Neighborhoods in Brookhaven, NY

• 

  

  

  /42

  Old Field

  Old Field is a compact, 2.2-square-mile residential neighborhood known for its scenic water views and outdoor activities. Surrounded by harbors, bays, and an inland pond, the area is highlighted by the iconic Old Field Point of Light lighthouse. The neighborhood is characterized by its large mansions and sprawling estates, many of which are hidden

  • Average Value

    $1.73M

  • List Price

    $865K - $5M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    2 Listings

  Old Field
• 

  

  

  /32

  Central Fire Island

  On the surface, Central Fire Island is defined by pristine beaches, forests tucked between dunes and little coastal towns at the heart of Fire Island, which is a thin coastal barrier island 5 miles across the Great South Bay from Long Island. But looking a little deeper reveals the area’s other main draw: the long history of a couple of its

  • Average Value

    $1.50M

  • List Price

    $565K - $4.4M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    26 Listings

  Central Fire Island
• 

  

  

  /29

  Belle Terre

  Belle Terre, a gated community marked by a historic French-inspired stone and iron gatehouse, is known for its exclusivity and scenic beauty. Located at the north end of Port Jefferson, this neighborhood has a rich history dating back to the early 20th century when real estate tycoon Dean Alvord developed the area. Today, Belle Terre is a strictly

  • Average Value

    $1.34M

  • List Price

    $838K - $7.5M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    13 Listings

  Belle Terre
• 

  

  

  /35

  Bellport

  Bellport, on the south shore in Brookhaven, is a distinctive neighborhood known for its vibrant artistic community, attracting artists, writers, performers, and musicians. The area features quaint South Country Road, lined with galleries, a theater, and cozy coffee shops. Residents enjoy a close-knit atmosphere, often getting around by bike or on

  • Average Value

    $1.25M

  • List Price

    $537K - $8.5M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    16 Listings

  Bellport
• 

  

  

  /28

  Eastern Fire Island

  Even on the darkest and stormiest of nights, the windswept sand dunes on Fire Island are magnificent. This thin Atlantic barrier island, just off the coast of Long Island, is an enchanting mix of sandy shores, ancient forests, protected natural areas and eclectic little beach towns. From May to October, Eastern Fire Island is a busy place, with

  • Average Value

    $902K

  • List Price

    $744K - $998K

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    1 Listing

  Eastern Fire Island
• 

  

  /34

  Setauket-East Setauket

  Very few neighborhoods can claim to be home to both waterfront views and a historic spy ring, but Setauket-East Setauket is certainly one of them. Once the center of the Culper Spy Ring, a famous Revolutionary War group that gave General George Washington himself information about British troops and their plans and played a vital role in the

  • Average Value

    $878K

  • List Price

    $208K - $3M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    31 Listings

  Setauket-East Setauket
• 

  

  /33

  East Moriches

  Located on Long Island’s South Shore just 6 miles from Westhampton, East Moriches has the kind of friendliness that is often found in books or movies set in small towns. “Sometimes we call this area the quiet Hamptons,” says Kevin Loiacono, a licensed real estate broker and the owner of BrookHampton Realty who has lived in the Moriches area for 24

  • Average Value

    $842K

  • List Price

    $588K - $2.3M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    19 Listings

  East Moriches
• 

  

  /28

  Eastport

  Although Eastport was once the center of Long Island’s duck farming industry — producing 6.5 million ducks every year at its height in the first half of the 1900s — you’d never know it today. All the duck farms are gone now, with much of the land portioned off into residential properties. The little downtown at its heart, though, retains much of

  • Average Value

    $824K

  • List Price

    $595K - $1.7M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    13 Listings

  Eastport
• 

  

  /35

  Shoreham

  Shoreham, a coastal neighborhood on Long Island, has evolved from a summer resort for wealthy New Yorkers to a year-round community. Known for its beaches, parks, farms, and cultural attractions, Shoreham offers a variety of ways for residents to enjoy their free time. The Shoreham-Wading River Central School District serves the area, with highly

  • Average Value

    $792K

  • List Price

    $650K - $969K

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    1 Listing

  Shoreham
• 

  

  /26

  Miller Place

  When it comes to small towns, there’s an old trope that people always give directions based on landmarks — turn right at the crooked tree, left at Miller’s place. And there’s truth to the trope, because that is, after all, exactly how Miller’s Place got its name. In 1720, a man named Andrew Miller owned a house near what is now North Country Road,

  • Average Value

    $785K

  • List Price

    $465K - $1.5M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    22 Listings

  Miller Place
• 

  

  /25

  Stony Brook

  History, education and outdoor destinations are the main ingredients that make Stony Brook a popular place on Long Island’s north shore to live and explore. The West Meadow Beach creates the town’s northern border, and Smithtown Bypass sits along the southern border. “Stony Brook is 10 to 15 minutes from the Smith Haven mall, and the university

  • Average Value

    $773K

  • List Price

    $422K - $1.6M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    20 Listings

  Stony Brook
• 

  

  /36

  Port Jefferson

  Port Jefferson has a rich maritime history. Since modern-day New Yorkers no longer rely on boats and ferries for transportation, the village has undergone a transformation over the past several decades. Shipbuilding infrastructure -- from the harbor to old boat repair shops and warehouses on Broadway -- are now open-air shopping plazas with

  • Average Value

    $765K

  • List Price

    $435K - $1.4M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    20 Listings

  Port Jefferson
• 

  

  /35

  Mount Sinai

  In many ways, Mount Sinai’s most striking feature is Cedar Beach, which is framed by Mount Sinai Harbor and the Long Island Sound less than 3 miles from Port Jefferson and 64 miles from Manhattan. Most residents live in spacious homes surrounded by towering trees, just minutes from the beach’s sand and rock shores. It’s a magnetic lifestyle, but

  • Average Value

    $762K

  • List Price

    $396K - $1.7M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    23 Listings

  Mount Sinai
• 

  

  /34

  Brookhaven

  Brookhaven feels very different from many of Long Island’s busy, crowded suburbs. Although the neighborhood covers nearly 6 square miles, a wildlife refuge and wetlands consume a good amount of this space. Its population density is roughly 550 people per square mile — more than three times less than the neighboring North Bellport, which has about

  • Average Value

    $760K

  • List Price

    $480K - $3.6M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    9 Listings

  Brookhaven
• 

  

  /29

  Center Moriches

  Sitting at the edge of Moriches Bay on Long Island’s South Shore, Center Moriches is a boater’s paradise. Creeks cut into it, creating four jagged “fingers” of land that are surrounded by water as they jut into the bay. The resulting abundance of homes with water access, creeks to explore and access to the bay — even access to the Atlantic Ocean

  • Average Value

    $746K

  • List Price

    $489K - $4.6M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    34 Listings

  Center Moriches
• 

  

  /32

  Blue Point

  Blue Point is a little sliver of a neighborhood in the town of Brookhaven. The hamlet, about 65 miles east of Manhattan, sits on the edge of the Great South Bay between Sayville and Patchogue. Its waterfront nature and position between these two popular communities are bonuses for many residents, but many stay for its quiet, relaxed atmosphere and

  • Average Value

    $742K

  • List Price

    $454K - $1.6M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    6 Listings

  Blue Point
• 

  

  /35

  Manorville

  Although Manorville’s name may sound prim and proper, it was born out of an act of rebellion. The hamlet was originally part of Manor St. George, a name honoring the British monarchy. In the mid-1800s, in an act of defiance against the British he’d fought against during the Revolutionary War, the local Long Island Rail Road station agent

  • Average Value

    $723K

  • List Price

    $140K - $2.6M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    47 Listings

  Manorville
• 

  

  /28

  Lake Grove

  Lake Grove is a compact Long Island village within the town of Brookhaven. “What makes this neighborhood different is that it is incorporated and manages its own water and waste, which requires an extra tax,” says Alex Goldenberg, a broker with Howard Hanna Coack Realtors and resident of nearby Setauket. Because of this, homeowners have better

  • Average Value

    $721K

  • List Price

    $450K - $1.2M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    7 Listings

  Lake Grove
• 

  

  /31

  Moriches

  Moriches is one of the last year-round residential hamlets on the south shore of Long Island that travelers pass by on their way to the Hamptons. Homebuyers looking for coastal or near coastal homes in a neighborhood not appropriated by rowdy nightclubs, fancy restaurants and hip boutiques often find themselves house-hunting in Moriches. “Once you

  • Average Value

    $690K

  • List Price

    $441K - $1.1M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    8 Listings

  Moriches
• 

  

  /35

  Lake Ronkonkoma

  Located in the center of Long Island, Lake Ronkonkoma is a mostly residential neighborhood that surrounds the eastern edge of its namesake waterbody, the largest and deepest freshwater lake in the region. Before The Hamptons became a popular weekend destination for affluent city dwellers, this hamlet drew in crowds that preferred the area’s

  • Average Value

    $653K

  • List Price

    $396K - $1M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    21 Listings

  Lake Ronkonkoma
• 

  

  /28

  Centereach

  Named for its approximate position in the middle of Long Island, Centereach is a large suburban area in the town of Brookhaven that has newer, competitively priced houses. “Homebuyers look here because they like the feel of having businesses around them,” says Alex Goldenberg, a broker with Howard Hanna Coack Realtors and resident of nearby

  • Average Value

    $626K

  • List Price

    $468K - $1.1M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    30 Listings

  Centereach
• 

  

  /28

  East Patchogue

  There’s an old adage that names have power — and if anyone’s looking to prove the point, East Patchogue makes a great case study. Located on Long Island’s South Shore, the hamlet sits between the Village of Bellport and its namesake, the Village of Patchogue. Over the past two decades, Patchogue has experienced a rebirth. It’s now one of the most

  • Average Value

    $616K

  • List Price

    $420K - $1.6M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    20 Listings

  East Patchogue
• 

  

  /32

  Terryville

  Tucked away in the middle of Long Island lies Terryville, a residential area with highly rated schools, convenient parks and quick access to Port Jefferson station. “Terryville is a very quiet area in the Port Jeff area. The homes are more established,” says Lesley Longmcleod, an associate broker at Signature Premier Properties who has over eight

  • Average Value

    $616K

  • List Price

    $436K - $980K

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    13 Listings

  Terryville
• 

  

  /30

  Farmingville

  Farmingville started as an area with family-owned farms, but today, brand-new townhouses, apartments and single-family homes fill this residential town in Long Island. “Farmingville has more apartments than surrounding areas, but it’s a quiet residential town without much industry. They have a lot of entertainment, like car shows and concerts.

  • Average Value

    $611K

  • List Price

    $435K - $1.1M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    15 Listings

  Farmingville
• 

  

  /24

  Port Jefferson Station

  Port Jefferson Station is an unincorporated hamlet south of the tourist-filled Port Jefferson village. Locals live 10 minutes away from Long Island's north shore beaches and minutes from the Long Island Rail Road, which gives commuters an easier path to central New York than driving over an hour west. “This is a very community-oriented place. When

  • Average Value

    $606K

  • List Price

    $426K - $852K

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    5 Listings

  Port Jefferson Station

Showing Results 1 - 25, Page 1 of 2