Neighborhoods in Florida Keys, FL

/27
North Key Largo

North Key Largo, one of the uppermost Florida Keys, supports a thriving ecosystem of native wildlife while also hosting one of the Keys’ most exclusive luxury communities. Schaus’ Swallowtail butterflies, American crocodiles and Key Largo woodrats roam beneath the lofty hardwood hammocks while residents enjoy deep sea diving, boating and fishing
- Average Value
  
  $4.91M
- List Price
  
  $644K - $16.9M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  9 Listings
North Key Largo
/36
Casa Marina

Once a destination for the island’s finest visitors, Casa Marina has become one of Key West’s most coveted neighborhoods. The community takes its name from the Casa Marina hotel, originally designed by Henry Flagler in the 1920s as a centerpiece at the end of the Overseas Railroad. Now, the historic Spanish Renaissance-style resort is surrounded
- Average Value
  
  $2.62M
- List Price
  
  $707K - $6.8M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  14 Listings
Casa Marina
/26
Truman Annex

When President Harry S. Truman spent winters at his little white house in Key West, he had no idea what legacy he would leave behind. Decades later, his house remains, surrounded by a delicately landscaped and gated community known as Truman Annex. Tropical foliage and fruit trees peek around white picket fences, and shaded sidewalks make the area
- Average Value
  
  $2.10M
- List Price
  
  $685K - $6.4M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  20 Listings
Truman Annex
/33
Duck Key

Duck Key eerily resembles a duck floating in the Atlantic Ocean — hence the name. But this island in the Florida Keys is much more than a tiny, waterfowl-shaped community. Located halfway between Marathon and Layton, the Key is known for its resort feel, and not just because it’s home to Hawks Cay Resort. “It’s an exclusive little community,” says
- Average Value
  
  $1.86M
- List Price
  
  $605K - $7M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  61 Listings
Duck Key
/31
The Meadows

Vivid mimosa tree blossoms coat the sidewalks in The Meadows, one of Key West’s finest landscaped neighborhoods. Homes in this small pocket of the island’s historic district are partially obscured by thick rows of towering palms and colorful tropical foliage toppling over white picket fences. Hugging a local marina, the neighborhood is praised for
- Average Value
  
  $1.79M
- List Price
  
  $617K - $4.3M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  10 Listings
The Meadows
/28
Old Town

Old Town is at the heart of Key West in more ways than one. This centrally located historic district serves as the city’s main shopping, dining and entertainment hub, home to boutiques, local businesses and a bubbly nightlife scene on Duval Street. Roosters and chickens, thought to be brought over from Cuba in the 1800s, roam the streets like
- Average Value
  
  $1.64M
- List Price
  
  $556K - $8M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  120 Listings
Old Town
/37
Mid Town

Mid Town’s location at the heart of Key West makes it a Goldilocks neighborhood — it’s close enough for residents to enjoy the city’s energetic core while maintaining a quiet suburban feel and easy access to parks and schools. Despite being sandwiched between historic Old Town and commercial-heavy New Town, the community has a distinct and
- Average Value
  
  $1.33M
- List Price
  
  $679K - $4.6M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  76 Listings
Mid Town
/30
Tavernier

Between its tidal pools and mangrove lagoons, Tavernier is no stranger to Florida wildlife. The island, home to the Garden Club of the Upper Keys and the Florida Keys Wild Bird Sanctuary, began as a small fishing community in the early 1900s. For decades, the island’s shallow flats have supported native birds such as cormorants, pelicans, egrets
- Average Value
  
  $1.27M
- List Price
  
  $531K - $5.3M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  45 Listings
Tavernier
/27
Cudjoe Key

Since its activation as a remote U.S. Air Force base in the late 1950s, Cudjoe Key has grown to include some of the most sought-after waterfront properties in the Lower Keys. Only a small portion of the horseshoe-shaped island is populated with a combination of single-family homes and resort rentals, leaving most of the land untouched. Some of it
- Average Value
  
  $1.27M
- List Price
  
  $678K - $4.5M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  40 Listings
Cudjoe Key
/26
Big Coppitt Key

Big Coppitt Key is among the few Lower Keys that are not dominated by resorts. The modest island is about 10 miles from Key West and sits just north of the city’s Naval Air Station, so it’s not uncommon to hear jets passing overhead. Beyond that, noise isn’t an issue. “Key West can be busy with tourists, but Big Coppitt is much less crowded,” says
- Average Value
  
  $1.19M
- List Price
  
  $320K - $6.6M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  26 Listings
Big Coppitt Key
/35
New Town

Known as the shopping and locals’ district, New Town is a predominantly residential area that has become a haven for year-round residents. Unlike the charm of Old Town’s boutiques and locally owned restaurants, New Town’s appeal comes from its convenience — local schools, parks and shopping centers are within minutes of quiet streets. And although
- Average Value
  
  $967K
- List Price
  
  $370K - $3.3M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  52 Listings
New Town
/32
Big Pine Key

Big Pine Key residents coexist with the Key deer, one of the Florida Keys’ most protected species. The island may be the largest remaining habitat for these petite deer, whose numbers have recently dropped below 800. But on Big Pine Key, acres of protected land allow these animals the space they need while inviting nature-loving residents who
- Average Value
  
  $906K
- List Price
  
  $465K - $4M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  79 Listings
Big Pine Key
/29
Stock Island

Rewind the clock on Key West by a few decades, add a handful of marinas and voila: Stock Island. “Stock Island resembles what Key West used to be. The locals call it the last little piece of Old Key West,” says Key West resident Suzanne Moore, principal broker with Suzanne Moore Real Estate. With few resorts and large hotels, this Lower Key, just
- Average Value
  
  $775K
- List Price
  
  $517K - $2M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  5 Listings
Stock Island

Florida Florida Keys

Florida Keys Types of Homes for Sale

Homes in Nearby Cities

Neighborhoods in Nearby Cities

Safest Neighborhoods in Nearby Cities

Neighborhoods in Nearby Counties

Monroe County Neighborhoods

Safest Neighborhoods in Nearby Counties

Safest Monroe County Neighborhoods

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage