilary if you're buying or selling.

11/19/24Beau Bailey

Google Review

Hilary got my house sold fast!!! Her communication was fantastic every step of the way. She made the whole process so easy. I highly recommend her for your next sale or purchase!!

11/18/24Cody Beck

Google Review

Hilary was fantastic to work with and helped us buy our first home and recently sell that home! We look forward to work with her again in the spring when we start searching for another.

11/16/24Zach Benson

Google Review

Hillary was a joy to work with! She guided me every step of the way, and I never once felt like I was going through the process of selling my house alone! She will be the only realtor I work with going forward!

9/17/24Katie Heilman

Google Review

Hilary is one of the best! She works diligently, fast and always has your best interest at heart. She’s 100% a hard worker, and always listened to our needs. I would 100% recommend Hilary for anyone needing an advocate in real estate!

5/12/24Kouri Hoffman

Google Review

Where can I start with Hilary... she has to be the absolute best realtor out there hands down. We got extemely lucky and met her through Zillow and throughout our entire buying process no matter what she had going on, she dropped everything she was doing to accomodate us. I asked her from day to be honest and straight forward about everything as we didnt want to waste our time or q. That is exactly what she gave us and we couldnt be any more appreciative of that! She was there for us every step of the way and if something wasnt right or didnt seem like it was going to work, she stayed positive and kept moving forward. We looked at probably over 100 houses in a little less than a years time and we were beginning to loose hope in the end. We finally found a great starter home that we can start our home ownership in and hopefully move into something much better down the road. She took great care of us and Im sure we will be using her for anything else moving forward. Feel like we also gained a friend for my fiance and myself!

4/16/24Alicia Fisher

Google Review

Not only was Hilary patient as a professional in my endless pursuit to ‘buy dirt,’ she became my friend who checked on me as a person, not just as a client. I appreciate her gentle way of giving advice, hearing my wild ideas that touched more points than a star has, and still encouraging and supporting me to the end and far beyond the date I finally closed on something. As a woman, person, and professional. . I’m truly blessed that our paths crossed and she’s still walking beside me as the next chapter in my life begins.

2/25/24Debra Key

Google Review

Hillary is the Best!!! Love her💖👍👍Works very hard and gets things done quick!👍

2/20/24Amber King

Google Review

If you are looking for a caring, kind real estate agent who will be there for you every step of the way, Hilary is the one! She worked tirelessly on my behalf and kept me in the loop during all the twists and turns. Cannot recommend highly enough!

12/13/23Brittnee Bertram

Google Review

Hilary helped me sell my 1st home and purchase my 2nd home. She was extremely professional and knowledgeable. She answered any question I had and gave me the guideance I needed.

8/15/23Jesse Furrow

Google Review

Hilary is a true professional and a joy to work with! Would highly recommend!

1/31/23Teresa Gross

Google Review

Seriously the absolute best realtor ever. She has went above and beyond for us not once but twice. We bought a home with Hilary and we loved her so much we wanted to sell our home with her! She found us our forever home and sold our other property to someone else hopefully their forever home too! She's dedicated, hard working, and will go above and beyond for her clients. If you're looking for a realtor you definitely need to make sure you call Hilary! She was our life saver!

12/17/22Kathy Lansford

Google Review

Hilary was recommended to us while we were still living in Texas. She was in regular contact with us while we sold our house there regarding what we would be looking for in Indy. Once she got it, she was on fire, visiting houses with us, pointing out things we'd missed. With us, she was particularly great at collaborating with the seller's agent, getting problems addressed quickly, helping us navigate complex paperwork and wire transfers. She is all about relationships. She was our first friend in Indy and continues to be a dear friend, keeping in touch with us and our extended family.
Trustworth. Professional. Generous. Friend to the end.

11/26/22Jordan Davis

Google Review

This was a great experience. Hilary goes above and beyond. thank you so much!

