









About Stefanie
Transaction History
- 1 Year
- 2 Year
- 5 Year
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
1 Year View by Quarter
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
2 Year View by Quarter
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
5 Year View
Neighborhoods Stefanie Has the Most Experience In
Stefanie's Listings and Deals
Stefanie's Active Listings
-
$260,000
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,056 Sq Ft
- 4811 Betsy Dr
- Franklin, OH
Welcome to 4811 Betsy Drive, a fully refreshed ranch home on a flat, half-acre lot in the heart of Franklin. Step inside to discover a bright and modern interior with all-new flooring, carpet, paint, lighting, baseboards, and a beautifully remodeled bathroom, all completed in 2025. The kitchen features brand new appliances, new roof and front door add to the home's worry-free appeal. Cozy up by
Stefanie Creech Comey & Shepherd
-
$365,000
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 3,200 Sq Ft
- 7700 Mourning Dove Ln
- Hamilton, OH
Fantastic 4 bedroom 2.5 bath home- 2400 square feet. Enjoy time in the second floor loft or convert to a 5th bedroom. Second floor laundry and finished lower level with NEW carpet. Freshly painted in the lower level and front 2 rooms. Custom pantry, newer appliances with a double oven range!! Fenced backyard with low HOA!
Stefanie Creech Comey & Shepherd REALTORS
-
$400,000
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,000 Sq Ft
- 7891 Ell Char Ct
- West Chester, OH
Come inside to the warmth and beauty this 4 bed 2.5 bath home has to offer. Drive on down the quaint cul de sac street and enjoy all the peacefulness this property has to offer. The .69 acre flat lot offers an expansive backyard ready for a swing set, pool, or mini soccer field. The home has had several renovations including new paint throughout, new lvp flooring, carpet, new electrical panel,
Stefanie Creech Comey & Shepherd REALTORS
Awards and Designations
- National Association of REALTORS
Stefanie's Reviews
12/10/23Jayde Hoffmann
Google Review
Buying a home is an easy process with Stefanie! Very professional and knows the business well. I am very happy with our new home. (:
12/10/23Ethan Oldfield
Google Review
Stefanie is the absolute best ! I am a first time home buyer with my fiance and she taught us everything we needed to know. She knew what we had in mind for a home and went above and beyond showing us houses almost every Saturday morning until she found us the perfect home. I will recommend her to anyone I know that is buying a home because she truly cares about her homebuyers.
12/10/23Dani Suddleson
Google Review
Stefanie is an incredible realtor! She took the pressure of selling off of us and went above and beyond to give us a relaxed experience.
12/10/23Jeffrey Joehnk
Google Review
Unlimited patience, vast knowledge of the local market and very well connected are just a few of the many wonderful attributes that Stephanie possess to help her clients
10/31/23Melissa Orr
Google Review
Stefanie and Kim proved they are top notch go getters in the real estate business. Stefanie worked with many contractors on our behalf, staged our house, and treated us with the utmost respect! 10/10 will use her in the future!
10/6/23Rachel Higgins
Google Review
Stefanie was great to work with when buying my first home! She was dedicated, patient and hard working all throughout the home buying process. I would highly recommend!
8/8/23Robin Sutherland
Google Review
Stefanie is so easy to work with. She took time to explain every step of the selling process. She put in a lot of effort to ensure small repairs were made and she made sure my house was staged to show at its best to get me a great price. I highly recommend her and her team.
7/19/23Fritz Huebner
Google Review
Had a really good experience with Stephanie and her team sold my mom and dad's house about a month ago she was very knowledgeable include me in on a lot of things I didn't know she was very helpful and a pleasure to work with thank you Stephanie for everything you've done
6/23/23Elliott Cade
Google Review
Best no-nonsense person you could ever work with! She makes everything about the entire process so easy that you sit here and think "there HAS to be something I need to do on my own, right?" NOPE, she takes care of just about everything that needs to be done when it comes to buying/selling. Look no further than here for anything you need realty related!
6/23/23Teresa Rumping
Google Review
Absolutely the best realtor I’ve ever worked with! If I could I’d give her more than 5 stars. Worked hard to get us an amazing deal on the house we bought and on the house we sold. I truly believe we wouldn’t have received 40 SHOWINGS AND 14 OFFERS, all above asking price, if we had gone with anyone else!
