Downtown Bay Shore
In Bay Shore’s first 200 years, it tried on names like new shoes. Early European settlers first called it Penataquit, a name used by the indigenous Secatogue. After trying on three more names, the area eventually circled back to that original name in 1849. The change lasted only a couple of decades, though, as locals and visitors — who came to the
-
Average Value
$887K
-
List Price
$437K - $3.9M
-
For Sale
Homes For Sale
9 Listings
