Kara Hinshaw

Santa Claus IN

5.0stars, 21 Reviews

Key Associates Signature Realty

448 Closed Sales

$92.9M Total Value

$29K - $1.2M Price Range

$207.3K Average Price

Prior five years

About Kara

Kara Hinshaw took over ownership from her parents who started Key Associates in 1975. She has been in the real estate business for 16 years and currently owns and operates the business in three locations Spencer, Dubois, and Vanderburgh County. Kara is a graduate of Purdue University with a degree in Industrial Engineering. Kara worked for 10 years as a Global Commodity Manager in North Carolina for IBM, Flextronics, and GlaxoSmithKline. During this time, she developed great negotiation skills working globally to procure and write contracts for these Fortune 500 companies. Kara started her real estate career when she moved back to Indiana to be with her family. Kara’s goals for Key Associates are to grow a brokerage that operates as a team across all Southern Indiana. She believes in supporting new and existing agents with tools, support, and training with what she needed when starting her real estate career. She has a passion for real estate and loves helping clients and her agents within her brokerage.

Home Types: House, Lot/Land, Condo, Commercial, MultiFamily, Manufactured

Years of Experience: 17

Education: Purdue University

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$13,550,530

Average Sale Price

$225,842

Price Range

$2K - $500K

Neighborhoods Kara Has the Most Experience In

Santa Claus

242 Sales
Huntingburg

19 Sales
Chandler

6 Sales
Newburgh

5 Sales
Boonville

4 Sales
Tell City

4 Sales

Kara's Recent Active Listings

$325,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,674 Sq Ft
10988 Indiana 62

Ferdinand, IN
Welcome to this fully remodeled home in a serene country setting! Sitting on 0.78 acres, this property blends modern upgrades with peaceful surroundings. Inside, you’ll find a spacious open-concept design with vinyl flooring throughout. The beautifully remodeled kitchen features custom Amish-built cabinets, a massive island, gas range, tiled backsplash, and sleek black stainless steel

Kara Hinshaw Key Associates Signature Realty

$1,649,500
- 5 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 5,795 Sq Ft
707 W Shepherds Ln

Santa Claus, IN
Start Showing Date: 9/16/2025 Stunning Lakefront Retreat on Lake Noel. Welcome to this 100% remodeled showplace on a corner lot overlooking Lake Noel. This home combines luxury finishes, thoughtful design, and incredible indoor-outdoor living spaces. Step inside the open floor plan, where the kitchen is the true centerpiece—featuring granite countertops, upgraded appliances, a massive island, and

Kara Hinshaw Key Associates Signature Realty

$118,000
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,819 Sq Ft
615 E Gum St

Evansville, IN
Welcome to this charming and up-to-date home located in downtown Evansville! Featuring 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, this property offers a spacious dining area and large family room perfect for gatherings. Enjoy your morning coffee or evening relaxation on the cute front porch. Conveniently situated near all the amenities of downtown, this home is ideal for comfortable living with a touch of city

Kara Hinshaw Key Associates Signature Realty

$265,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,468 Sq Ft
484 S Winter Ln

Santa Claus, IN
Welcome home to 484 S Winter Lane—a welcoming, well-maintained ranch nestled in the heart of Christmas Lake Village’s Polar Shores neighborhood. Built in 2006 and set on a generous, level 0.33-acre lot, this three-bedroom, two-bath home features a timeless exterior of brick, stone, and vinyl siding. Inside, enjoy 1,468 square feet of open, one-level living with vaulted comfort and functional

Kara Hinshaw Key Associates Signature Realty

$270,000
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,798 Sq Ft
2704 E Walnut St

Evansville, IN
Fully Remodeled from Top to Bottom – Like New! Welcome to 2704 E Walnut Lane, a beautifully updated home in a convenient Evansville location just minutes from the Lloyd Expressway. Every detail of this home has been thoughtfully renovated, making it feel brand new. The main level features a bright and open floor plan that seamlessly connects the living, dining, and kitchen areas—perfect for

Kara Hinshaw Key Associates Signature Realty

$200,000
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 1,905 Sq Ft
564 E Graham Place

Bloomington, IN
Kara Hinshaw Key Associates Signature Realty

$262,500
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,450 Sq Ft
4285 N Elm St

Richland, IN
New Construction by Smith Homes! This affordable 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home is the lowest-priced new build within 15 miles of downtown Newburgh. Located on a flat lot in the quiet town of Richland, Indiana, this home offers peaceful small-town living with quick access to city amenities. Featuring a functional layout and modern finishes, it’s scheduled to be finished just in time for the upcoming

Kara Hinshaw Key Associates Signature Realty

$5,000
- Land
- 0.38 Acre
- $13,158 per Acre
316 Tinsel Cir

Santa Claus, IN
Enjoy all of the fabulous amenities of Christmas Lake Village; including 3 (three) lakes spread across over 230 acres (Christmas Lake, Lake Holly, & Lake Noel) that allow boating, fishing, and water skiing. Located near the Recreation Center, there is a beach/swimming area with a diving board, & beach volleyball. Multiple parks throughout this gated community include basketball courts, a tennis

Kara Hinshaw Key Associates Signature Realty

$160,000
- 4 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,808 Sq Ft
232 Fernwood Dr

Evansville, IN
Kara Hinshaw Key Associates Signature Realty

10/31/23Anna Sherbatova

Google Review

Best Realstatelicence Experience Ever any difficult questions come to best resolution

9/21/23Neil Guess

Google Review

We were completely satisfied with whole experience with the selling of our home. Kara is very professional, knowledgeable and kept us informed all the way through the selling process. Our home sold 5 hours after going on the market! We highly recommend using Kara to sell your home!!

9/14/23Nathan Lueken

Google Review

Kara does a fantastic job. I have bought and sold real estate from Key. Kara handled both transactions, she is extremely knowledgeable and most importantly she communicates with you every step of the way.

Kara Hinshaw

(812) 567-1876

Key Associates Signature Realty

(812) 567-1876

Kara Hinshaw

About Kara

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Kara Has the Most Experience In

Kara's Listings and Deals

Kara's Recent Active Listings

Kara's Reviews