6/7/23Julie Turner
Google Review
Stefanie is incredibly!! She has definitely became apart of my family. I would recommend her to anyone. I can’t wait to buy a forever home with her in the future!
6/7/23Taylor Weeks
Google Review
Stefanie was such a pleasure to work with on selling our house and finding our dream home. She was always readily available and great at communicating. Her knowledge on the different areas in town is endless which really helped us make the best decisions for our family. We can’t thank her enough! Would highly recommend her!!
5/8/23Sandra Ahmed
Google Review
Being a first time buyer and a solo buyer, Stephanie walked me through every step of the way ensuring I always understood my options. She is a wealth of knowledge, resources etc and doesn’t hesitate to offer her guidance. You can’t go wrong with having Stephanie on your side. 💕
4/28/23Renee Higgins
Google Review
Stefanie was amazing to work with when looking to buy my first home! As a first time homeowner, she walked me through the process step by step and helped me out even after moving in. Highly recommend!
4/28/23Joshua Forbis
Google Review
Kim Kelly did a very great outstanding over the top with finding us a house before was even listed how we were having issues with every house being listed and getting sold fast she did great for us Got the house under contract real fast and shield the deal yesterday and closed gladly appreciate it that we're finally in a home that we no longer have to rent and went above and beyond to find us at home for us to start our next new chapter in life thank you so much to everyone her and everyone on her team
4/28/23Teresa Williams
Google Review
Stefanie was a wonderful agent! She was always there for me, very patient listened to what I wanted and communicated effectively. I would highly recommend her.
4/28/23Sheila Osborne
Google Review
Kim kelley was our agent, she called us every time she found a house she thought would fit us. She found a house that wasn't even on the market yet, we were the first to see it and a month later we are moving in. She helped me with all my questions. Kept me updated on everything. She is professional, and relatable. I am very grateful for her help and I would definitely call her again if I ever decide to sell or buy. Ty Kim! ☺️
12/12/22Ric Shaw
Google Review
Stefanie and her team are the best !
They go the extra mile to get the job done with no issues. I highly recommend her and her team to sell and buy.
Thanks for all you did !
9/12/22Katrina Terry
Google Review
Stefanie worked with me for 2 years on the sale of my large family home. Some would say it sold in a day, but the reality is it took 2 years of her guidance. And then finding our new home - every time something popped up, Stefanie was the enthusiastic cheerleader willing to make the trek all over Cincinnati to help find our next stop. Over 60 houses! And she guided us through. Closed on both properties within 4 hours of each other. And we are so happy. Thank you Stefanie and team!
9/11/22Kate B
Google Review
Above and beyond. Of all the words I can think of to describe Stefanie, above and beyond seems to be the best way to describe her approach to everything she does. From finding us the right property, to giving us moving supplies, to staging our house for photography and sale, and beyond! Everything she did (and continues to do) for us seems like more than I ever expected a realtor to do. She seems to have the phone number for every honest professional in the greater Cincinnati area (painters, electricians, even water proofing professionals). When a waterproofing company wanted to charge us nearly $40,000, she referred me to her waterproofing professionals. They showed me where our house already has waterproofing and that we only needed to spend $1,200 to fix a couple cracks. If it wasn’t for Stefanie we could have easily spent way more than necessary. But that’s how Stefanie works- she’s always looking out to make sure her customers are not taken advantage of. She continually goes above and beyond watching out for their best interest. I would never consider undertaking any real estate transaction without Stefanie by my side. She’s the most trustworthy and honest realtor in the greater Cincinnati area.
9/11/22Eric Gross
Google Review
I have worked with Stefanie multiple times and she’s the best! She’s knowledgeable and always goes above and beyond for every client. One of the best agents I have worked with!
6/18/22Jonathan Lipsitz
Google Review
The market has been brutal for buyers. NO way do we get such a special house without Stefanie and her team. So many bidders but Stefanie found a way to package our offer to appeal perfectly to the sellers. Then before we even move in she has people in the house making repairs and getting the house ready. We feel so lucky!
6/6/22Blair Blazey
Google Review
6/1/22Michael Dragon
Google Review
5/31/22La Donna Storer
Google Review
I learned of Stefanie and her amazing team when my friend sold her house. The extra effort and attention that Stefanie put into that sale really stood out to me, but I had no idea what that truly entailed until we selected her to sell our home.
