Newest Homes for Sale in Theresa, NY

Wow! How about some waterfront right on the Indian River? Yep, walk down the hill of your property and enter into your level oasis right on the river. Now let's go into this home with 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths. Yep, you read that right too! How about 4 nice sized bedrooms and 2 full baths, one on the main floor, and with laundry! This house has a nice sized living room combo set up and a wood

Kirk Gilchrist Listing by Bridgeview Real Estate

Triplex located in the heat of Theresa currently generating $2,750/month in rent. Opportunity exist to increase rents to market! Current owner made many investments in the property post purchase including new paint job, exterior stairs being rebuilt, two total unit makeovers with paint, flooring and some appliances. Additionally secured reliable tenant base. This one checks all the boxes! Cash

Courtney Thomas Listing by Marble Key Realty LLC

Rare investment opportunity in the heart of Theresa offering exceptional income potential and flexible use options! The property features three separate units, including two in the main house and a private third unit above the barn, ideal for added privacy or supplemental income. Each unit includes in-unit laundry, and the property has a past rental history. Making this the perfect opportunity

Vivian Santos Listing by NNY Homes Inc

Discover this special blend of flora, fauna and fishing along the pristine waters of Butterfield Lake. This extraordinary property offers an rarely-offered retreat accessible only by boat, ensuring ultimate levels of privacy and tranquility experienced in very few areas of the north east. Nestled among nearly 150 acres of lush woodlands the wooded stand features a charming beaver pond, with an

Timothy Kent Whitetail Properties Real Estate

Newly renovated 4-family house on a large corner lot in Theresa. This house underwent a full interior and exterior renovation in 2024 at a cost of $148,500. There are three 2-bedroom apartments and a 1-bedroom all returning excellent market rate rents. The tenants pay all utilities except for sewer and water. Thee is a coin-op laundry available for the tenants, which provides additional income.

Robert Morris Listing by Howard Hanna Real Estate

ACCESSED EXCLUSIVELY BY WATERCRAFT the run across Butterfield Lake slows everything down. The sound of the motor fades, as the shoreline comes into view, and the world left behind fades with only the sounds of loons and the water lapping on almost 2,800 feet of shoreline. There is no road leading here—only a huge body of water, and the quiet that comes with separation. A soft, welcoming edge at

Timothy Kent Listing by Whitetail Properties Real Estate, LLC

2 furnished lakefront cottages on Hyde Lake-A Summer Paradise! Discover the perfect summer escape with two charming cottages nestled side by side on the beautiful lake! Each cottage features an open floor plan with 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom, offering a cozy and inviting retreat with breathtaking views of the lake and stunning sunsets right from your spacious deck. Whether you’re looking to boat or

Cathy Garlock Listing by Garlock Realty

Beautiful large 5.20-acre lot with electric, new well and septic. Also, there is an 8-to-10-foot all graveled road down to the water's edge that you could drive your 4-wheeler or golf cart. The boat launch is located right across the lake from this property. Don't miss this picturesque spot to build your dream home or seasonal cottage.

Lori Turgeon Listing by Garlock Realty

Rare opportunity to own a stunning 11.7 acre wooded property with sweeping views of Butterfield Lake, located near Alexandra Bay. This unique offering combines privacy, acreage, and direct waterfront access, perfect for creating your dream home or seasonal escape. the property features approximately 355 feet of waterfront, complete with stairs leading down to the shoreline, making it easy to

Amy Jo Thomas Listing by Front Porch Realty

Discover the perfect blend of privacy and natural beauty with this stunning 4 acre wooded lot with 282 feet of waterfront, overlooking picturesque Butterfield Lake. Nestled among abundant trees, this serene property offers peaceful water views and the ideal setting to build your dream home, or seasonal getaway. Enjoy the tranquility of nature while still being just a short drive from the charming

Amy Jo Thomas Listing by Front Porch Realty

Just over 2 acres of raw, untamed ground set in a quiet, natural area. This property is loaded with thick cover and holds plenty of wildlife, making it a solid spot for hunting or getting off the grid for a while.If you’re looking for a place to track game, scout, or just spend time in the woods without being bothered, this land gets it done. It’s private, peaceful, and has the kind of

Robert Adams Listing by Lake Ontario Realty, LLC

Spring has sprung! Discover an incredible opportunity to own 44 acres of beautiful, versatile land within the Village of Theresa. The land offers multiple buildable lots, making it ideal for a savvy investor or someone looking to create a private family compound. Essential utilities are readily available, with electric and water hookup availability directly on Morgan Street, simplifying any

Kaitlin Delles Listing by Marble Key Realty LLC

13+ Acres on Route 37N! Conveniently located close to I81 and Theresa/Redwood, the parcel is wide, level, & clear with almost 400' of road frontage divided between 2 stretches. Contact an agent today for details.

Stephen Gleason Listing by NNY Homes Inc

Discover your year-round escape on the Indian River! Nestled on a two stunning Indian River waterfront lots, this delightful 2-bedroom, 2-bath retreat is the perfect four-season sanctuary. An airy, flowing layout connects the kitchen, dining, and living areas into one welcoming space made for relaxing and gathering. The roof was replaced within the last 3 years, giving you peace of mind from day

Robert Gardner Listing by Bridgeview Real Estate

Welcome Home to Beautiful Hyde Lake! Ready for lake life? This fully furnished three-season cottage is ready for you—just pack your bags and head to camp! This charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath home has so much to offer, including a spacious living area with a cozy fireplace to keep you warm on those cool evenings by the lake. The property also includes a one-stall garage that could easily be converted

Melinda Countryman Listing by Lake Homes Realty LLC

FIXER-UPPER OPPORTUNITY NEAR FORT DRUM Ready for your next renovation project? This spacious 4-5 bedroom, 2-bath home is waiting for the right contractor or investor to bring it to life Featuring high ceilings and open layout, ready for the sheetrock. Also includes large storage garage for vehicles & storage. Located close to in land lakes- perfect for outdoor enthusiasts. Call now for details &

Cathy Garlock Listing by Garlock Realty

Discover the perfect escape on this stunning 2.0-acre parcel nestled along the beautiful Lake of the Woods. Surrounded by mature trees and the peaceful sounds of nature, this wooded lot offers the privacy and serenity you’ve been searching for. Located in an area with year-round residences, this property provides the flexibility to create either a peaceful seasonal retreat or a comfortable

Amanda Miller Listing by Lake Ontario Realty, LLC

Looking for the perfect spot to build your new home? Check out this 1.1-acre building lot located on a quiet country road! This parcel offers plenty of space and privacy with room for a house, garage, and outdoor enjoyment. Just 20 minutes to Fort Drum and Watertown, making it ideal for commuters. Country setting, yet close to amenities. Don’t miss this great opportunity—call today!

Teresa Caprara Listing by North Star Real Estate & Property Management

Here is the opportunity to own your own small, remote island on Grass Lake. This property can be used to construct a camp and other recreational activities such as fishing, kayaking or duck hunting. You must use a 10 HP motorboat or canoe to access the island.

Ronald Lassiter Listing by North Star Real Estate & Property Management

Amanda Kingsbury Listing by Grey Arrow Realty, Inc.

Check out this great spot with waterfront on the Indian River. This would be the perfect place for a house or a camp. The river is perfect for canoes and kayaks and also some good fishing. Call to take a look today!

Desiree Dercole Listing by Bridgeview Real Estate