Hi there! I’m Krissy (Gustinger) Carnahan — your friendly, go-to real estate agent here in the beautiful Florida Keys. Whether you’re buying, selling, or just dreaming of a home in paradise, I’m here to help make it happen.
I grew up in Miami and have been lucky enough to call the Keys my second home since 1967 when my family purchased property here. That deep-rooted connection has given me a true understanding of island life — from the hidden gems and local hot spots to the tides, canals, and neighborhoods that make the Keys so special.
I earned my degree in Counseling & Rehabilitation from Marshall University and went on to complete a Master’s in Higher Education at Florida State University. My journey has taken me across the country, including a stint in Los Alamos, New Mexico, where I worked in real estate with Karen Hawkins at Los Alamos Pajarito / ReMax Realtors. In. 2003, the call of the ocean brought me back home to the Keys, where I became a licensed Community Association Manager and spent nearly two decades protecting other peoples investments while managing many condominium associations right here in paradise.
While I loved my CAM career, my heart was always in Real Estate. In 2021, I made the leap back into sales, got licensed again, and began working as the Office Manager at ROG Engage the Keys. Today, I’m proud to continue my journey with Realty ONE Group Destination — a company that truly believes in supporting and empowering its agents.
I share my island home with two lovable English Labradors and one spunky Havanese, and when I’m not helping clients, you’ll probably find me out on or under the water, walking the beach, volunteering for the many organizations I am involved with and or enjoying a local event with friends and family.
Real estate in the Florida Keys isn’t just about buying or selling a home — it’s about finding your place in a community and lifestyle that’s unlike anywhere else. I’d love the chance to be part of your journey.
Reach out anytime — I’m always here to help!
Home Types:
Manufactured, Condo, House, Townhouse, Lot/Land
Years of Experience:
4
