Section Image

Will Penney

Fairlawn, OH
5.0stars, 304 Reviews
EXP Realty, LLC.
467 Closed Sales
$109.9M Total Value
$95K - $1.1M Price Range
$235.4K Average Price
Prior five years

About Will

Thanks for viewing our profile!

Our office is in Stow, and we service the following areas within 30 minutes of our office: Stow, Hudson, Cuyahoga Falls, Munroe Falls, Silver Lake, Tallmadge, Mogadore, Northampton, Macedonia, Twinsburg, Sagamore Hills, Northfield, Northfield Center, Boston Heights, Peninsula, Akron, Bath, Fairlawn, Copley, Green, Norton, Richfield, Streetsboro, Kent, Brimfield, Aurora, Mantua, Wadsworth, Cuyahoga and Medina counties.

I have been a full time Realtor since 1988. I was one of the top Realtors in the state of Ohio for a large national real estate organization during the 1990's. My wife, Mary, and I started Penney Real Estate Company in February of 2001.

Unlike most of the large real estate companies who gain market share by employing lots of average Realtors, who sell 5-10 homes a year each, we have gained market share by providing our clients with a much higher level of experience and service who, in turn, refer us to their friends and family members.

I am more effective because I work harder and invest in my business! The average days on market for my listings and my list price versus sale price ratio are better than most agents because I have more experience and I am dedicated to success.

Everyone talks about service these days. But here is the difference: I have over 30 years of experience selling lots and lots of houses! I understand our local market, the buying and selling process, and I know how much homes are worth. I also understand how important communication is.

We make keeping our clients informed from start to finish a huge priority. An informed client is a happy client. A happy client will refer us to their friends and family. It's quite simple. Few things are more annoying to me than having to hunt someone down in this day and age of always being within inches of your phone. Our clients never have to hunt us down!

Also, unlike most Realtors who handle all aspects of the real estate transaction by themselves and spread themselves thin, I have a fantastic support team.

BUT... our team works differently than most:

Many really productive Realtors have several buyer agents and listing managers who they assign their clients to. Those team members are the ones who work with the buyers and sellers and the transactions are listed under the team leader's name . Often times the buyers and sellers don't actually work with the team leader at all!

I work with ALL of my buyer and seller clients, period.

Our showing agent, Rebecca, shows our buyer clients homes, but once a home is identified the buyer works with me directly, and I handle the negotiations and the purchase process.

Our client service manager, Tina, helps with our seller and buyer clients during the marketing and closing process, but the seller works with me during the contract, negotiation and selling part of the process.

This way, our buyer and seller clients benefit from working with our group but I am always the one who oversees the important parts of the buying or selling process.

Our clients love this as evidenced by our 5 star rating and the fact that I am the highest rated Realtor in Northeast Ohio! Google my name and you'll see hundreds of 5 star client reviews. We would love to work with you as well, so feel free to call us today. Thanks again for visiting my Homes.com profile.

On a personal note... we have two kids, live in Bath, and I am a long distance runner. I've run many road marathons and trail ultra marathons.
Home Types: House, Lot/Land, Townhouse, Condo, Manufactured, MultiFamily, Commercial
Years of Experience: 17

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Total Deals
46
Total Value
$13,108,097
Average Sale Price
$284,959
Price Range
$60K - $740K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
27
Total Value
$7,062,811
Average Sale Price
$261,586
Price Range
$62K - $465K

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Total Deals
84
Total Value
$21,049,147
Average Sale Price
$250,585
Price Range
$35K - $740K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
58
Total Value
$15,070,584
Average Sale Price
$259,838
Price Range
$62K - $490K

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Total Deals
287
Total Value
$63,475,631
Average Sale Price
$221,169
Price Range
$29K - $740K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
180
Total Value
$46,440,428
Average Sale Price
$258,002
Price Range
$13K - $1.1M

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Will's Listings and Deals

Awards and Designations

  • CRS - Certified Residential Specialist

Will's Reviews

5.0stars, 304 Reviews

4/18/25Bill Schwing

Google Review

We met Will Penney as the selling agent of our new home we purchased. We found him to be very honest, straight forward and fair in his dealings with our purchase so much that we hired him to sell our home. He gave us great advice and explained the whole seller/buyer process clearly and concisely. Will has a great sense of humor and it was a pleasure working with him. He has an open invitation to knock on our door anytime for a visit! Thanks again, Will!

4/17/25Brittany Casto

Google Review

Will Penney is just amazing! He’s super thorough and, most importantly, someone you can fully TRUST. We’ve worked with him to buy and/or sell three of our homes now, and every single time it’s been a great experience. We wouldn't trust anyone else with this process. He really knows his stuff—you can tell he’s been in the business for a long time and genuinely loves what he does.
Not only is Will knowledgeable, but he’s also a really nice guy who makes the whole process smooth and stress-free. Plus, his team is fantastic and helps take care of all the details so everything is done right. If you’re looking for a realtor, I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Will Penney!

4/15/25Les Dykes

Google Review

Will Penney Group eXp are really great to work with. My condo was sold in just a few days. You cannot go wrong with them.

Agent License #348168
Agent Photo

Will Penney