Our home was a one-of-a-kind property that had no comps for the surrounding area. That makes the selling process very tricky with appraisals. The Show Time Team came in and rearranged furniture, brought several staging items, spent four hours making sure everything would look amazing in the listing pictures, and even changed out a light fixture that didn’t fit the room. When they were done, my husband said, “We should buy this house!” That’s how impressive the house looked. The pictures of course popped and enticed several showings. They even staged the outdoor living area and pool.
We are thrilled to say that we sold our home in a cash offer that went as beautifully as any closing could have gone. Stefanie was extremely instrumental in having contacts in plumbing, electrical, and radon mitigation that made all requested repairs no problem at all. She knows everyone!!
You owe it to yourself and to your investment in your property to call Stefanie when you want to sell your house. You will get top dollar while working with a professional who knows how to get things done.
She’s a Rockstar!! ❤️
5/31/22Jim Dragon
Google Review
Being in retail management my whole life restaurants and grocery retail I have found that there is a small handful of tools available to you that makes you successful.
Your character, your tenacity, your standards you set for yourself and the standards you set for the people around you.
Being a leader you must possess these skills if you are to be successful.
I have found Stephanie Creech to have these qualities and then some.
She accesses a situation brilliantly and quickly, organizes a game plan with a quickness then implements her plan with out delay. She has kept me informed every step of the way through the selling process of my home. I was very satisfied before the sale, through the sale and after. I'm greatful to have had her at my side through this arduous and quick process of selling.
Would I use her again? Absolutely, would I recommend her and Comey @ Shepherd to others? IN A HEART BEAT....
Jim Dragon
4/9/22DANIA KEYS
Google Review
HANDS DOWN, THE BEST REALTOR EXPERIENCE I HAVE EVER HAD!!! Five Star Service from a Five Star Agent!!!
I was fortunate to be referred to Stephanie Creech by my estate attorney. This was my third home sale, but my first time selling a home in Probate. My Grandparents lived in this home nearly 60 years. This was our family home. And Stephanie Creech became like a family member.
You want your Realtor to be a/an:
1. Communicator
2. Expert
3. Compassionate person
Stephanie was all of the above, but you can place the word ‘Outstanding’ in front of each one. When you are selling your family home, it’s tough. When you are selling your family home and you live 9 hours away, and your family home has approximately 40 years of memories and artifacts in every nook and cranny, it becomes challenging to say the least. Stephanie handled our home as if it were her own. She brought her expertise and her abundance of resources front and center. She communicated with me and my family every step of the way. And she NEVER showed exhaustion, impatience or irritation with the amount of work that was needed to place our home on the market. At times, I kind of thought she enjoyed it!
The sale of our family home was a major project, requiring movers, dumpsters, donation agencies, tree removal, equipment removal, deep cleaning…everything! It was emotional and tiring. To sum up what Stephanie did for me throughout all of this: SHE HAD MY BACK. I WAS NINE HOURS AWAY AND SHE HAD MY BACK. Stephanie made sure that everything was accomplished, she honored my Grandparents, their memories and their lifelong work. And she ensured our home sold at the highest price, and that we got what we deserved for our family home.
I have no doubt that Stephanie Creech is the best Realtor in Cincinnati, and anyone on her team can be trusted to bring the same level of intensity to their clients. If you are looking for a Real Estate agent whether you are selling or buying, do not look any further or you will be selling yourself short. FIVE STAR SERVICE FROM A FIVE STAR AGENT!!!!🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟. Thank you so much Stephanie!!!
3/28/22Nicole Ciresi
Google Review
Stefanie and her team were so wonderful to work with! They went above and beyond to help us sell our home after already finding us our dream home! They are professional and are always there when you have a question. We had a great experience!
11/29/21Dawn Weyl
Google Review
Stefanie and her team were very thorough and responsive. They made my experience stress free. Stefanie walked me through every aspect of selling my home. I highly recommend them!
11/3/21Veronica DeBra
Google Review
Stefanie was awesome from the very first phone call until closing! She knows her job well! Stefanie thinks of everything- and is very easy going and helpful in every aspect of the process. We have found our go-to realtor! Thanks Stefanie for all of your help!
9/23/21Celesta Dickerson
Google Review
I couldn’t have gotten through selling my mother’s house without Stephanie! She guided us through the whole thing and physically helped clean and prepare the house to sell! I would highly recommend her to anyone buying and selling a house!
