Safest Neighborhoods in Staten Island, NY

• 

  

  

  /30

  Todt Hill

  Located in the center of Staten Island, Todt Hill is situated around the borough’s highest point and is widely considered to be its most affluent neighborhood. Large stately homes sit along quiet residential streets and private cul-de-sacs with old-growth trees. “One of the biggest things that the area is known for is that at more than 400 feet,

  • Average Value

    $2.22M

  • List Price

    $1.1M - $14.6M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    20 Listings

  Todt Hill
• 

  

  

  /32

  Lighthouse Hill

  A serene and affluent neighborhood perched atop a hill at the center of Staten Island, Lighthouse Hill takes its name from the still-operating Staten Island Range Lighthouse, built in 1912. The area’s elevated vantage point provides residents with spectacular views of New York Harbor and surrounding parks, and with a CAP Index score of 1, crime is

  • Average Value

    $1.24M

  • List Price

    $744K - $3.4M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    7 Listings

  Lighthouse Hill
• 

  

  

  /29

  Emerson Hill

  Located in central Staten Island, Emerson Hill is a compact residential neighborhood with quiet winding streets, dense tree cover and premium homes. “At 300 feet above sea level, the area is known for being one of the highest points on the eastern seaboard between Florida and the Cape Cod peninsula,” says Joe Tirone, a broker/owner with Compass

  • Average Value

    $1.17M

  • List Price

    $624K - $2.4M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    17 Listings

  Emerson Hill
• 

  

  

  /35

  Pleasant Plains

  Home not just to plains but to waterfront views and wooded streets and footpaths, Pleasant Plains is a neighborhood on Staten Island’s South Shore that lives up to its name. With a leafy suburban feel, the hamlet offers a humble sense of community and modest housing styles tucked on residential streets. “It’s just a very nice, quiet little

  • Average Value

    $1.10M

  • List Price

    $654K - $2.4M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    5 Listings

  Pleasant Plains
• 

  

  

  /27

  Charleston

  Charleston, located near the southern tip of Staten Island, stands out for its sparse population and abundant open spaces, contrasting with the borough's typically dense neighborhoods. Approximately one-third of the area is residential, featuring mostly unattached single homes with yards, some with garages, alongside semi-detached and townhouses.

  • Average Value

    $1.04M

  • List Price

    $805K - $1.8M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    4 Listings

  Charleston
• 

  

  /31

  Prince's Bay

  After the Verrazzano Bridge opened in 1964, Staten Island went through a three-decade residential construction boom. While that momentum faded as all the usable land plots had houses built on them, construction continued in Prince’s Bay for a little longer than other South Shore neighborhoods. “We get more knockdowns and builds because there’s not

  • Average Value

    $1.04M

  • List Price

    $561K - $1.9M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    19 Listings

  Prince's Bay
• 

  

  /32

  Richmondtown

  Recognized for its historic roots, Richmondtown is a corner of Staten Island providing a slice of suburbia in New York while celebrating its rich legacy in American history. The neighborhood gets its name from the 100-acre Historic Richmond Town, a living history village and cultural center that performs reenactments and houses a colonial museum.

  • Average Value

    $1.02M

  • List Price

    $674K - $1.7M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    8 Listings

  Richmondtown
• 

  

  /26

  Annadale

  Down the South Shore is Annadale, one of Staten Island’s more residential neighborhoods. Much of the west side is taken up by the Blue Heron Park Wildlife Preserve, and the rest of the streets mainly host single-family homes sized from townhouses to mini-mansions. “It has a more suburban feel, as opposed to being in the city,” says Richard

  • Average Value

    $990K

  • List Price

    $650K - $2.3M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    14 Listings

  Annadale
• 

  

  /35

  Tottenville

  At the very end of Staten Island, behind North Mount Loretto State Forest, Tottenville offers a New York City version of small-town America. Amboy Road, the main thoroughfare, is dotted with locally owned businesses and colonial and Victorian houses sporting American flags. Despite being a bit secluded, Tottenville has a diverse mix of

  • Average Value

    $948K

  • List Price

    $492K - $3.1M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    37 Listings

  Tottenville
• 

  

  /30

  Woodrow

  Woodrow is a lesser-known neighborhood on Staten Island’s South Shore—a 15-mile drive from the ferry in St. George and a 12-mile drive from the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge. But to Woodrow locals, the remote location is seen as a bonus, shielding the largely residential community from mass urbanization and preserving the neighborhood’s quiet, serene

  • Average Value

    $894K

  • List Price

    $563K - $2.2M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    21 Listings

  Woodrow
• 

  

  /42

  Huguenot

  Huguenot is the only neighborhood on Staten Island that touches both the north and south shores, and its narrow shape puts a variety of structural and natural amenities within easy reach. “There are definitely some strip malls that are within walking distance to a lot of homes,” says Kerry DeBellis, a native Staten Islander with 24 years of real

  • Average Value

    $884K

  • List Price

    $443K - $2.7M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    19 Listings

  Huguenot
• 

  

  /25

  New Dorp

  New Dorp stays true to its small-town Staten Island feel. Situated less than 2 miles from the sandy shores of the Atlantic Ocean in neighboring New Dorp Beach, the enclave offers a vibrant shopping and dining scene along New Dorp Lane that comes alive with an equally vibrant community. “New Dorp is very community-oriented,” says local Realtor

  • Average Value

    $855K

  • List Price

    $306K - $1.4M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    11 Listings

  New Dorp
• 

  

  /31

  Silver Lake

  Nearly all of the homes in Silver Lake lie within the small cluster of quiet streets along the western edge of Silver Lake Park, a streetscape unlike any other Staten Island neighborhood. Many of the broad streets are split down the middle by tree-lined medians, where some of the borough’s oldest trees cast long shadows across single-family homes,

