Recently Sold Cincinnatus, NY Homes

/2
$27,500

Sold May 20, 2026

5317 New York 221, Willet, NY 13863
- Land
- 6.83 Acres
- $4,026 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 8 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Pamela Cullip Listing by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty

5317 New York 221, Willet, NY 13863
/2
$380,000

Sold Dec 17, 2025

2779 Maricle Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,300 Sq Ft
- Built 2006
Last Sold Summary
- 24% Below List Price
- $165/SF
- 146 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $400,137

Last Listing Agent Carey Smith Listing by EXIT Realty Homeward Bound

2779 Maricle Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$175,000

Sold Jan 22, 2026

2832 Cincinnatus Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,728 Sq Ft
- Built 1920
Last Sold Summary
- 8% Below List Price
- $101/SF
- 110 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $186,426

Last Listing Agent Donna Standish Listing by Yaman Real Estate

2832 Cincinnatus Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$283,000

Sold Aug 29, 2025

3202 County Route 2, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,568 Sq Ft
- Built 2018
Last Sold Summary
- 19% Below List Price
- $180/SF
- 213 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $302,376

Last Listing Agent Donna Standish Listing by Yaman Real Estate

3202 County Route 2, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$135,000

Sold Nov 19, 2025

2274 E Freetown Texas Valley Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,012 Sq Ft
- Built 1970
Last Sold Summary
- $133/SF
- 15 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $173,320

Last Listing Agent John Aspinwall Listing by Hage Real Estate

2274 E Freetown Texas Valley Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/46
$275,000

Sold Oct 10, 2025

5840 Baldwin Corners Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 5 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,368 Sq Ft
- Built 1900
Last Sold Summary
- 10% Above List Price
- $116/SF
- 52 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $280,850

Last Listing Agent Shannon Dumond EXIT REALTY HOMEWARD BOUND

5840 Baldwin Corners Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$23,900

Sold Jul 19, 2025

Lot 7 German Rd, Willet, NY 13863
- Land
- 6.6 Acres
- $3,621 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 323 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Chris Palmer Listing by United Country Palmer Real Estate, Inc

Lot 7 German Rd, Willet, NY 13863
/2
$98,000

Sold Oct 31, 2025

2936 Center Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- Land
- 12.39 Acres
- $7,910 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 11% Below List Price
- 73 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $99,228

Last Listing Agent Joanne Sweeney Listing by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty

2936 Center Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$379,000

Sold Mar 09, 2026

4280 Freetown Cross Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 4 Beds
- 2,640 Sq Ft
- Built 2019
Last Sold Summary
- 3% Below List Price
- $144/SF
- 22 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $384,096

Last Listing Agent Ashley Warfield Listing by Yaman Real Estate

4280 Freetown Cross Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$25,900

Sold Oct 30, 2025

Lot 2 German Rd, Willet, NY 13863
- Land
- 5.22 Acres
- $4,962 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 379 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Chris Palmer Listing by United Country Palmer Real Estate, Inc

Lot 2 German Rd, Willet, NY 13863
/2
$217,000

Sold Aug 11, 2025

5754 Cheningo Solon Pond Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,414 Sq Ft
- Built 1974
Last Sold Summary
- 1% Above List Price
- $153/SF
- 8 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $231,086

Last Listing Agent Jeanette Pursell Listing by Yaman Real Estate

5754 Cheningo Solon Pond Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$62,000

Sold Nov 19, 2025

0 Kostenko Sutton Rd, Pitcher, NY 13801
- Land
- 16.1 Acres
- $3,851 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 22% Below List Price
- 237 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent John Cammarata Listing by Howard Hanna

0 Kostenko Sutton Rd, Pitcher, NY 13801
/2
$130,000

Sold Jul 15, 2025

5690 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 960 Sq Ft
- Built 1991
Last Sold Summary
- $135/SF
- 35 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $117,326

Last Listing Agent Listing Comparative4 UNKNOWN NON MEMBER

5690 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$185,000

Sold Feb 06, 2026

3946 Suarez Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,452 Sq Ft
- Built 1985
Last Sold Summary
- 34% Below List Price
- $127/SF
- 164 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $193,098

Last Listing Agent Linda Fox Listing by Fox Properties and Real Estate

3946 Suarez Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$28,000

Sold Oct 08, 2025

Lot 4 German Rd, Willet, NY 13863
- Land
- 6.6 Acres
- $4,242 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 6% Below List Price
- 359 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Chris Palmer Listing by United Country Palmer Real Estate, Inc

Lot 4 German Rd, Willet, NY 13863
/2
$177,500

Sold May 27, 2026

4339 May Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,440 Sq Ft
- Built 1974
Last Sold Summary
- 1% Below List Price
- $123/SF
- 176 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $181,000

Last Listing Agent Pamela Williams Listing by Yaman Real Estate

4339 May Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$26,900

Sold Dec 08, 2025

Lot 3 German Rd, Willet, NY 13863
- Land
- 6.5 Acres
- $4,138 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 10% Below List Price
- 410 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Chris Palmer Listing by United Country Palmer Real Estate, Inc