9/20/21KAY RONSHEIM
Google Review
Stephanie and team are rock stars! Stephanie has the industry knowledge to help buyers and sellers make the right decisions. Stephanie has a contact for everything! The team is great to work with and we would highly recommend!!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
9/1/21S Muller
Google Review
8/29/21Nicole Plennert
Google Review
These ladies are the greatest! They went so far above and beyond to help us find our wonderful home and to sell our “too large” home!! Stefanie and Angel are the best!
8/29/21Kevin Wogenstahl
Google Review
7/28/21John Brown
Google Review
7/15/21Thomas Elam
Google Review
7/1/21Aaron Caroll
Google Review
Stefanie is the best! As a first time homebuyer, she made the process accessible and comfortable. I definitely recommend her!
7/1/21Randy Wogenstahl
Google Review
Stefanie Creech is hands down the best real estate agent I’ve ever worked with. Her knowledge of the industry is simply incredible and her commutation skills are outstanding. If you’re a buyer or seller and would like a stress free transaction give Stefanie a call, you won’t be disappointed! Thanks for all your help!!
5/17/21Kate Bierman
Google Review
I recently had the pleasure of working with Stefanie when I was looking for my home. From day 1, she has always answered every call or email no matter what time of day or night it was. Her professionalism, mentorship, knowledge, honesty, and hard work ethic are much respected and appreciated. I never felt that she was just trying to sell me a house, but that she was a mentor to answer my questions and help me to make the best decision for my family.
If the time ever comes when I will be looking for a new home, there isn't any question on who my Realtor will be!
5/11/21Caesar Hossain
Google Review
Stefanie is one of the best realtor I have worked with. She is helpful, friendly and amazing.
5/10/21Kathy Heger
Google Review
Stephani is awesome! Works hard to sell or find you a home.
5/10/21Jim and Shelly Setters
Google Review
Stefanie Creech is an outstanding realtor! She goes over and beyond to meet the needs of her clients. My husband and I are very busy with work, running our own business and sports with the kiddos. Stefanie was very understanding about our crazy schedule and was very flexible. She helped us with the sale of our home and the purchase of a new one. She knew exactly what we were looking for and was always on the forefront with new listings. We appreciated her knowledge, responsiveness, professionalism, and enthusiasm! Stefanie was a pleasure to work with! Should we decide on another move in the future we will definitely return to Stefanie! Thank you Stefanie! We appreciate you!
5/9/21Diane Bacher
Google Review
5/9/21Jennifer Curtis
Google Review
Stefanie is one of a kind! She genuinely cares about each client and works tirelessly until they find the perfect place to call home! She’s a great listener and advocate! She is a fantastic negotiator and is knowledgeable about every aspect of the business. Hire her today! You will be so glad you did!
5/3/21Mike Mayleben
Google Review
Regardless how many clients Stefanie has, you always feel like you’re the only one. For most, that matters. It mattered to me. You’ll get good honest feedback, a hard dedicated worker and someone that ALWAYS goes the extra mile. She made our experience memorable.
5/3/21Dwayne Spiers
Google Review
Hard worker that goes above and beyond for the client! Highly recommend.
5/3/21Sandy Dudukovich
Google Review
Stephanie was very helpful in giving me ideas on preparing my home for open house. She brought over shoe booties for open house and candy for guests. While people liked the home my steep backyard was an issue. She found a buyer who wanted a pool and my yard turned out to be a perfect setting for them. She worked hard for me and I appreciated it.
5/2/21Monir Farooque
Google Review
Stefanie is a very energetic person. She doesn’t get bogged down easily. No matter how difficult her clients may be!
5/2/21mark hess
Google Review
4/30/21Debbie Grubbs
Google Review
Looking for a house in 2020 was hard because they were going fast. Stefanie stepped up her game and was on top of it. My experience with Stefanie was awesome. Stefanie was alway available and worked so hard to get things finalized quickly for us to move in before Christmas. Not only does Stefanie work doing the process but after you buy and get settled in, she still follows up with you and see how the house is going. If you are looking and want someone to be persistent, Contact Stefanie Creech! She is your relator!
