While the gridded streets of Shelbyville make it appear like a bustling city, “it’s a sleepy little community where everyone knows everybody,” explains Amy Limpus of the Property Shop of Indiana, the city's top agent and a lifelong resident of Shelbyville. “I grew up here, my husband grew up here, and we both have businesses in the community. We never thought about living anywhere else.” Despite its small-town feel, Shelbyville directly connects to the capital via nearby thoroughfares.
An aerial view showing some of Shelbyville's neighborhood streets.
This Ranch home is another example of the typical Shelbyville neighborhood.
1/2
Custom-built homes with a median in the $200,000s
Less than 35 miles from Indy, the city includes a range of custom-built homes constructed anywhere from the 1960s to the early 2000s. While some streets feature Arts and Crafts-style homes, others include bungalows and ranch-style architecture. Sidewalks link together the houses near downtown Shelbyville, but outlying homes offer a more secluded setting alongside farmland. “A typical three-bedroom ranch is probably going to be about $200,000, and that would be one that is older. More custom areas are brick, and they’re selling for much higher—close to $300,000,” Limpus explains.
Homes like this neat and well-kept ranch-style home are typical in the Shelbyville area.
You can find it in Shelbyville, from minor to spacious homes like this.
1/2
Learning through Shelbyville Central Schools
Part of Shelbyville Central Schools, the city's residents benefits from a B-rated district, according to Niche. Students start at Coulston Elementary, a B-minus-rated school, and transition to Shelbyville Middle, a school with a B rating. For high school, students attend B-rated Shelbyville High and gain access to academic teams like Spell Bowl and Quiz League, as well as organizations like Business Professionals of America and Robotics Club.
Kids can easily walk or bike to Shelbyville Middle School.
Shelbyville Sr High School educates teens in Shelbyville's neighborhoods.
1/2
Exercise for residents and their pups at Blue River Memorial Park
Though Shelbyville is a small city with a population of over 25,000, the rural roots of the city shine through its many parks and recreational opportunities. Blue River Memorial Park sits in northeast Shelbyville and includes over 180 acres of green space, including a butterfly habitat, walking trails and a dog park. Though Blue River is the most expansive option, Kennedy, Sunrise, Sunset and Morrison Park offer smaller-scale options closer to the downtown area. When it gets too cold to enjoy the outdoors, the Shelby County YMCA off Route 9 provides a space for locals to play pickleball, participate in group fitness classes or swim in an indoor pool. For an old-school movie experience, the Skyline Drive-In plays new flicks and classics in the eastern part of the city, a more rural section of Shelbyville. The location also includes a small arcade and a café with quick bites like hot dogs and unique eats like the Bonehill Cheeseburger—a burger between two soft pretzels.
Shelbyville's Blue River Memorial Park has abundant activities for the entire family.
The 10-acre Kennedy Park in Shelbyville has a shelter, playground and basketball courts.
1/2
Kroger in Shelbyville, more retail at the nearby Greenwood Park Mall
With several stores and restaurants in Shelbyville, residents don’t need to venture far to grab the essentials. Kroger is less than 2 miles east of the city center, and Walmart is less than 3 miles northeast. For larger-scale shopping trips, residents can reach Greenwood Park Mall in about 25 miles, home to national retailers like JCPenney, Macy’s and Foot Locker. Locally owned and operated restaurants make up most of the dining options in the Shelbyville. Grandma’s Pancake House takes care of breakfast and is within walking distance for those in the concentrated part of the city. Just half a mile north of Grandma’s, Pudder’s covers lunch or dinner. For nightlife, downtown Shelbyville stays lively with cozy bars like Capone’s Downtown Speakeasy and Willie Farkle’s.
Grandma's Pancake House in Shelbyville is known for breakfast, but check out the great lunch too.
Capone's Downtown Speakeasy in Shelbyville has the perfect vibe for your lunch or night out.
1/2
First Fridays and a Christmas parade
The Horseshoe Indianapolis Casino includes year-round entertainment close to home, but the city also hosts events throughout the year to connect the community. The monthly First Friday event highlights the area’s local shops, restaurants and musicians, and the Christmas Parade celebrates artists, the high school marching band and local organizations.
Travel into Indy via I-74
While there’s no public transportation, there are senior service vans that assist with access to medical care or trips to nearby MHP Major Hospital. For trips into Indy, there are multiple ramps to Interstate 74, including one to the north and west of downtown. If residents need to travel outside of Indiana, the Indianapolis International Airport is about 40 miles away.
Written By
Hannah Rainey
Photography Contributed By
Mark Chenoweth
Video By
Derek Fowler
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Rhonda Krebs,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Shelbyville, IN sell after 51 days on the market compared to the national average of 58 days. The median sale price for homes in Shelbyville, IN over the last 12 months is $264,445, up 13% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Welcome to 2338 Marjorie Way, a stunning new construction home for sale in Shelbyville. This single-story home offers an open-concept living area that seamlessly connects the main gathering spaces. Additional highlights include 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms-including a luxury owner's bath upgrade-a 2.5-car garage, an owner's en-suite bathroom, and more! The home's design emphasizes comfort and
Discover this stunning new construction home at 2317 Bear Oak Run in Shelbyville. This thoughtfully designed 2-story home offers exceptional quality and contemporary living spaces perfect for today's lifestyle. This well-appointed home features 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, an electric fireplace, a loft, walk-in closets in each bedroom, a 2-car garage, and more! The home's design emphasizes
Discover this stunning new construction home for sale at 2318 Marjorie Way in Shelbyville. This thoughtfully designed single-story home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, an electric fireplance, an owner's en-suite bathroom, a 2-car garage, and more! This home showcases excellent design quality throughout, featuring an open-concept floorplan that creates seamless flow between living areas. The
New laminate flooring, light fixtures, breaker panel, tile walk-in shower & vinyl windows! This home is now available on the southwest side of Shelbyville. If you're looking for a place to call your own and would like to be within walking distance to the schools, Boys/Girls clubs, Morrison Park and convenience stores, check this out! Step into the sunny living room, where you'll find a coat
Welcome to this well maintained brick ranch home located in a private country setting with a great view. Features 2-bedroom, 2-full bath This home offers 1176 sq ft plus a 2 car attached garage. Inside you will find an open living and dining area. Master bedroom with a private bathroom. Several updates have been done over the past year including a new roof and AC unit. The large 0.73 acre lot has
Step into the charm of this 3-bedroom, 2-bath Shelbyville home built in 1900, offering character you simply don't find in newer construction. Inside, you'll appreciate details like high ceilings, tall base trim, and the timeless feel that comes with a classic home. Situated on a corner lot in town, the property features a fully fenced backyard along with two covered porches that provide great
This is a DR Horton Montgomery Floor Plan home built in 2019. This traditional designed two-story features three spacious bedrooms all with walk in closets and a loft with split floor plan providing privacy & flexibility for your lifestyle. Laundry Room is upstairs. Main level has a dedicated office space, formal dining room, breakfast room sitting between the kitchen and family room. Family Room
The Aspen II floorplan has it all- from a spacious home office, an open concept living and kitchen area, a large loft, and four bedrooms with plenty of space. You cant go wrong choosing this floorplan! Make The Aspen II your own with the many optional upgrades. If you fall in love with the interior, you will love the elevations on the exterior of this new build home!Entering off the front porch,
Welcome home to the Muncie, an exquisite two-story home that's part of our Smart Series. This floorplan features three different elevations to choose from and a set of upgrades that will make your home unique to you. The standard layout includes a two-car garage, a gathering room, a kitchen, a flex room, a dining nook, three bedrooms, two-and-a-half bathrooms, and a loft.