Lot 3 German Rd, Willet, NY 13863
/2
$420,000

Sold Dec 24, 2025

2254 Maricle Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 4 Beds
- 5 Baths
- 2,688 Sq Ft
- Built 1980
Last Sold Summary
- 19% Below List Price
- $156/SF
- 79 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $421,567

Last Listing Agent Amy Schenck Listing by Yaman Real Estate

2254 Maricle Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/22
$120,000

Sold Sep 26, 2025

2879 E View Terrace, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 5 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,832 Sq Ft
- Built 1965
Last Sold Summary
- 25% Below List Price
- $66/SF
- 98 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $156,874

Last Listing Agent Derek Schoenfeldt HOWARD HANNA

2879 E View Terrace, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$166,000

Sold Jun 11, 2025

2953 E Freetown Texas Valley Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 1 Bed
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,008 Sq Ft
- Built 1990
Last Sold Summary
- 4% Above List Price
- $165/SF
- 15 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Shuryl Menapace Listing by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty

2953 E Freetown Texas Valley Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$311,000

Sold May 04, 2026

3541 Preston Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,402 Sq Ft
- Built 1996
Last Sold Summary
- 9% Below List Price
- $129/SF
- 40 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $314,719

Last Listing Agent Jenna Davi Listing by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty

3541 Preston Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$190,700

Sold Jul 08, 2025

2415 State Route 26, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,680 Sq Ft
- Built 1947
Last Sold Summary
- 2% Below List Price
- $114/SF
- 22 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $193,796

Last Listing Agent Nicole Wynn Listing by Yaman Real Estate

2415 State Route 26, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$160,400

Sold Jan 06, 2026

2879 Cincinnatus Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,108 Sq Ft
- Built 1940
Last Sold Summary
- $76/SF
- 5 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $175,224

Last Listing Agent Jeanette Pursell Listing by Yaman Real Estate

2879 Cincinnatus Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$195,000

Sold Dec 08, 2025

2918 New York 41, Freetown, NY 13040
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,184 Sq Ft
- Built 1954
Last Sold Summary
- 9% Above List Price
- $165/SF
- 17 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Roger McKee Listing by McKee Real Estate

2918 New York 41, Freetown, NY 13040
/20
$30,000

Sold May 08, 2026

3655 Jordan Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- Land
- 2.5 Acres
- $12,000 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 14% Below List Price
- 102 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $35,142

Last Listing Agent William Lidell YAMAN REAL ESTATE

3655 Jordan Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$150,000

Sold Aug 14, 2025

4062 Stramba Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- Land
- 22 Acres
- $6,818 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 96 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Pamela Williams Listing by Yaman Real Estate

4062 Stramba Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/14
$90,000

Sold Feb 19, 2026

0 County Road 6, German, NY 13040
- Land
- 35 Acres
- $2,571 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 36% Below List Price
- 573 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent William Carey Win Morrison Realty

0 County Road 6, German, NY 13040
/2
$230,000

Sold Dec 23, 2025

4743 Clark Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 3,000 Sq Ft
- Built 1993
Last Sold Summary
- 18% Below List Price
- $77/SF
- 103 Days On Market
Current Estimated Value $260,315

Last Listing Agent Jason Hage Listing by Hage Real Estate

4743 Clark Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
/2
$200,000

Sold Oct 17, 2025

0 Telephone Rd Unit S1616239, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
- Land
- 69 Acres
- $2,899 per Acre
Last Sold Summary
- 5% Below List Price
- 34 Days On Market
Last Listing Agent Jerry Hartnett Listing by Hartnett Realty Solutions

0 Telephone Rd Unit S1616239, Cincinnatus, NY 13040

New York Cortland County Cincinnatus

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average home price in Cincinnatus, NY?

Homes for sale in Cincinnatus, NY have an average home price of $231,981.

What is the average time to sell a house in Cincinnatus, NY?

The houses for sale in Cincinnatus, NY spend an average of 86 days on the market.

What is the number of active homes for sale in Cincinnatus, NY?

There is 1 active home for sale in Cincinnatus, NY.

How many homes have sold over the last 12 months in Cincinnatus, NY?

10 homes have sold in Cincinnatus, NY over the last 12 months.

Home Prices in Cincinnatus, NY

The median home sale price in Cincinnatus, NY is $184,100, up 24% year-over-year. Homes in Cincinnatus sell in 86 days on average, compared to the national average of 58 days.

Home Price Trends

Median Sale Price $184,100	Median Single Family Sale Price $184,100
Average Price Per Sq Ft $102	Number of Homes for Sale 1
Last 12 months Home Sales 10	Months of Supply 1.20
Median List Price $195,000	Median Change From 1st List Price 5%
Median Home Sale Price YoY Change 24%

How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home

Cincinnatus Types of Homes for Sale

More About Living in Cincinnatus

Homes for Sale in Nearby Zip Codes

Homes for Sale in Nearby Cities

Homes for Sale in Nearby Counties

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage