









About Holly
Transaction History
- 1 Year
- 2 Year
- 5 Year
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
1 Year View by Quarter
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
2 Year View by Quarter
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
5 Year View
Holly's Listings and Deals
Holly's Recent Active Listings
-
$225,000
- Land
- -- per Acre
- 1286 Fawnskin Dr
- Fawnskin, CA
Discover an extraordinary 1.25-acre haven nestled on a private easement road in Fawnskin, where the National Forest becomes your backyard. This upslope, wooded lot offers a stunning potential build site for your dream home. Picture your future home featuring peekaboo views of Big Bear Lake, complemented by the tranquil beauty of the forest, mountains, and canyon landscapes. A detailed survey and
Holly Gardner Keller Williams Big Bear
-
$825,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,610 Sq Ft
- 1614 S Colusa Dr
- Big Bear City, CA
Escape to the mountains with this "Country Heart" log home, nestled at the end of a picturesque cul-de-sac! With ski slope views and a location close to Bear Mountain Ski Resort, the golf course, and the Big Bear Alpine Zoo, this is your gateway to mountain adventures year-round. Inside, you'll find 3 cozy bedrooms (2 downstairs, 1 upstairs), a large loft, and 2 full bathrooms (one on each
Holly Gardner Keller Williams Big Bear
-
$350,000
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,120 Sq Ft
- 1887 Baldwin Lake Rd
- Big Bear City, CA
This captivating log cabin is more than a home--it's an invitation to experience the magic of mountain living. Perched amidst serene open space, it boasts unforgettable panoramic views of Baldwin Lake, Snow Summit, and Bear Mountain Ski Resorts, promising breathtaking scenery every day. Step inside to discover an inviting atmosphere with an open floor plan, soaring vaulted ceilings, and large
Holly Gardner Keller Williams Big Bear Lake Arrowhead
-
$569,999
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,520 Sq Ft
- 42557 La Cerena Ave
- Big Bear Lake, CA
Charming mountain home nestled in the sought-after lower Moonridge area. This spacious home offers 3 bedrooms- one conveniently located on the main floor- and two additional bedrooms plus a bonus room on the upper level. One full bath on each level and a laundry room leading to the backyard near the kitchen. Open floorplan allows for ample space to gather with friends and family. Plenty of
Holly Gardner Keller Williams Big Bear Lake Arrowhead
-
$325,000
- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 576 Sq Ft
- 526 Kern Ave
- Sugarloaf, CA
Wow, it's gorgeous!! This fully remodeled home is light, bright, and super clean! Fully remodeled and tastefully decorated! Turn-key and ready to enjoy! Enter the living room to discover a beautiful fireplace to cozy up to, T&G wood open beam ceilings, and a spacious open floor plan! The kitchen features beautiful countertops, cabinets, and stainless appliances. Bonus room through the living room
Holly Gardner Keller Williams Big Bear Lake Arrowhead
-
$409,000
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 840 Sq Ft
- 433 Sugarloaf Blvd
- Big Bear City, CA
Such a sweet mountain setting! This beautiful log sided, remodeled, turn-key, gambrel offers 3 bedrooms and 1 bath and is situated among the trees in a great location of Big Bear City, just minutes from the lake, ski slopes, and shopping! Fantastic open floorplan with lots of log trim and that cozy mountain feel! The living room offers T&G ceilings and a beautiful wood burning stove to cozy up to
Holly Gardner Keller Williams Big Bear Lake Arrowhead
-
$339,000
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 704 Sq Ft
- 532 W Sherwood Blvd
- Big Bear City, CA
Nestled in the heart of Big Bear City, this charming single-story Sierra-style cabin is the perfect mountain retreat. Surrounded by a fenced, beautifully landscaped yard, the property exudes the quintessential mountain vibe, both inside and out. The interior boasts vaulted wood-beamed ceilings, warm wood accents, and a stunning native rock fireplace that adds cozy character. Well-maintained with
Holly Gardner Keller Williams Big Bear Lake Arrowhead
-
$475,000
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 704 Sq Ft
- 40123 Hillcrest Dr
- Big Bear Lake, CA
Wow! Gorgeous mountain Sierra style home in a fantastic area of Big Bear Lake Central! Completely remodeled and beautifully done! This 2 bedroom, 1 bath cutie sits on a huge 13,860 sq ft lot and has a huge newer two-story barn and a ''she shed'' laundry room with plumbing, gas and electric to it! Enter the living room to find a beautiful rock wood burning fireplace, vaulted T&G open beam
Holly Gardner Keller Williams Big Bear Lake Arrowhead
-
$550,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,334 Sq Ft
- 388 Cedar Ln
- Sugarloaf, CA
Stunning custom-built home with only 2 owners! Updated in 2007 & very well maintained! This immaculate home offers 3 beds, 2 baths, an oversized 2-car garage w/ 12 ft walls, a second 1-car garage, a circular concrete driveway, all on a huge fully fenced lot w/ 2 sheds & RV parking! Enter the living room to find gorgeous 10 ft ceilings & a beautiful brick fireplace w/ a wood burning stove insert
Holly Gardner Keller Williams Big Bear Lake Arrowhead
Awards and Designations
- National Association of REALTORS
Other Experience
Holly's Reviews
7/20/23Lance Kendricks
Google Review
We had a great experience with Holly. She was helpful and throughout the entire process of selling our home. We got it sold in an everything taken care of in a timely manner!
6/17/23Living It Out Doors
Google Review
Holly was amazing, very punctual when meeting for property reviews which was important to me since I was driving up from San Diego. After a few visits she got a feel for what I was looking for and then it happened. I found the right place within my budget. Highly recommend using Holly, especially with her knowledge of Big Bear properties and neighborhoods.
6/5/23Isela Favela
Google Review
Best realtor ever thanks Holly you made my dream come true
5/29/23Holly Sparke
Google Review
I recently had the pleasure of working with Holly and would work with her again anytime. She was professional, helpful and knowledgeable in all things pertaining to real estate and Big Bear. I was a little stressed at having to complete everything from another state but Holly got everything done for me that I couldn’t do physically for myself and in a timely manner as I closed in two weeks. She genuinely cares about her job, her reputation and was joy to work with. Give her a call.
5/11/23Jon Caffall
Google Review
I, unfortunately, worked with a different realtor before working with Holly. The other realtor did very little to work hard to sale my property and let six months elapse before I could get a different realtor.
Holly was my choice and she had the property sold in a very short time. She keeps you updated on the status of the sale of your property. She also has multiple contacts should you need anything related to your property which I did need to do a few repairs. You should strongly consider this wonderful realtor in either buying or selling a property.
5/10/23Linh Ding
Google Review
Holly is great realtor who is very knowledgable and easy to work with. There were some issues with our funding which caused some delay but Holly was able to work her magic and our home was closed without any issues. She was a great communicator and helped us throughout the whole process. Thank you Holly.
4/26/23Hyun Suh
Google Review
Holly went above and beyond to help with selling our property. Since we are not locals there were lots of big and little things that we could not personally attend to, and Holly took care of them all for us. She also has an amazing photographer that makes your property stand out amongst the competition. We sold our property so fast, we didn't have time to mentally prepare to let it go. :)
3/24/23Amy Rosen
Google Review
Holly was incredibly easy to work with and responsive throughout our entire process. We live out of town from where the house was being sold, and Holly always made sure our home was available to be shown and always kept us informed of any updates. Towards the end of our escrow, weather caused delays preventing us from the ability to move out. Holly was so kind and effective at working between both parties to make sure everyone was happy and comfortable. A successful sale well done!
3/16/23Lisa Enciso
Google Review
Holly is an absolute rockstar!!! She is honest, trustworthy, and doesn’t make you feel like you are being sold on anything. She tells it like it is and is an all-around super cool person. Professional, responsive, and able to make you feel comfortable through every step of the transaction. I plan on using Holly for any future real estate needs and you should to.
3/12/23Ernie Huang
Google Review
Holly was introduced to me by my property management company. Through out several months when the house was on the market, Holly has been extremely helpful, very patient and most importantly very timely addressed all our issues and offered good solutions. The house was recently sold with a fair market value and we are extremely happy with her professional services. I would recommend anyone who are thinking about selling their properties in Big Bear Areas. Ernie Huang
1/26/23Dennis Armold
Google Review
Holly did an outstanding job on our sale and escrow. Constantly
communicating with us and keeping us up to date on everything as they transpired.
The escrow was unusual in many ways and Holly worked all the issues and completed the sale. Highly recommend her for any real estate help you may need in Big Bear.
1/18/23PAT DE LA HUNT
Google Review
11/11/22Mark Simpson
Google Review
Holly was such a pleasure to work with! My wife and I were able to find our first home in Big Bear by leaning on Hollys expertise. She was patient with us and able to identify exactly what we wanted. She also may be the coolest realtor in Big Bear!
11/7/22Katarina Jenkin
Google Review
Holly is the best! She took care of my husband and I this year, and the process was so smooth and easy. She answered all of our questions quickly and was so easy to work with! The best in Big Bear!
10/18/22Lori McPeck
Google Review
Talk about results!!! Holly has the local knowledge of Big Bear and the work ethic to get it done. She reeled in the buyers and got us more than we ever expected for our property. Super professional and super cool! Thank you Holly for a GREAT selling experience!
10/17/22Drew Bizzaro
Google Review
Absolutely the best experience from listing to selling our property. A true professional.
6/10/22Sueyn Tang
Google Review
Holly helped us with the purchase of a rental property in Big Bear during a seller’s market when inventory was low and competition was fierce. She always made herself available to view properties with short notice and promptly drafted offers, which was important in such a fierce market. Holly continued to execute through close of escrow, and was able to get us everything we asked for of the Seller. Thank you Holly!
6/8/22Carol Crosby
Google Review
Holly was a blessing to work with. She was absolutely a breath of fresh air and very professional. Holly is an amazing realtor so blessed to have worked with her on the purchase of our home.
6/7/22Amy Cash
Google Review
Holly made our home buying experience effortless!
6/3/22Sarah Krane
Google Review
Holly was amazing in helping us purchase our home in Big Bear. She is extremely knowledgeable and was able to answer all of our questions. Holly made herself available to us day or night throughout the process of our home purchase.
6/1/22Tom Lee
Google Review
A consummate professional, Holly did not rest until she found us the perfect home! Holly's extensive knowledge of the Big Bear area plus her level of experience makes her the perfect realtor for the mountain. Add to that a great personality and you have it all! Highly recommended.
5/31/22Amanda Bartle
Google Review
Holly was great to work with! Easy to schedule with and found us the perfect spot!
5/31/22Tammy Valenzuela
Google Review
Holly is an incredible agent. She was diligent when issues and concerns came up. Her hard work and dedication made us feel like she really cared and of course it was a success. She got the job done!!!
5/31/22Arthur Valenzuela
Google Review
what can i say, Holly worked hard for us on this journey to purchase our first home, even though at times we encountered some issues along the way she never strayed from the objective and we are forever grateful for the hard work she put in for us, love you Holly
5/31/22Juneffer Gambin
Google Review
Holly was great! She closed the sale in record time for us, 17 days! She was very responsive, easy to communicate with and straight to the point. Highly recommend Holly to anyone looking to purchase or sell their home.
5/31/22Bill Kirkland
Google Review
You just won't do any better than going with Holly Gardner and her team. I recently sold a property in Sugarloaf. It initially went smoothly and quickly but there was a title glitch (my problem) that delayed the sale for several months. Holly worked with me and the buyer to keep the deal in place until the title problem was settled. Once that cleared, the final process took just a few days to complete and there are now a happy seller and a happy buyer.
I just can't say enough about the care and professionalism shown by Holly.
Why would you go with anyone else?
5/31/22Chardelle Smith
Google Review
We can’t thank Holly enough for all her help and knowledge. She was quick to get back to us and answered all our questions/concerns. The process to sell our house was stress free thanks to Holly.
12/30/21Arnold Urias
Google Review
This is who you work with when you want integrity instead of a salesperson. Holly focuses on what is best for clients; no hidden agendas and tricky sales tactic's to worry about here, this is someone you can trust; ask me how I know. I have been originating on the mountain since 97 , I have provided financing for serval of her clients and and Holly actually sold one my personal homes.
11/11/21Richard Dunbar
Google Review
Holly Gardner, was the best Relator I have ever dealt with on selling my Property and also the purchase of my new property at the same time in Big Bear. Holly had everything done and closed within three weeks and was a very smooth transition. I would recommend Holly and her team to anyone buying in Big Bear. Thank you Holly!!
9/10/21Michael Tindell
Google Review
holly made selling out rental cabin effortless, she took care of everything and made the experience easy for us. In all my years of buying and selling home this was by far the best experience. Thank you again holly! We will see you again when we sell or by our next property.
9/5/21Reyna Civitate
Google Review
8/16/21Darla Rodrigo
Google Review
Holly represented me in selling my vacation home in Sugarloaf. I was pleased with the outcome of her representation. She promptly listed the property, and it sold within 6 weeks of it being listed. Thank you!
8/13/21Sandee
Google Review
Holly was our realtor when we bought our cabin in Big Bear and we wouldn't think of going to anyone else when it was time for us to sell. She handled all the details of the sale in such a professional manner, from arranging the photographs, to representing us during the very quick sale, to following up when escrow closed. We wholeheartedly recommend Holly for your real estate needs.
7/8/21Vince Francis
Google Review
Holly has been a great agent and consultant for two transactions over 3 years. Always very responsive, knowledgeable, and gets great results. Highest recommendations for Holly! Thank you.
7/3/21Barbara Woolf
Google Review
Holly was very kind and professional to work with. Always following up with me and keeping in touch. Answered any questions I had. Made the selling process easy. Took care of everything. Very satisfied with her services. I highly recommend her and her company. Thanks for everything again holly.
6/29/21Jozef Soltysik
Google Review
1/4/21Paula Mieszerski
Google Review
Definitely would (and have) recommended Holly Gardener as the realtor of choice. She’s honest and professional. Holly stays on top of the paperwork, easily explains mortgage documents, and responds to emails/calls promptly. Holly will keep your interests and needs first as you look for or sell your home. Would use her again in a heart beat.
1/4/21Dana Sue Naclerio
Google Review
Holly was amazing. This was the first time my husband and I sold a house so we were not very knowledgeable on how things worked. Holly was very helpful and walked through everything. I would highly recommend Holly Gardner.
1/4/21Alice Vorotch (Alsh2012)
Google Review
Holly was an excellent agent. We would use her again at the first opportunity.
1/4/21Bradley Johnson
Google Review
Holly helped us buy our second home in Big Bear Lake this year. Everything was made incredibly simple and we would definitely use her again.
11/4/20Tiffany Derrick
Google Review
Holly always went the extra mile to make sure we were happy. She is professional and helpful. I would recommend her to anyone who wants the best service.
10/7/20Walter Lezameta
Google Review
Holly helped us all away through the purchasing process given details about what is next. Making an offer, signing documents, inspection and telling the sellers to fix what it needed to be fixed before closing escrow. She gave us details about insurance, utilities and service companies in Big Bear, CA. She walked the extra mile with us working with my schedule because I live 2 hrs away from there and met sometimes late to help us. We are happy with this house purchase in Sugarloaf CA. and we recommend Holly Gardner as your realtor. Thank you Holly.
10/4/20Jason Lezameta
Google Review
10/4/20Phillip Thebodeau
Google Review
9/22/20Charles Gallinat
Google Review
9/22/20coleen aldrich
Google Review
Holly followed through just as she said she would! I have high expectations of people after working in healthcare 37 years! She did not disappoint! I would recommend her to anyone buying a property or selling one! Thank you Holly for making selling our cabin, a great experience ♥️
8/17/20Mimi Simmons
Google Review
Holly is the best! She made our home buying process so simple and easy! We dealt with a lot of ups and downs through the process, but Holly handled everything so perfectly and was such a huge help and support. She smoothed out any and all details and was there to handle EVERYTHING throughout the process of home buying. She is the best realtor in Big Bear and who I will always recommend to anyone, without fail! We love Holly!
8/17/20Savannah Lee Simmons
Google Review
Holly is the best realtor in Big Bear! Seriously one of the most responsive, kind, and thoughtful agents ever. She is a true gift. She also has so many connections with so many businesses on that mountain that she can help refer to any trustworthy businesses for any needed housework/contracting! She is truly the most well rounded agent ever. If you’re buying a home in Big Bear, it only makes sense to go with Holly as your realtor!
She worked with us closely for months to find the perfect home and we really found the PERFECT home. I wish I could rate her 6 stars. So thankful!!!
8/4/20Chas Richardson
Google Review
Holly was so helpful. My husband and I are first time buyers and really had no clue. Any questions we had, she answered. She helped us find the home of our dreams and fought for us the whole way. I would HIGHLY recommend using Holly as your real estate agent.
Thank you so much Holly
C & M
7/24/20Nicki McGee
Google Review
Holly was always available, very helpful and a pleasure to work with throughout the process.
7/11/20Gary Flanders
Google Review
We have bought and sold many houses in our 50 years of marriage. We have lived in 9 different states from one end of the country to the other. It was a spontaneous decision to sell our home in Big Bear California and we could not have been more pleased to have the best realtor we have ever encountered: Holly Gardner. We were so impressed by her constant attention as she anticipated every element of the sale. We’ve never experienced this type of personal professional service. Please, if you would like to buy or sell in this area, do yourself a favor and contact Holly.
7/11/20Zenith DeRosier
Google Review
Holly was great to work with. She's a real estate expert and really helped my wife and I thru every step of the escrow process.