4/30/21Alyssa Wilson
Google Review
4/30/21Jam C
Google Review
Stefanie was very patient and helpful in our search for our current home. She was honest about houses that she didn't think were in our best interest, instead of trying to seal a quick deal and be done with us, even after having already shown us many houses. She was great with our boys and interacted with them positively. They thought she was "fun". She made sure that she (or at the very least anther colleague) was available to show us houses, even on short notice. I would highly recommend her as a buyer's agent!! 🙂
4/29/21Linda Eberling
Google Review
Stefanie Creech went the extra mile to keep me informed of all my options, the best path to selling my condo, and even altering me to financial situations , such a escrow reimbursements and tax options, after the sale. She is an honest, personable professional at every level. Fortunate is the seller or buyer who can benefit from her expertise.
4/29/21Jeannie Setters
Google Review
We had a great experience with Stefanie when she sold our home 2 years ago. She was knowledgeable, kind, patient, experienced, timely and so many other positive things! She knew exactly what we needed to do to sell our home in the most timely manner but was so patient, kind and empathetic with us as we had just lost a very dear family member.
I would recommend her to my closest friends and family....and I actually have!
4/29/21Sandy Haynick
Google Review
I wish I had met Stefanie long before we did, because she was nothing short of AMAZING selling our house! She was honest and down-to-earth, and knew immediately after meeting one time that she was the agent for us! She sold our house before it was even officially listed, at a much higher price than we had thought! We’ve bought and sold houses in 4 different states now, and I wish we had Stefanie for every transaction!
4/29/21Zach
Google Review
We loved working with Stefanie. She helped us buy our first home and made us feel like family. Stefanie goes above and beyond to make the home buying process smooth and easy. I would recommend her to anyone!
4/29/21Faye Deardurff
Google Review
Stefanie was the agent that listed my condo I had multiple offers and it sold with 24 hours. She was very thorough and professional. I really appreciate how she was on top of things and how she kept me informed every step of the way. I would highly recommend her for any real estate transaction.
4/29/21Jen Maratos
Google Review
Stefanie sold our house quickly and for a good price. She was always very responsive and involved throughout the entire process. I would recommend her!
4/29/21Ryan McEwan
Google Review
Odds are if you’re reading this, you are trying to see if Stefanie is the best fit for your real estate needs. I don’t have to know you or your situation to say that if you are in the market, either listing or buying, Stefanie is the Realtor you want in your corner. She goes above and beyond for her clients and goes to great lengths to make sure your concerns are addressed and your needs taken care of. She knows the market and will make sure you get a fair price, but is also sharp enough to get you the best value. And she’s not just doing it because that’s her job, she genuinely cares.
4/29/21Katie Laughlin
Google Review
Stefanie goes above and beyond for her clients and is a wealth of information and resources. She will guide you through the entire process of buying or selling with her excellent negotiating skills and vast knowledge of the industry.
4/29/21Christy Falco
Google Review
Stefanie is amazing to work with and I would highly recommend her services to anyone.
4/29/21Jennifer Benson
Google Review
Stefanie is a beast! She will fight to get you the best deal, will educate you on all aspects of home buying/selling and she will work non stop!
4/29/21Regina Taylor
Google Review
If you need a realtor that has great energy and personality call Stefanie!!
4/29/21Latosha Brown
Google Review
Stefanie is very professional & was extremely patient while helping us search for a home for over year, making herself available whenever we called. We couldn’t have asked for anything more in a Realtor!
4/28/21Jamie Buchanan
Google Review
Stephanie listed my home and went way above expectations!
Stephanie was very caring, professional and all around an amazing person/realtor. Very hands own from beginning to end.
I will definitely recommend Stephanie to friends and family when they are in need of selling/buying a home!
Stephanie you ROCK!!!
4/28/21Lauren Creech
Google Review
4/27/21John Shackleford
Google Review
Stephanie knows her business and beside that, is a pleasure to know and personally work with! A straight shooter, she will be honest with you and give great advice about your current home you are wanting to sell or the new one you may be looking to purchase!
Stephanie is very responsive to any questions you may have whether buying or selling. She will work tirelessly for you!
4/26/21Tosha Duritsch
Google Review
Stefanie made our home buying/selling experience seamless. She has in-depth knowledge of the local market and was able to steer our choices into a direction that saved time and energy during a big life transition. She is a true professional in the real estate field and we would choose her to work with again and again.
4/26/21Jess McComb
Google Review
Stefanie did a great job helping me find a home I loved and was great throughout the buying and selling process. I'd recommend her to anyone buying or selling. Great agent who provides amazing support along the way.