  • Average Value

    $850K

  • List Price

    $302K - $1.1M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    1 Listing

  Silver Lake
• 

  

  /33

  Randall Manor

  Randall Manor, an affluent Staten Island neighborhood, started as an old-age home for sailors on the Kill Van Kull, a tidal strait between New York and New Jersey. Established in the early 1800s, Sailors’ Snug Harbor eventually included everything from a music hall to a hospital, as well as living quarters built in grand Greek-revival style. The

  • Average Value

    $808K

  • List Price

    $220K - $1.1M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    3 Listings

  Randall Manor
• 

  

  /27

  Willowbrook

  Just 12 minutes from the Verrazzano Bridge into Brooklyn, Willowbrook is a neighborhood that deals in balance. In many ways, it’s a typical North Shore neighborhood, with plenty of through traffic thanks to its position near the Staten Island Expressway, but it’s also known for its quiet pockets of homes located on little side streets. Its

  • Average Value

    $800K

  • List Price

    $435K - $1.5M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    15 Listings

  Willowbrook
• 

  

  /34

  Bulls Head

  On Staten Island’s west side, tucked between both natural and industrial parks, is Bulls Head. This residential neighborhood has the suburban features that the Island is known for, such as wide, house-lined streets and mini malls. But its proximity to the Staten Island and MLK Jr. expressways sets it apart, giving residents easy access to

  • Average Value

    $798K

  • List Price

    $535K - $1.2M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    18 Listings

  Bulls Head
• 

  

  /25

  Manor Heights

  This convenient, residential pocket in Mid-Island is just 20 miles from Times Square, where strong schools and proximity to green space attract newcomers seeking a tight-knit community. It’s also close to the College of Staten Island and Staten Island University Hospital, both large employment centers. It’s home to a sizable number of yeshivas

  • Average Value

    $793K

  • List Price

    $540K - $1.2M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    6 Listings

  Manor Heights
• 

  

  /22

  Eltingville

  In Eltingville, residents maintain access to the facets that make New York City so attractive. “You have tremendous access to transportation to get to Manhattan or the other boroughs, and you’re between two neighborhoods that give you great shopping and restaurants,” says Frank Rizzo, who has over 20 years of real estate experience on Staten

  • Average Value

    $793K

  • List Price

    $463K - $1.4M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    35 Listings

  Eltingville
• 

  

  /36

  Bay Terrace

  Bay Terrace may not be on a bay, but it is within walking distance of scenic Raritan Bay with its waterfront walking path and sandy beach. This quiet, compact community is situated between the bayside Great Kills Park and Ocean View the Cemetery Beautiful on the western side. The six or so peaceful blocks in between the two are within walking

  • Average Value

    $789K

  • List Price

    $241K - $1.1M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    5 Listings

  Bay Terrace
• 

  

  /28

  Fort Wadsworth

  Located on the northeastern shore of Staten Island, Fort Wadsworth is a residential enclave named for the Revolutionary War-era military base found on its far east side. Residents here enjoy some of the most spectacular views in the borough, including the commanding span of the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge, New York Harbor and the skylines of downtown

  • Average Value

    $774K

  • List Price

    $192K - $2.4M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    8 Listings

  Fort Wadsworth
• 

  

  /30

  Castleton Corners

  Situated on the North Shore of Staten Island, Castleton Corners, also known as Four Corners, offers residents a slice of suburban paradise within the five boroughs. Often called the borough of parks, Castleton Corners is no stranger to open green spaces. "It's a beautiful community surrounded by endless amenities but also natural open spaces,"

  • Average Value

    $773K

  • List Price

    $112K - $1.1M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    21 Listings

  Castleton Corners
• 

  

  /32

  Oakwood

  On quiet days, residents of Oakwood can hear the ocean waves crashing to shore. Cedar Grove Beach lines the eastern border, ensconcing the neighborhood in a crisp velveteen breeze. Tree-lined streets along residential blocks, parks and greenspaces make for simple living amid natural beauty. The neighborhood is almost entirely domestic, comprised

  • Average Value

    $772K

  • List Price

    $554K - $1.2M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    17 Listings

  Oakwood
• 

  

  /27

  Sunnyside

  Once home to sheep meadows and farmland, Staten Island’s Sunnyside is now a family-oriented community that’s walkable to parks and is convenient to both the St. George Ferry Terminal and the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge via the Staten Island Expressway. The enclave was also once home to a healthy population of Italian immigrants who settled there

  • Average Value

    $757K

  • List Price

    $350K - $1.5M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    18 Listings

  Sunnyside
• 

  

  /29

  Westerleigh

  In the northern section of Staten Island, the Westerleigh neighborhood is notable for its tree-lined streets, well-maintained homes and suburban feel, stemming from the area’s early roots as a summer community for members of the National Prohibition Campground Party and followers of the prohibition movement. As those early summer visitors turned

  • Average Value

    $755K

  • List Price

    $495K - $1.6M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    26 Listings

  Westerleigh
• 

  

  /28

  Great Kills

  Great Kills, at the north end of the South Shore, is a microcosm of the best things Staten Island has to offer. A beach and marina on the southeast side support local yacht clubs, several small shopping plazas put grocery and home essentials within reach, and four-star Italian restaurants serve excellent meals. Plus, housing styles that vary from

  • Average Value

    $742K

  • List Price

    $408K - $1.6M

  • For Sale

    Homes For Sale

    41 Listings

  Great Kills

Showing Results 1 - 25, Page 1 of 2