$2,906,484Average Value$1,231Average Price per Sq Ft23Homes For Sale
A commercial-free barrier island
On the slim barrier island of Casey Key, located between the larger cities of Sarasota and Venice, quiet afternoons are punctuated by the sound of gulls. Residents can collect shells along this community’s white sand beaches or spend an afternoon paddle boarding in the Gulf of Mexico’s bright blue waters. There are only a few 1950s-era motels and vacation rentals scattered throughout Casey Key, as this quiet paradise prides itself on remaining primarily residential. “You’ve got your privacy and you still get the feel of the old Florida,” says Daniel Matusiak, a luxury real estate consultant and broker. Over the decades, Casey Key’s views, quiet roads and multi-million dollar estates have attracted famous residents like renowned author Stephen King. For most tourists, Casey Key is off the beaten path which means the community remains both traffic- and commercial-free.
Spanish-influenced estates with water views
In Casey Key, buyers will find a diverse offering of glamorous estate homes as well as some more modest three-bedroom homes dating back to the 1960s. Architectural styles range from Spanish-influenced designs featuring red-tiled roofs to sprawling modern mansions camouflaged by rows of palm trees. Here, the average sale price hovers around $5 million, but price points can easily reach upwards of $12 million. Homeowners on the Gulf side of the Key have access to their own private beaches — which increases these properties’ price tags — while the west side offers ranch-style homes overlooking Blackburn Bay at price points of $3 million. According to Matusiak, about 15 % of properties have bay-to-gulf access, the best of both worlds.
Casey Key homes are grand, updated, and expertly built.
Many Casey Key homes are built in a grand Mediterranean style with gated entrances.
1/2
Seafood with ocean views at Casey Key Fish House
At the Casey Key Fish House, a local favorite, patrons can order everything from fresh sesame-crusted tuna to classic deep-fried seafood items. About 5 miles south across from Nokomis Beach is Pop’s Sunset Grill. Listen to live music, enjoy the bay views and try their spicy tuna wrap. Travel across the bay to The Clever Monkey in Osprey, known for its craft beer menu. Nearby, residents can do their grocery shopping at Publix or check more items off their to-do lists in the Bay Street Town Center, home to boutique shops, cafes, and restaurants like By the Bay Bistro, Bella Vino & Cucina and Midge Johnson Fine Art.
Casey Key residents can find conveniences and groceries at the nearby Publix.
Casey Key Fish House is la popular restaurant located just outside of Casey Key.
Casey Key residents have access to retail shops and restaurants nearby.
1/3
Yoga and drum circles on Nokomis Public Beach
Residents can enjoy Florida’s warm weather from behind the helms of their very own motorboats or opt to rent a kayak or paddleboard near Blackburn Point. To catch some waves, surfers head to the south side of North Jetty while fishermen try their luck on the north side. Free yoga classes are offered on Nokomis Beach most mornings at 9 am. Or stick around on Wednesdays and Saturdays to catch the rhythmic beats of a drum circle just before sunset. A short drive south brings residents to Venice where they can attend a lecture series or a Jazz concert at the Venice Art Center. Thirty minutes north, and they’ll arrive in Sarasota, known as Florida’s cultural coast. Catch a performance at the Sarasota Opera House or pick up a pair of season tickets at the Florida Studio Theater.
An emphasis on the arts in Sarasota County public schools
Casey Key students are incorporated into the Sarasota County School System. Kids kindergarten through Grade 8 attend Laurel Nokomis Elementary/Middle School, which has a student-teacher ratio of 15 to 1. From there, they can head to Venice High School, known for its Arts Academy Apprenticeship Program which gives juniors and seniors the opportunity to collaborate with industry professionals. Both Laurel Nokomis and Venice High were awarded A grades from the educational review site, Niche.
Venice Senior High School in Venice FL is an A rated school.
Laurel Nokomis School has 1,342 students in grades PK, K-8.
1/2
Spot manatees while exploring Blackburn Park
Nokomis Public Beach, a popular spot for seashell hunting, is the oldest public beach in Sarasota County. There’s plenty of parking in the morning for those who drive to the beach, but locals may find it easiest to make the trip on their bikes. Across the Blackburn Point Swing Bridge is Blackburn Point Park, where birding enthusiasts can keep an eye out for Great White Herons and Brown Pelicans. If lucky, visitors may even spot a manatee or two. The park also offers picnic tables, pavilions and boat launches for public use.
The Sarasota Bradenton International Airport and a smaller municipal facility
Residents get on and off the island by car via the historic Blackburn Point Swing Bridge or Albee Road. From Blackburn Point, the Sarasota Bradenton International Airport is just 30 minutes away on US Highway 41. From there, catch a direct flight to nearly 50 US cities. Alternatively, the local Venice Municipal Airport provides a landing place for privately owned aircrafts.
On the island of Casey Key itself, take advantage of the resort-like views by biking or riding an electric scooter down the road. Residents love docking their boats in the slips at the Casey Key Fish House, then grabbing a bite with some stellar views.
