Homes for Rent in Exeter, NY

Exeter, NY, offers a rural lifestyle nestled between the Plainfield State Forest and Canadarago Lake. With a population of around 1,000, residents live in vintage homes along winding country roads, gathering in the hamlet of Schuyler Lake for daily needs. The area is known for its natural attractions, including Exeter State Forest, which spans nearly 2,000 acres and offers camping, hunting, and snowmobiling. Canadarago Lake features Baker’s Beach with lifeguard services and a boat launch at Canadarago Boat Marine Park for fishing. Housing in Exeter includes ranch-style properties, Cape Cods, lake houses with private docks, and restored 19th-century homes, primarily located along state routes 51 and 28 and the lakefront. Retail and dining options are available in nearby Burlington Flats, home to HoneyPot Farms Meadery, High Burl Brewery, and Rustic Ridge Winery. Cooperstown and Richfield Springs offer additional amenities, including Price Chopper supermarkets. Students attend Richfield Springs Elementary School and Richfield Springs Junior-Senior High School, which have strong athletic programs. Exeter is conveniently connected to Cooperstown, 12 miles away, and is 30 miles from Oneonta and Utica via state routes.