Section Image

Erica Mayfield

5.0stars, 8 Reviews
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
23 Closed Sales
$7.6M Total Value
$164.5K - $1M Price Range
$330.9K Average Price
Prior 5 years

About Erica

Family is everything to me and that’s exactly how I approach real estate.

Finding the right home isn’t just about bedrooms, bathrooms, or square footage. It’s about how a space fits your life, your routines, your memories, and the people you love most. It’s where your everyday moments happen, the busy mornings, the quiet nights, the holidays, and everything in between. Helping you find that kind of home is what truly matters to me.

As a mom of two, I understand firsthand how important it is to find a place that truly works for your family not just today, but as life grows and changes. I know what it feels like to want the right neighborhood, the right layout, and that sense of comfort when you walk through the door and think, “this feels like us.”

I’ve called Fishers home for 19 years and have been part of the Hamilton County community for over 20. This is where I’ve built my life and raised my family, but my experience doesn’t stop here. I’ve had the opportunity to help clients buy and sell homes throughout the surrounding areas as well, and I’m always ready to go where my clients need me.

For buyers, I’m here to make the process feel clear, supported, and a lot less overwhelming. From your first showing to the closing table, I’ll guide you through each step helping you understand the market, write strong offers, and feel confident in your decisions.

For sellers, I focus on helping your home stand out and shine. From pricing strategy and preparation, to marketing and negotiations, I approach every detail with care. My goal isn’t just to sell your home it’s to help you move forward smoothly and successfully into your next chapter.
What matters most to me is how you feel throughout the process. I believe in being honest, approachable, and truly present. You’ll never feel like just another transaction. I care deeply about the people I work with and the trust they place in me.

Real estate is more than a job for me, it’s a way to serve families during some of the biggest moments in their lives. Whether you're buying your first home, selling a place full of memories, or making your next move, I’m here to walk alongside you every step of the way.

If you’re thinking about buying or selling, have questions, or just want to talk through your options, I’d love to connect.

Let’s find the place that feels like hom
Home Types: House, Lot/Land, Condo
Years of Experience: 5

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Total Deals
4
Total Value
$1,806,000
Average Sale Price
$451,500
Price Range
$176K - $1M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
3
Total Value
$1,085,500
Average Sale Price
$361,833
Price Range
$200K - $481K

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Total Deals
7
Total Value
$2,798,000
Average Sale Price
$399,714
Price Range
$176K - $1M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
5
Total Value
$1,596,339
Average Sale Price
$319,268
Price Range
$165K - $481K

Seller Deals

Total Deals
8
Total Value
$3,299,850
Average Sale Price
$412,481
Price Range
$176K - $1M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
15
Total Value
$4,310,744
Average Sale Price
$287,383
Price Range
$76K - $481K

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Erica's Listings and Deals

Other Experience

First Time Home Buyers, Investments, Luxury Homes, Military Families, New Construction

Erica's Reviews

5.0stars, 8 Reviews

2/29/24Jeremy Miller

Google Review

Erica deserves 100 stars! We recently closed on our dream home, and it was an absolute pleasure working with her. From the start, Erica showcased unparalleled knowledge and passion for real estate.

She made the entire home-buying process seamless and stress-free. Erica's commitment to communication stood out – always prompt, addressing every concern, and keeping us well-informed at every stage.

What sets Erica apart is not just her professionalism, but her genuine dedication to client satisfaction. She guided us through the complexities, ensuring we understood each step and felt confident in our decisions.

Personable and approachable, Erica felt like a friend on this journey. She took the time to understand our preferences, providing tailored recommendations. If you're looking for a knowledgeable, dedicated, and friendly real estate agent, Erica is the one.

Thank you, Erica, for helping us find our dream home!

2/29/24David M

Google Review

Let me tell you how a visit to the Fishers farmers market changed my life. I was just walking around with my hubby and talking to everyone who had a booth. I saw this adorable woman sitting there with real estate cards. I asked her for a card and that we just moved into town and will be looking in the next year. She even invited us to a firefighter event they were sponsoring or her fire fighter husband 😍 was sponsoring I couldn’t remember. Not even three months later I sent her an email letting her know we were ready to start looking. Erica was very professional and patience on what we were looking for. She gave us her honest opinion on things and made the process so smooth. I later on asked her if she even got any leads that day from having a booth she said “no” until I got a hold of her. We just closed on our wonderful 3,200sq ft house that we got for a steal of a deal. It was fun countering offers. It didn’t matter that the deal was around $400k she got it done. Another great thing is she will be our realtor for life. We will be purchasing more homes for investments. I bet she didn’t except this at all when she first met me. She did say she felt good vibes during our interaction. If you are a spiritual person and feel good vibes follow your intuition and choose her. It was fun going from house to house in the snow. Sorry for talking a lot but that’s just me. Also Erica is good at conversation as she is showing the house.

9/7/23Kailee Gross

Google Review

Erica was awesome! Would definitely recommend to family and friends!!

Agent License: Indiana #21002287
Agent Photo

Erica Mayfield