9/16/22Bryan Murphy

Google Review

Almost 10 years to the day of buying the property I closed on the sale of my duplex this week. Earlier this summer I decided to look into what the property would fetch in this crazy housing market. I reached out to Hilary and couldn’t be happier that I did. One of our first conversations I told her the number I had in my head and she thought that might be a little high (very few comparable properties in the area), but she said if I wasn’t in a rush to sell we’d see what happens. She ended up landing me that number! I was also looking for someone to be totally hands on with the entire process. One of the reasons I was looking to sell was that I was just tired of the rental grind. Hilary did absolutely everything for me in the selling process and was always sending me updates. If you’re looking into buying or selling, contact her! You won’t be disappointed.

7/22/22Olivia Blaker

Google Review

Hilary has went above and beyond to help our family with selling and buying! She is very considerate of our needs, accommodating with our kids and schedules and takes time to truly make us feel like we are her top priority! We will always recommend her to anyone!

6/14/22Missi Brooks

Google Review

Hilary was absolutely WONDERFUL to work with! Super friendly, very professional and knowledgeable! I would highly recommend her to anyone considering buying or selling!

3/27/22Shannon Sutterfield

Google Review

Hillary was amazing. She was 5 steps ahead of us at all times, which was perfect for our situation. She made a stressful situation, seamless, and she made my sister happy which was what mattered most to me.

1/7/22Alycia Rivas

Google Review

My family and I are beyond impressed with Hilary and highly recommend her! She is so personable, responsive, an incredible communicator, and efficient and highly knowledgeable in Indianapolis real estate.

Here’s our story: We decided to move to Indianapolis to be close to family, but we had only visited a few times and knew virtually nothing about the city. Hilary spent so much time with us up front to learn about our family, our desires for a home and neighborhood, and about our lifestyle. As we communicated more, it was very apparent that Hilary truly knew us because our virtual housing search was spot on. Every house that showed up in our list met all of our requirements. She got us! Then when we were ready to look at homes in person, we flew to Indianapolis for a few days only, hoping that we would finish our 3-day trip with a new home… and we did! We looked at homes in neighborhoods all throughout Indy - from Broad Ripple to Fountain Square and Bates-Hendricks to Downtown - allowing our family to familiarize ourselves with the various neighborhoods and truly get a better sense for what would fit us best. In only three days, we managed to see 12 homes, put in an offer on one home, and conduct the home inspection. While most people likely wouldn’t move that quickly, our family was able to do so only because of Hilary’s expertise and efficiency. We love our new state, our new neighborhood, and our new home. We couldn’t have done it without Hilary! Furthermore, we wouldn’t have wanted anyone else supporting us throughout this entire process.

P.S. We loved Hilary so much that my parents also worked with her for their cross-country move to Indianapolis.

12/19/21mary abernathy

Google Review

I have found that Hilary really cared about us making the right choice in our location. She listened and understood our concerns. I would highly recommend her to anyone for your real estate needs. It’s like finding a great healthcare provider and telling everyone that she can help them as well!

11/30/21Chivas Sell

Google Review

Hilary was amazing to work with, she was very good with keeping us updated through the process. She went above and beyond. We will use her in any future real estate needs.

11/14/21Teresa Gross

Google Review

Seriously, couldn't ask for a better realtor. She was honest, worked hard for what we wanted, and very responsive. A 5 star review is just not enough for such a hard working person such as Hilary. We are completely satisfied and plan to use her in the future to sell our old house.

11/2/21Amanda Kirby

Google Review

Hilary was wonderful to work with! She went above and beyond to make sure our family was able to buy the perfect home! She made the process very easy and answered all our questions. Hilary is someone who wants to get to know you and what you are looking for in a home. She is extremely professional and responsive to her clients. If you want a great experience and someone who truly cares, I recommend her for your reality needs!

10/28/21Angie Durbin

Google Review

Hilary is an amazing agent to work with. She is quick to communicate and always willing to go the extra mile. I highly recommend Hilary for your real estate needs and I look forward to continuing to work with her!

10/28/21Jeanne Franklin

Google Review

Hilary is a great realtor! She found the perfect home for us. What sets Hillary apart from other realtors is that she truly cares about finding the right home by listening and asking good questions so that she understands what you want. She is responsive and not afraid to ask tough questions when necessary. I highly recommend Hillary Casstevens!