5/30/20Steve
Google Review
Holly was not only professional and helpful but she responded quickly each and every time I reached out to her. While selling just a couple of small lots she treated this transaction as if it were hundreds of thousands of dollars and I appreciated it. I would certainly recommend her to anyone looking to invest or sell in the Big Bear area! Thank you Holly :-)
5/26/20Ellen Liguori
Google Review
Holly was great. The selling of my cabin was effortlessly. She was on top of the process and available to me for any questions. I would recommend her highly to anyone needing to sell their property.
3/17/20Clarissa Cowan
Google Review
Holly helped us sell our family big bear home quick an efficiently. She was attentive and responsive. Made home selling as simple as possible. Great to work with Holly-we recommend her highly.
1/29/20Kristin Schofield
Google Review
My husband and I just sold our home in Big Bear with Holly. Our experience was seamless and easy. She has been in Big Bear a long time and has an extensive knowledge of the area. Our home sold in two days! We couldn't be happier with the process. I only wish I could use her with our purchase in Arizona!
11/25/19Ryan Barnett
Google Review
As a first time home buyer, Holly took the time to explain each step of the process and worked hard to make sure we got the home of our dreams. I would recommend Holly to anyone buying or selling a home.
9/13/19Joe Mineiro
Google Review
Holly is the most professional and downright nicest real estate agent I’ve ever worked with. She consistently went above and beyond throughout the process of my home purchase. Having lived all her life in the area, she also had great insight about the neighborhoods and local area, as well as an amazing reputation as being “the best in town” among all those I worked with, like the inspector and escrow company. If you are looking to buy or sell a home in the Big Bear area, you simply cannot do better than Holly as your real estate agent. My standards are very high, and she exceeded them. If you choose Holly, I have no doubt you will be glad you did!
8/19/19David Berman
Google Review
Holly Gardner is simply the best real estate agent I've ever had the pleasure of working with. She's responsible, takes initiative and fights for her clients. If you are looking to purchase or sell a home in Big Bear there is simply no better person to have on your side than Holly Gardner.
7/28/19Larry Campbell
Google Review
Holly went overboard in helping me in selling out home in Big Bear Lake. If it were not for her help - I would have had a lot of problems.
She is the best and if I were ever to need a realtor - she would be the only one that I would use. They really don't come much better!
3/21/19Alyssa Roenigk
Google Review
We've been visiting Big Bear for a few years, and on NYE, decided we wanted to start looking for a home to buy. Less than THREE MONTHS later, we closed on our new home in Boulder Bay. That is thanks to Holly. She made the process smooth and easy, went above and beyond when we couldn't be on location and is so knowledgable about the area and fun to work with. We recommend her so highly!
3/7/19Andrew Crabtree
Google Review
Holly. Is. The. Best. I spoke to a number of different realtors when I was beginning my Big Bear real estate exploration and Holly was the runaway favorite. She was patient with me (as a first time home-buyer and overall nit-pick) and she was excitable and fun which made the entire process more enjoyable. She brought me more - and BETTER - options to look at because she listened to what I was looking for and seemed genuinely excited about finding the perfect fit. A fun, easy, personable process that couldn't have gone smoother. Only the highest of recommendations for Holly!
3/4/19Kam Hansen
Google Review
Holly is a fantastic real estate agent. After showing us houses in the rain, we bought one! The transaction was smooth. I highly recommend Holly for your real estate needs.
3/3/19Erica Linares
Google Review
Holly is knowledgeable, experienced, and a consumate professional. She was a great communicator and can’t recommend her enough. You’re in good hands with Holly Gardner as your Real Estate Agent. Thanks so much Holly!
3/3/19Hugo Bautista
Google Review
Holly was absolutely PHENOMENAL. She was always on time, well prepared, and very patient. We live in LA, which is a couple hours from BB: and Holly made everything so easy and accessible. A true gem in real estate.
3/2/19John Kats
Google Review
Holly is the Best Real Estate Agent I have ever worked with
2/19/19Jorge Rivero
Google Review
2/18/19Mike Dills
Google Review
2/18/19Christina Marmolejo
Google Review
2/18/19Robin Hart
Google Review
Holly is very professional, and she gives back to her community.
4/21/18JAMIE
Google Review
4/20/18B Gereghty
Google Review
She is awesome !
4/20/18Arleen Lonning
Google Review
AMAZING in every way! Very good realtor. Raised on the mountain. Knows how to please a buyer for sure. LOVE our mountain cabin THANK YOU Holly for a job well done and a beautiful buying experience!
4/19/18Chase Gardner
Google Review