Hurricanes are a concern in Southwest Florida
According to Lori Summers, a Realtor with Corcoran Dwellings and ½ of the Golden Summers Mortgage Team, the Sarasota area is known for being relatively safe when it comes to hurricanes. "There are stories of an ancient blessing that explain why Sarasota is protected from hurricanes,” she says. Still, Casey Key residents were tasked with repairing large-scale damage to their infrastructure after Hurricane Idalia struck in August 2023.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Lee Brewer,
an experienced agent in this neighborhood.
Parks in this Area
Pocono Trail Preserve
Picnic Area
Trails
Hiking
Shoreland Park
Calusa and Seminole People Monument
Humphris Park
Venice Army Air Base Park
Laurel Park
Bike Trails
Picnic Area
Tennis
Transit
Airport
Sarasota/Bradenton International
35 min drive
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Casey Key
US
Homicide
2
4
Sexual Assault
1
4
Assault with Weapon
1
4
Robbery
1
4
Burglary
2
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
1
4
Larceny
2
4
Crime Score
1
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Casey Key, Venice sell after 115 days on the market compared to the national average of 47 days. The average sale price for homes in Casey Key, Venice over the last 12 months is $2,728,990, down 35% from the average home sale price over the previous 12 months.
If you are looking for the ultimate in bayside waterfront living on Casey Key, come see this newly remodeled home on a rare cul-de-sac site with water views on three sides and from almost every room. Unlike many, this home survived both hurricanes Helene and Milton with no flooding of the living area. In the past few months the home has been upgraded with 24-inch white porcelain tile flooring,
DIRECT BEACHFRONT BEING SOLD AT LAND VALUE! Best beachfront value on the barrier island. One of the best values for Gulf-front land currently offered in Sarasota and Manatee Counties! This 1.1-acre property on Casey Key features an impressive 100 feet of direct beach frontage, boasting endless sun-kissed days and breathtaking sunsets right from your own backyard. The allure of this property lies
Nicole Hammons-DovgopolyiMICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY
This captivating Gulf-to-Bay residence perfectly embodies timeless coastal style. Start your mornings on the lanai with coffee in hand as the sun rises over the Intracoastal Waterway. Launch your boat from the bayside dock, then spend your afternoons on your private beach—where breathtaking Gulf sunsets are practically a nightly guarantee. Inside, you'll find expansive, light-filled rooms
Gulf-front serenity on Casey Key. On the desirable shores of Casey Key, this quintessential beachfront retreat, Osmyrrah, is a sanctuary of tranquility, designed for relaxed, organic living with an intimate connection to the sea. With private, pristine beachfront and panoramic Gulf views, you’ll be immersed in dazzling sunsets, soft white sands and the soothing rhythm of the waves every single
Welcome to 416 Casey Key Rd – an exceptional waterfront estate offering private Gulf beach access, spectacular views, and elevated, storm-safe construction on one of Florida’s most exclusive barrier islands. This three-story concrete block home offers timeless coastal design paired with the latest modern features for seamless living and entertaining.Inside, you’ll find four spacious
Take a break and unwind at this peaceful oasis. Casey Key is a great option if you are looking for the quieter side of Gulf Coast living. Come see another reason everyone is asking What's all the fuss about Sarasota?" This get away sits on .75-acre lot, just steps from Nokomis Beach. This rental is also perfect for beach lovers and is well-suited for family gatherings. This spacious house
NEWLY RENOVATED UNFURNISHED HOUSE ON CASEY KEY!! Cute one story ranch style house tucked away on a cul-de-sac on private Casey Key. One car garage and behind the house is a large lawn leading to a dock on a mangrove lagoon that leads out to the intracoastal waterway, perfect for kayaking . This house has two bedrooms and two bathrooms, the main living areas are all open plan that include the
DIRECT GULF FRONT HOME IN A UNIQUE LOCATION. Gorgeous 1,750 SqFt of luxury on 3 stories, an Elevator, and the finishing are top quality. Sit on the balcony for a quiet evening and watch the most spectacular sunset on the West Coast of Florida. A 2 Bedrooms, 3 Bathrooms with plenty of living space for a Luxurious beach house. Could be leased-furnished or Turnkey furnished. Live on a very special
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Lee Brewer,
an experienced agent in this neighborhood.
Average Home Value
Source: Public Records
Property Mix - Square Feet
This Neighborhood Has More Owners
Demographics
Total Population
644
Median Age
63
Population Density
2 ppl/acre
Population under 18
11.3%
Below the national average
23.8%
Population over 65
45%
Significantly above the national average
19.1%
Finances
Median Household Income
$188,157
Significantly above the national average
$71,702
Average Household Income
$196,257
Education and Workforce
High School Graduates
97.8%
College Graduates
59.7%
Significantly above the national average
34.1%
Advanced Degrees
27%
% Population in Labor Force
44.1%
Below the national average
65.1%
Weather
Annual Precipitation
50''
Average Winter Low Temperature
52°F
Average Summer High Temperature
91°F
Annual Snowfall
0''
Area Factors
Somewhat Bikeable
Bike Score®
30/ 100
Car-Dependent
Walk Score®
5/ 100
Source: Walk Score
Source: Walk Score
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
