3

Neighborhoods in Fire Island, NY

  • /32

    Central Fire Island

    On the surface, Central Fire Island is defined by pristine beaches, forests tucked between dunes and little coastal towns at the heart of Fire Island, which is a thin coastal barrier island 5 miles across the Great South Bay from Long Island. But looking a little deeper reveals the area’s other main draw: the long history of a couple of its

    • Average Value

      $1.50M

    • List Price

      $565K - $4.4M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      26 Listings

    Central Fire Island
  • /34

    Western Fire Island

    Breathtaking sunrises and sunsets blazing across the sky, cool salty breezes and a peaceful atmosphere draw people to Western Fire Island, a beachy barrier island 5 miles off Long Island’s South Shore. The slip offers a respite from the New York City noise and traffic – for the most part, vehicles aren’t permitted, so people rely mainly on bikes

    • Average Value

      $1.48M

    • List Price

      $778K - $3.5M

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      14 Listings

    Western Fire Island
  • /28

    Eastern Fire Island

    Even on the darkest and stormiest of nights, the windswept sand dunes on Fire Island are magnificent. This thin Atlantic barrier island, just off the coast of Long Island, is an enchanting mix of sandy shores, ancient forests, protected natural areas and eclectic little beach towns. From May to October, Eastern Fire Island is a busy place, with

    • Average Value

      $902K

    • List Price

      $744K - $998K

    • For Sale

      Homes For Sale

      1 Listing

    Eastern Fire Island