Introducing The Juniper one of Arbor Homes newest two-story floorplans, offering beautiful exterior designs and flexible options to make it uniquely yours. Choose from multiple upgrades, add a basement for extra space, or expand your great room with a 2 rear and side extension. You can even add a third-car garage for more storage.Step inside to a welcoming hallway and convenient powder bath
Discover this exceptional new construction home at 2322 Marjorie Way in Shelbyville, built by M/I Homes. This thoughtfully designed 2,169 square foot home features an open-concept living space that seamlessly connects the main gathering areas, creating an inviting atmosphere for daily living and entertaining. Key Features: 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms Electric fireplace Spacious loft Walk-in closets
Picture yourself in the spacious and flexible Empress floorplan a 3,200 sq. ft. home with five bedrooms, multiple living areas, and endless options to make it your own. Designed for those who love to entertain, The Empress offers both elegance and everyday comfort.Step inside to a welcoming living room that can double as a home office or sitting area. A powder room and formal dining room make
The Palmetto is one of Arbor Homes newest and most flexible floorplans offering everything you could want in a new construction home. With multiple elevation styles, optional basements, and the choice of a full front porch or breezeway, The Palmetto can easily be tailored to your lifestyle.Step inside to a spacious front living area that can serve as a formal dining room or quiet office with
Discover your perfect living space! Head through the uncovered patio and into the foyer to find a flex room. Customize this space in any way you wish! Or park in your two-car garage and go through the entry to find a spacious great room that opens to a kitchen with an island and a charming breakfast nook. Also on the first floor is a convenient home office. Upstairs are three bedrooms, one
Discover comfortable living at Loper Commons Apartments in Shelbyville, Indiana. Our pet-friendly community offers spacious one, two, and three-bedroom apartments with updated cabinetry, granite countertops, and fully equipped kitchens with upgraded appliances. Enjoy beautifully landscaped grounds, a pond, and amenities like a playground, picnic & grill areas, a clubhouse, and a fitness center.
Eight37 Lofts offers unique 1-, 2-, and 3-bedroom layouts that are sure to fit your exciting lifestyle. Enjoy modern finishes, open-concept layouts, and spacious storage inside your apartment, along with inviting outdoor spaces and convenient on-site parking throughout the community. It’s a place you’ll be proud to call home.
Convenient to Indianapolis, Cimarron Place includes everything you're looking for in a home, including washer/dryer hookups, a swimming pool, and plenty of storage! That's why we're the best address in town! Please call for the latest specials.
The Mill is a brand-new affordable* apartment community in Shelbyville, Indiana where modern living meets small-town charm. Our stylishly designed studio, one, two, and three bedroom apartment homes feature spacious kitchens with electric appliances, plenty of room to entertain, large closets, and washer and dryer connections. Step outside your door and you'll find a 24-hour fitness center,
NO DEPOSIT/NO UTILITIES. Please call Christian Investments at 3one7-three98-7two0three and select option number 2. Our hours are Monday through Friday 7:30 AM until 3:30 PM. Have to have proof of income for the last 6 months and no evictions. Applications are available at 318 E Broadway St Shelbyville IN at the back of the building go in office door and applications will be located at bottom of
NO DEPOSIT. Please call Christian Investments at 3one7-three98-7two0three and select option number 2. Our hours are Monday through Friday 7:30 AM until 3:30 PM. Have to have proof of income for the last 6 months and no evictions. Applications are available at 318 E Broadway St Shelbyville IN at the back of the building go in office door and applications will be located at bottom of steps.
NO DEPOSIT. Please call Christian Investments at 3one7-three98-7two0three and select option number 2. Our hours are Monday through Friday 7:30 AM until 4:30 PM. Have to have proof of income for the last 6 months and no evictions. Applications are available at 318 E Broadway St Shelbyville IN at the back of the building go in office door and applications will be located at bottom of steps.
NO DEPOSIT. Please call Christian Investments at 3one7-three98-7two0three and select option number 2. Our hours are Monday through Friday 7:30 AM until 3:30 PM. Have to have proof of income for the last 6 months and no evictions. Applications are available at 318 E Broadway St Shelbyville IN at the back of the building go in office door and applications will be located at bottom of steps.
Very nice studio apartment now available! Near trails, trailheads (Blue River), parks (Sunset Park), canoe and kayak launches (at Sunset Park) this studio apartment will play into the outdoor enthusiast's interests for sure! Easy maintenance, almost plug and play, and all utilities included! Only one bill per month that catches all of your housing costs! Fridge and stove included in rent.
Step inside this renovated retreat,Where charm and style softly meet.Two bedrooms, one bath, a cozy space,Modernized with elegance and grace.A sleek kitchen, perfect for your flair,A bedroom serene, dreams take to the air.A bathroom sanctuary, a place to unwind,This haven of comfort is one of a kind.With abundant light and a vibrant locale,Where
(ad price is nightly) This is a short term rental, nightly or weekly, or monthly. It is fully furnished & perfect for those traveling on work or visiting family. Here is our fully furnished 2-bedroom condo, available for long-term lease also. Nestled on a secluded golf course, this charming property offers a serene retreat for extended stays. Immerse yourself in breathtaking views & tranquil
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
