Nicole Cotter

Montello WI

Cotter Realty LLC

124 Closed Sales

$22.1M Total Value

$59.9K - $492.5K Price Range

$178.1K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Nicole

Home Types: House, Lot/Land, Manufactured, Commercial, Townhouse

Years of Experience: 10

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	12
Total Value	$2,362,400
Average Sale Price	$196,867
Price Range	$26K - $490K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	5
Total Value	$1,155,000
Average Sale Price	$231,000
Price Range	$55K - $415K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	24
Total Value	$4,326,700
Average Sale Price	$180,279
Price Range	$11K - $490K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	12
Total Value	$2,902,125
Average Sale Price	$241,844
Price Range	$35K - $458K

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	88
Total Value	$15,696,050
Average Sale Price	$178,364
Price Range	$6K - $493K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	36
Total Value	$6,385,425
Average Sale Price	$177,373
Price Range	$21K - $458K

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Nicole is Experienced In

Portage

1 Sale
Ripon

1 Sale
Weston

1 Sale

Nicole's Recent Active Listings

$320,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,456 Sq Ft
W3959 Elk Ave

Montello, WI
Discover your own private sanctuary nestled in 5 acres of nature. Surrounded by woods this 3 bedroom 2 bath home allows you to leave all the hustle and bustle behind. Open concept with your kitchen and living room area provides the perfect set up for enjoying time together. Office/Den allows the perfect spot for a crafter or those who work from home. Nice size pantry in the kitchen and patio

Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$425,000
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,650 Sq Ft
356 Sherman Ave

Markesan, WI
Perched upon the hilltop you will find this quality built 4 bed 3 bath home. Overlooking it's 3 acres with a short stroll to Lake Puckaway this one is calling your name. The large Sunroom is perfect for your morning coffee or entertaining your guests. Plenty of sunlight brightens the main living area, large workable kitchen for the chef in the family. Family room on the lower level walks out to

Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$30,000
- Land
- 0.84 Acre
- $35,714 per Acre
L51 Eagle Cir

Mecan, WI
This is where your dream starts...bring your plans to this 0.84 acre lot on the Golf Course. Situated right in the heart of recreation country, there is so much at your fingertips. Golf, ATV/UTV, area lakes, fishing, hunting, hiking, biking, restaurants, shopping, Princeton Flea Market, the list goes on. Step out of the hustle and bustle and into the "up north" way of life. Soil test already

Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$12,900
- Land
- 0.86 Acre
- $15,000 per Acre
L16 Sandy Pines Ct

Redgranite, WI
Just north of Redgranite, this level and private wooded lot in Sandy Pines Estates offers an excellent opportunity for your dreams. The property totals 0.86 acre with a peaceful, natural setting surrounded by mature pines. A private septic system and well will be required, as none are currently installed. adjacent lot also available, buy both and expand your piece of paradise.

Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$19,000
- Land
- 0.47 Acre
- $40,426 per Acre
L14 Oak Rd

Marquette, WI
Located in the heart of a sought-after recreational area, this wooded lot offers a peaceful natural setting with convenient access to outdoor adventure. Enjoy deeded access to Lake Puckaway, the Oak Road boat landing, and the Grand River Wildlife Area—all just a short walk from the property. The surrounding landscape features a rich blend of open marsh and emergent cattail wetlands, upland

Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$19,000
- Land
- 0.47 Acre
- $40,426 per Acre
L16 Oak Rd

Marquette, WI
Located in the heart of a sought-after recreational area, this wooded lot offers a peaceful natural setting with convenient access to outdoor adventure. Enjoy deeded access to Lake Puckaway, the Oak Road boat landing, and the Grand River Wildlife Area—all just a short walk from the property. The surrounding landscape features a rich blend of open marsh and emergent cattail wetlands, upland

Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$899,000
- Land
- 27 Acres
- $33,582 per Acre
W3021 County Road C

Montello, WI
A true Montello hidden treasure—this property is one you must see to fully appreciate. The impressive 9,000 sq. ft. building is designed for versatility, featuring four overhead doors, full insulation, concrete floors, heating, and plumbing with a finished bathroom. Whether you envision a business venture, rental storage, or personal use, this space offers endless possibilities. Beyond the

Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$549,990
- Land
- 26 Acres
- $21,105 per Acre
L1 County Road C

Montello, WI
A rare find—this 26+ acre property opens up to a private retreat ideal for camping, recreation, and relaxation. Multiple RV sites with electric service are already in place, complemented by a spacious garage for convenient storage. The crown jewel of this property is the impressive 1,900+ feet of winding frontage along the Fox River, offering unmatched natural beauty and direct access to the

Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$23,500
- Land
- 0.74 Acre
- $31,757 per Acre
LOT 73 Pine Dr

Montello, WI
Motivated Seller: This level 0.73-acre lot (150' x 213') offers an excellent opportunity to build your future home. A recent soil percolation test indicates suitability for a conventional, at-grade septic system. A private septic and well will be required, as none are currently installed. Power and commercial fiber-optic internet are available at the road for added convenience. Located on a quiet

Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

Recently Sold

$199,900

Sold May 15, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 760 Sq Ft
W4009 County Road C

Montello, WI
- $263/SF
- 10 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $200K
Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$490,000

Sold Apr 20, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,724 Sq Ft
N6270 County Road B

Westfield, WI
- 16% Below List
- $180/SF
- 91 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $502K
Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$130,000

Sold Nov 19, 2025
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 952 Sq Ft
N3540 Myra Ln

Mecan, WI
- 1% Above List
- $137/SF
- 5 Days On Market
Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$218,500

Sold Nov 14, 2025
- 2 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 1,364 Sq Ft
W1010 Laurie Ln

Montello, WI
- 3% Below List
- $160/SF
- 16 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $226K
Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$33,000

Sold Sep 9, 2025
- Land
- 1.30 Acre Lot
L96 Golf Ridge Cir

Mecan, WI
- 7% Below List
- 336 Days On Market
Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$335,000

Sold Aug 22, 2025
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,794 Sq Ft
W5211 Fern Ave

Montello, WI
- 1% Below List
- $187/SF
- 7 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $321K
Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$370,000

Sold Aug 5, 2025
- 3 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 3,264 Sq Ft
N4774 11th Dr

Montello, WI
- 14% Below List
- $113/SF
- 98 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $404K
Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$130,000

Sold May 23, 2025
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 916 Sq Ft
223 Doty St

Montello, WI
- 10% Below List
- $142/SF
- 15 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $133K
Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

$198,000

Sold May 19, 2025
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 900 Sq Ft
N3431 W Tomahawk Trail

Montello, WI
- 7% Below List
- $220/SF
- 19 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $198K
Nicole Cotter Cotter Realty LLC

Awards and Designations

NAR - National Association of Realtors

Nicole Cotter

(920) 744-3214

Homes for Sale by City

Nicole Cotter

About Nicole

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Nicole is Experienced In

Nicole's Listings and Deals

Nicole's Recent Active Listings

Recently Sold

Awards and Designations